Consolidation of several legal entities, intercompany and transfer pricing
Combining group reporting (brand, retail, production, sole proprietors and limited companies) into one without double-counting intra-group sales. The owner sees the group’s real profit and debt, decides at what price entities sell goods to each other, and shows the bank a single picture.
Why this document
When a brand sells goods to its own retail entity, one company records revenue and the other a cost, yet the group has gained no money. Without eliminating such turnover the group looks bigger and more profitable than it is. Consolidation removes double counting and shows which entity earns and which does not. The price inside the group decides where profit lands, so it must be justified: the tax authority may check that it resembles a market price. A bank and an investor judge debt for the whole group, not for one company.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- Combining group reporting (brand, retail, production, sole proprietors and limited companies) into one without double-counting intra-group sales. The owner sees the group’s real profit and debt, decides at what price entities sell goods to each other, and shows the bank a single picture.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The group finance director or the holding chief accountant; monthly management consolidation, quarterly and annual for the bank and audit; to the owner a summary by group and by entity.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Statements are summed without eliminations → revenue and profit are overstated → eliminate intragroup revenue, settlements and unrealized profit. Intragroup balances do not match → consolidation does not close → reconciliation and signing of the register by both parties. Different accounting policies in entities → figures are not comparable → a single policy and template.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand in a group usually produces and sells wholesale, including to the group own stores. Intragroup shipments at RUB 2,300 (RUB 2,400 to external customers) create brand revenue that does not exist at group level and unrealized profit in retail stock. In the example 7,500 units for RUB 17.25 million, of which 30% remains in stock, unrealized profit of 2,475 thousand is excluded from group EBITDA.
- Retail
- A retailer in a group buys from the brand at the transfer price and shows it as a purchase; in consolidation its purchases from the brand are eliminated together with the brand revenue and the remaining stock is restated to group cost. The intragroup receivable and payable (2,595 thousand) are eliminated on both sides. A separate question is a retailer on a sole-trader or USN regime: its revenue and taxes follow another regime, and consolidation runs in management accounting.
What it consists of
Why consolidate
- Without it group revenue and profit are overstated: the same goods are counted at the producer, the retailer and the intermediary. Stock on the balance sheet contains profit the group has not yet earned.
- The group shows the real debt burden: loans of different entities are summed, while intragroup loans are eliminated.
What is eliminated
- Intragroup revenue and the corresponding cost or purchase (one operation, two entities).
- Intragroup settlements: receivables of one entity and payables of another; loans and interest on them.
- Unrealized profit in stock: the share of intragroup supplies remaining in the recipient stock × the seller margin; it reduces stock and profit and creates a deferred tax asset.
- Dividends within the group and investments in subsidiaries (in full consolidation).
Consolidation procedure
- A single accounting policy and chart of accounts; a single currency and closing dates; a line mapping table; an intragroup transaction register signed by both parties.
- Summing entity statements, then an eliminations column, then the consolidated result; a check: the balance sheet ties, intragroup balances are equal on both sides.
Transfer pricing
- The transfer price is the price of an intragroup deal. It affects in which entity profit remains, and so taxes, managers incentives and the loan terms of each entity.
- Methods: the comparable market price (the price to external customers adjusted for volume and terms), cost plus (cost + an agreed markup), resale minus (retail price minus the retailer margin).
- Practice: document the method and compare yearly with the price to external customers; a deviation within reason (in the example −4.2%) with an explanation (volume, no bonuses, logistics).
- For tax control of deals between related parties there are special rules in the Tax Code (controlled transactions and documentation); applicability, thresholds and documentation should be checked with a tax adviser: they are not in the norm register, not verified.
Brand and retailer: what is computed differently
- Brand: a brand in a group sells wholesale to its own retail at a transfer price: its revenue and the profit in the retail stock are eliminated, brand royalties inside the group are eliminated the same way.
- Retailer: the group retailer shows the purchase from the brand as cost: on consolidation the purchase is eliminated, the stock balance is revalued to group cost, intragroup payables are eliminated on both sides.
Brand: how the document differs and what to add
- Brand: the brand in the group is the supplier: intragroup shipment to the retailer goes at a transfer price that must be at market level.
