Syntha Lab RU

Tax regime and group structure: simplified, general, business splitting, limits

Compares the tax burden of regimes (simplified, general) and describes how to build a group of companies (brand, production, retail, sole proprietors) without signs of business splitting and within limits. The owner uses it to choose the regime and ownership structure, knowing where the saving is and where the risk of reassessment lies.

Contracts, tax, accounting Brand and retail Verified: 2026-11-14

Open interactively →

Why this document

The tax regime determines not only tax but also whom you can sell to: buyers on the general regime value input VAT, and crossing simplified-regime limits happens automatically. So the owner, the finance director and the tax lawyer read the document, and decide whether to stay on the simplified regime, move to the general one and split the business. Splitting without independent substance in each company is challenged by an audit and tax is reassessed. The structure is therefore built on real functions and business reasons, not on a wish to stay under a limit.

At a glance

What is this document and why is it needed?
Compares the tax burden of regimes (simplified, general) and describes how to build a group of companies (brand, production, retail, sole proprietors) without signs of business splitting and within limits. The owner uses it to choose the regime and ownership structure, knowing where the saving is and where the risk of reassessment lies.
Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
The owner and CFO with a tax adviser; reviewed when income grows, VAT changes and before creating new entities; regimes compared at least yearly.
What mistakes are the most common?
Splitting a business across stores to keep the simplified regime → assessment under Tax Code Art. 54.1 → a structure with business purpose. Choosing a regime by rate, not input VAT → overpayment → compare the full burden. Missed the VAT threshold → arrears and fines → monitor cumulative income.

For whom

Brand
Brand: production and wholesale (much input VAT under the general regime), marketing, trademark rights. Separate entities are often set up for the brand (rights), production and sales; each needs a business purpose.
Retail
Retailer: many stores, registers, rent, a high share of VAT-bearing purchases; under the simplified regime special VAT rates of 5 and 7%, under the general regime input VAT deduction. Splitting by store to keep the simplified regime is risky.

What it consists of

Regimes

  • General regime: corporate income tax (main rate 25%, Art. 284, 176-FZ) and 22% VAT with deduction; suits a high share of VAT-bearing purchases and large buyers.
  • Simplified “income” or “income minus expenses” (Arts. 346.18, 346.20): rates by region; VAT payer above the Art. 145 threshold (RUB 20 million, 228-FZ), at the general or a special rate; other limits (income, headcount): check the current text.
  • NPD (self-employed): by its law not suited to resale of purchased goods; small own-production has an income limit; not checked against the text.
  • Insurance contributions: a reduced SME tariff under Art. 427 subject to conditions (income share from listed activities, 104-FZ, order 4125-r, list content not checked).

Splitting and group structure

  • Tax benefit as the main purpose of a deal is not allowed: Tax Code Art. 54.1 (not checked against the text); splitting indicators: shared staff, warehouses, brand and accounting, income “cut” below limits.
  • Brand: A lawful structure: each entity has its own function (brand rights, production, retail), own resources and contracts at market prices (transfer pricing).

Choosing a regime: what matters to each side

  • Brand: with production and wholesale there is a lot of input VAT (fabric, factories, logistics, import): the general regime gives a deduction while on the simplified regime at a special rate there is none; large wholesale buyers need the deduction and expect an invoice with VAT.
  • Retailer: in retail the individual buyer does not use a deduction, so the regime is chosen by profitability: the lower the pre-tax margin the better the general regime with deduction; splitting a chain into entities to stay on the simplified regime is dangerous.
  • Brand: when spinning off an entity for the brand or rights, writes functions, resources and inter-company prices in advance; supports market-based pricing with a calculation.
  • Retailer: when opening stores in different regions checks regional simplified-tax rates and the headcount and income limits at the date of transition.

Control questions on the regime

  • What burden results under each regime on data of the last four quarters, and how does it change if revenue grows by a quarter?
  • Which limits on income, headcount and residual value are close to being exceeded, and when does the VAT obligation arise?
  • Does each group entity have independent functions, resources and market-priced contracts, and are the pricing calculations kept?