- Brand: revenue from the group to the retailer is RUB 17.25 million at RUB 2,300 per unit against external wholesale at RUB 2,400: the price difference is justified by volume and terms.
- Brand: the brand’s cost on intragroup units is eliminated together with revenue; brand profit stays in the group only after the goods are sold to an external customer.
- Brand: the brand receivable from the retailer (RUB 2.595 million) is eliminated from consolidated receivables and reconciled with the recipient’s payable.
- Brand: the brand reports as a separate group segment: revenue, margin and stock by external and internal channels.
- Brand: license and royalty payments between brand and group entities are part of transfer pricing and are eliminated.
- Brand: the brand pays corporate income tax on its own statements, the group only adjusts the consolidated ones: the tax effect of unrealized profit is shown separately.
- Brand: with several tax regimes (the general regime at the brand and the simplified one at other entities) consolidation is supplemented with a table of differences.
Retailer: how the document differs and what to add
- Retailer: the retailer in the group is the recipient: intragroup purchases form part of the goods flow and limit the choice of brands.
- Retailer: part of the intragroup batch (30%) is in the retailer’s stock at the report date: unrealized profit of RUB 2.475 million is removed from group stock.
- Retailer: retailer payables to the brand are eliminated on consolidation; if intragroup payment terms are longer than external ones, this is hidden financing of the retailer by the brand and it is disclosed.
- Retailer: the retailer records the purchase at the transfer price, so its margin and the brand margin within the group depend on the internal price: the sum does not change, the distribution does.
- Retailer: the retailer often carries network rent and staff, so in consolidation the retail segment shows operating leverage that the brand does not.
- Retailer: brand stock in retailer stores and returns within the group are counted once in group inventory, not twice.
- Retailer: the retailer’s loyalty program on the brand’s goods: whether point redemption is compensated within the group; the rule is written into the contract and reflected in consolidation.
- Retailer: segment reporting shows retail separately: revenue by stores and online, rent and network contribution; this is the basis for decisions on closing weak points.
How to read the result and which decisions follow
- Group consolidated margin is below the sum of entity margins by the amount of unrealized profit: do not compare the group with the market before intragroup sales are excluded; decide on the internal price at group level, not entity level.
- Mutual balances do not agree at the date: stop the period close and reconcile the statements; a gap above a few thousand roubles is almost always different recognition dates or VAT.
- The internal price is above the external wholesale price by more than the policy tolerance: a tax and corporate risk; justify by volume and terms or return to the market level.
Control checks
- Group revenue equals the sum of entities less intragroup sales (206,665 + 510,159 − 17,250 = 699,574).
- Group profit equals the sum of entity profits less unrealized profit plus the tax effect; the group balance sheet agrees after eliminations.
- Typical traps: intragroup VAT shown in revenue, elimination of revenue only without cost, unrealized profit computed on the whole batch, controlled transactions without documentation.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Statements of each entity for the period | P&L, balance sheet, cash flow in a single accounting policy and template |
| Intragroup transaction register | party, contract, date, amount, VAT, settlement balance, units |
| Group goods held by recipients | quantity and cost of goods supplied within the group, at period end |
| Contracts and the transfer pricing method | price, method, review date, comparison with external prices |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Draw the group map: entities, roles, tax regimes, ownership shares, intragroup flows.
- Step 2: Introduce a single accounting policy and report template for all entities; close dates equally.
- Step 3: Collect the intragroup transaction register, sign it by both parties; reconcile settlement balances.
- Step 4: Sum entity statements into one table (line × entity).
- Step 5: Eliminate intragroup revenue and purchases, settlements and loans.
- Step 6: Compute unrealized profit in stock and adjust stock, profit and deferred tax.
- Step 7: Check the balance sheet and end-to-end identities: assets equal liabilities and equity, eliminations are symmetric.
- Step 8: Show the result in two cuts: by group and by entity; EBITDA, debt and net debt to EBITDA separately.
- Step 9: Check transfer prices: compare with prices to external customers, document the method and reasons for deviations.
- Step 10: Once a year review the structure: is each entity needed, how tax burden and risks change.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Unrealized profit in stock | UP = Intragroup supplies × Share in stock × Seller margin | Seller margin = (price − cost) ÷ price; the share in stock is by quantity. |
| Consolidated revenue | Group revenue = Σ Entity revenue − Intragroup revenue | Take intragroup revenue from the register, not from an estimate. |
| Consolidated EBITDA | Group EBITDA = Σ Entity EBITDA − Unrealized profit | The realized part returns to EBITDA when the retailer sells the goods. |
| Deferred tax | DTA = UP × Corporate income tax rate | The tax in the seller entity was paid on profit the group has not yet received: a temporary difference. |
| Transfer price deviation | Dev., % = (Internal price ÷ External price − 1) × 100 | Compare at comparable volumes and payment terms. |
Formulas in notation
- Group revenue
Rev_G = Σ_i Rev_i − IC
Rev_i is revenue of entity i, IC is revenue from intragroup sales; the same amount is eliminated from the recipient’s cost.- Unrealized profit
UP = IC · h · m
h is the share of the intragroup batch still in the recipient’s stock, m is the supplier’s gross margin on that batch; UP is removed from stock and profit.- Tax effect
TE = UP · t
t is the corporate income tax rate; a deferred tax asset is recognized when preparing consolidated statements.- Mutual balances
AR_IC = (IC + VAT_IC) · d / 365
d is the intragroup payment term; the supplier’s receivable and the recipient’s payable are mutually eliminated.
Worked example
Consolidation of the brand and the retailer in a group: summing, eliminations and the result, RUB thousand
| Line | Brand | Retailer | Sum | Eliminations | Consolidated |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 206,665 | 510,159 | 716,824 | −17,250 | 699,574 |
| Cost of sales (negative) | −90,222 | −263,758 | −353,980 | 14,775 | −339,205 |
| Gross profit before reserve | 116,443 | 246,401 | 362,844 | −2,475 | 360,369 |
| EBITDA | 35,048 | 34,800 | 69,848 | −2,475 | 67,373 |
| Net profit | 21,051 | 11,662 | 32,713 | −1,856 | 30,857 |
| BALANCE SHEET AT YEAR END | |||||
| Cash | 14,351 | 1,766 | 16,117 | 0 | 16,117 |
| Receivables | 22,533 | 3,410 | 25,943 | −2,595 | 23,348 |
| Net inventory | 55,765 | 99,722 | 155,487 | −2,475 | 153,012 |
| Advances and fixed assets | 23,677 | 71,443 | 95,120 | 0 | 95,120 |
| Deferred tax asset on unrealized profit | 0 | 0 | 0 | 619 | 619 |
| Total assets | 116,326 | 176,341 | 292,667 | −4,451 | 288,216 |
| Payables | 9,781 | 54,579 | 64,360 | −2,595 | 61,765 |
| Loan | 24,000 | 50,000 | 74,000 | 0 | 74,000 |
| Other liabilities | 7,014 | 17,100 | 24,114 | 0 | 24,114 |
| Equity | 75,531 | 54,662 | 130,193 | −1,856 | 128,337 |
| Check: assets − liabilities − equity | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| TRANSFER PRICE | |||||
| Brand price to the affiliated retailer, RUB | 2,300 | ||||
| Price to external wholesale customers, RUB | 2,400 | ||||
| Internal price deviation from external, % | −4.2 | ||||
| Brand gross margin on internal sales, % | 47.8 | ||||
| Brand gross margin on external sales, % | 50 | ||||
| INTRAGROUP LOAN (illustrative, not from Models B and R; eliminated in full) | |||||
| Loan from the brand to the retailer, RUB thousand (a brand asset and a retailer liability) | 3,000 | ||||
| Interest on the loan at 14%, RUB thousand (brand income and retailer expense) | 420 | ||||
Example condition: the brand sold 7,500 units to the group retailer at RUB 2,300 (RUB 17.25 million), and the retailer holds 30% of these units at year end. Unrealized profit 2,475 (brand margin on internal sales 47.8%); the tax effect 619; the intragroup receivable and payable of 2,595 each. The balance check in the eliminations column is zero: assets, liabilities and equity are eliminated symmetrically. The retailer purchases from the brand are included in its cost of sales; this is a simplification of the example. Link to the models: 7,500 units at RUB 2,300 are 9.4% of the brand units in Model B (80,000) and 6.3% of the retailer purchases in Model R (272,152): Model R computes cost of sales as a share of price, so the elimination is shown as a separate illustrative operation, not as a Model R line. An intragroup loan of 3,000 at 14% (interest 420) is eliminated entirely: the loan and interest on both sides, the consolidated result does not change; brand royalties and dividends inside the group are eliminated the same way. Transfer pricing rules for related parties (controlled transactions) were not checked against the Tax Code text: check thresholds and documentation with a tax adviser.