Brand and retailer: what differs in practice

  • Brand: with own production has more VAT-bearing purchases (fabric, trims, sewing services), which shifts the choice towards the general regime.
  • Brand: builds the group by function (design and rights, production, sales) and keeps transfer prices at market, otherwise the structure falls under Art. 54.1.
  • Brand: documents brand rights and royalties within the group by contracts and counts withholding tax and VAT on royalties.
  • Retailer: with several stores does not split the business for the simplified-regime limit: each entity needs its own activity, resources and business purpose.
  • Retailer: assesses the regime by margin: nearly all of a retailer purchases bear VAT, and corporate income tax is applied to gross margin.
  • Retailer: watches the simplified-regime limits on income, headcount and residual value and the moment when VAT arises.
  • Retailer: when selling through a marketplace counts tax on the fee and on revenue separately and checks which base enters the limit calculations.
  • Retailer: counts rent and payroll in the expenses of the income-minus-expenses regime, where they reduce the base, and not in the income regime.

How to read the result and what decisions follow

  • Compare the full burden including VAT as a percentage of revenue, not the rates: simplified 6% without deduction may be costlier than the general regime with a large VAT-bearing share.
  • The position of the break-even relative to your VAT-bearing share shows the safety margin: if the margin is under ten percentage points the regime is unstable.
  • Decision: the regime for next year, a review date, cumulative threshold control, consulting a tax specialist before changing the structure.

Where the data comes from

Data sourceFields
P&L and tax accountingrevenue, expenses, input VAT, payroll
Group structureentities, functions, assets, staff, contracts
Tax calendar and limitsthresholds, regional rates

How to build it step by step

  1. Step 1: Gather revenue, expenses and the VAT-bearing purchase share.
  2. Step 2: Compute the burden under the general, simplified income and income-minus-expenses regimes (see example).
  3. Step 3: Check limits and the date the VAT threshold is exceeded.
  4. Brand: Step 4: Consider buyers: large ones care about VAT deduction.
  5. Brand: Step 5: If a structure is needed, describe the functions and business purpose of each entity.
  6. Retailer: Step 6: Set transfer prices between entities and keep the calculations.
  7. Step 7: Discuss with a tax adviser before launch; review yearly.
  8. Brand: Step 8: Recompute the brand regime when entering large chains and when the import share grows: the input VAT deduction may outweigh the simplicity of the simplified regime.

Formulas

MeasureFormulasNote
General regime burdenT = 25% × (Income − Expenses) + Output VAT − Input VATExpenses excl. VAT; deduction subject to conditions.
Simplified income-minus-expenses burdenT = max(Rate × (Income − Expenses); 1% × Income) + Special VATMinimum tax under Art. 346.18; VAT without deduction.
Regime break-evenVAT-bearing purchase share at which general = simplifiedCompute in calculations regbreak, regime.
Margin threshold: simplified regime with 5% special VAT versus general regimeSimplified “income” 6% + VAT 5% = 11% of revenue excl. VAT; the general regime with VAT-bearing costs ≈ (25% + 22%) × (Revenue − Costs) = 47% × pre-tax profitEquality at a pre-tax margin of 11 / 47 ≈ 23% of revenue: below it the general regime is cheaper, above it the simplified regime; a simplified illustration (the simplified rate is regional, not all costs bear VAT): see the regime and taxburden calculations.

Formulas in notation

Simplified income minus expenses
T = max(t × (I − E); 1% × I) + special VAT
The minimum tax protects the budget at low profit; special-rate VAT without deduction. Example: RUB 14,250,000.
Break-even VAT-bearing share
s* = (25% × (I − E) + r × I − T_simp) / (r × E)
Above s* the general regime is better, below it the simplified one. For simplified 6%: 120% (illustrative rates).

Worked example

Revenue RUB 150 million excl. VAT, expenses RUB 105 million excl. VAT, 80% of expenses bear VAT; simplified rates 6% and 15% conditional (by region), simplified VAT 5%

RegimeIncome/corporate income tax, RUBVAT payable, RUBTotal, RUB% of revenue
General regime11,250,00014,520,00025,770,00017.2%
Simplified income 6% + VAT 5%9,000,0007,500,00016,500,00011.0%
Simplified income-minus-expenses 15% + VAT 5%6,750,0007,500,00014,250,0009.5%

Contributions and regional rates are excluded; with a different VAT-bearing share the ranking changes. The result shows the method, not a recommendation. Check limits and rates in the current Tax Code.