Figures
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Brand revenue | +206,665 | 206,665 |
| Retailer revenue | +510,159 | 716,824 |
| Sum of entities | — | 716,824 |
| Intragroup shipment | −17,250 | 699,574 |
| Group revenue | — | 699,574 |
Group revenue: from the sum of entities to consolidated. The brand’s intragroup shipment to the retailer is eliminated from group revenue, otherwise it is counted twice.
Intragroup flows and eliminations. What is eliminated on consolidation: revenue and cost of the shipment, unrealized profit in the recipient’s stock and mutual balances.
- Brand: shipment 17,250 → Retailer: 30% still in stock; Eliminate revenue and cost 17,250 / 9,000
- Retailer: 30% still in stock → Brand: shipment 17,250; Unrealized profit 2,475
- Eliminate revenue and cost 17,250 / 9,000 → Group statements
- Unrealized profit 2,475 → Group statements
- Group statements
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: intragroup supplies are seasonal and unrealized profit peaks at season end when the retailer holds stock; compute at the end of each quarter.
- Footwear
- Footwear: production is often in a separate entity (a factory), so a chain of three links and two eliminations; the price per pair in the chain is documented separately.
- Accessories
- Accessories: brand rights are often in a separate entity: an intragroup royalty is another intragroup transaction eliminated on consolidation.
- Kids
- Kids: certificates and responsibility for conformity are tied to a specific entity (manufacturer or importer); this affects group structure and contracts.
- Men
- Menswear: no consolidation specifics; differences come from the format and channels.
- Women
- Womenswear: no consolidation specifics; the seasonality of collections and drops affects the size of unrealized profit, as with apparel.
Common mistakes
- Statements are summed without eliminations → revenue and profit are overstated → eliminate intragroup revenue, settlements and unrealized profit.
- Intragroup balances do not match → consolidation does not close → reconciliation and signing of the register by both parties.
- Different accounting policies in entities → figures are not comparable → a single policy and template.
- A transfer price chosen “for taxes” with no documents → risk of claims and dispute → a method and comparison with external prices.
- The bank is shown summed EBITDA without unrealized profit → trust is lost → compute covenants on consolidated data.
- The tax regime of an entity (USN, general, sole trader) is ignored → the group tax burden is computed wrongly → compute taxes per entity, then combine.
Russian specifics
- Consolidated statutory statements for organizations are defined by federal standards and the accounting law; check the obligation and the scope for your group; management consolidation is not regulated by law. Rule: Law 402-FZ of 06.12.2011: Federal Law of 06.12.2011 No. 402-FZ on accounting (rule check not completed).
- Splitting a business between several entities and sole traders for a tax regime (USN, VAT) is controlled by the tax authorities: in a group each entity needs a business purpose and real functions; USN and VAT thresholds are set by the Tax Code and amending laws (see Law 228-FZ on the VAT threshold). The statement about control of business splitting does not rest on a read norm text: not checked. Rule: Law 228-FZ of 04.07.2026: Federal Law of 04.07.2026 No. 228-FZ (income threshold under Art. 145 of the Tax Code) (rule check not completed).
- Intragroup loans and interest: check the contract terms and the arm length of the rate separately; interest in tax expenses is rationed (the rule is not in the register, not verified).
- A brand license within the group (royalty) is formalized under part four of the Civil Code (Arts. 1235, 1237); registration and terms affect taxes and consolidation. Rule: Civil Code part 4: Civil Code, part four (Arts. 1232, 1235, 1237, 1486, 1491, 1515) (rule check not completed).