Figures

Tax burden under three regimes
Bar chart: General regime 11.3m, Simplified income 6% 9m, Simplified income minus expenses 15% 6.75m05m10m15m20m25m30mGeneral regimeGeneral regimeIncome or corporate income tax: 11.3mVAT payable: 14.5m25.8mSimplified income 6%Simplified income 6%Income or corporate income tax: 9mVAT payable: 7.5m16.5mSimplified income minus expenses 15%Simplified incomeminus expenses 15%Income or corporate income tax: 6.75mVAT payable: 7.5m14.3mRUB
  • Income or corporate income tax
  • VAT payable
Data as a table
MeasureIncome or corporate income taxVAT payable
General regime11.3m14.5m
Simplified income 6%9m7.5m
Simplified income minus expenses 15%6.75m7.5m

Tax burden under three regimes. Income or corporate income tax and VAT payable. Contributions and regional rates are excluded. Revenue RUB 150,000,000 and expenses RUB 105,000,000 excl. VAT, 80% of expenses bear VAT; simplified rates conditional, simplified VAT 5%. The result shows the method, not a recommendation.

General and simplified burden at different VAT-bearing purchase shares
Line chart: General regime: 44.3m → 21.2m; Simplified 6% + VAT 5%: 16.5m → 16.5m; Simplified 15% + VAT 5%: 14.3m → 14.3m010m20m30m40m50m02040608010080% in the exampleGeneral regime, 0: 44.3mGeneral regime, 20: 39.6mGeneral regime, 40: 35mGeneral regime, 60: 30.4mGeneral regime, 80: 25.8mGeneral regime, 100: 21.2mSimplified 6% + VAT 5%, 0: 16.5mSimplified 6% + VAT 5%, 20: 16.5mSimplified 6% + VAT 5%, 40: 16.5mSimplified 6% + VAT 5%, 60: 16.5mSimplified 6% + VAT 5%, 80: 16.5mSimplified 6% + VAT 5%, 100: 16.5mSimplified 15% + VAT 5%, 0: 14.3mSimplified 15% + VAT 5%, 20: 14.3mSimplified 15% + VAT 5%, 40: 14.3mSimplified 15% + VAT 5%, 60: 14.3mSimplified 15% + VAT 5%, 80: 14.3mSimplified 15% + VAT 5%, 100: 14.3mRUB
  • General regime
  • Simplified 6% + VAT 5%
  • Simplified 15% + VAT 5%
Data as a table
MeasureGeneral regimeSimplified 6% + VAT 5%Simplified 15% + VAT 5%
044.3m16.5m14.3m
2039.6m16.5m14.3m
4035m16.5m14.3m
6030.4m16.5m14.3m
8025.8m16.5m14.3m
10021.2m16.5m14.3m

General and simplified burden at different VAT-bearing purchase shares. The general regime line falls as the VAT-bearing share rises (the deduction grows), the simplified lines do not depend on it; the crossing is the regime break-even.

General regime burden by component
Waterfall: Corporate income tax +11.3m, Output VAT +33m, Input VAT deduction −18.5m, Total burden 25.8m010m20m30m40m50mCorporate income taxCorporate income taxCorporate income tax: +11.3m+11.3mOutput VATOutput VATOutput VAT: +33m+33mInput VAT deductionInput VAT deductionInput VAT deduction: −18.5m−18.5mTotal burdenTotal burdenTotal burden: 25.8m25.8mRUB
  • positive
  • negative
  • total
Data as a table
StepChangeLevel
Corporate income tax+11.3m11.3m
Output VAT+33m44.3m
Input VAT deduction−18.5m25.8m
Total burden—25.8m

General regime burden by component. Corporate income tax, output VAT and the input VAT deduction add up to the total burden.

Specifics by category

Apparel
Apparel: the general regime model; many VAT-bearing purchases in wholesale, the general regime often wins for a brand with production.
Footwear
Footwear: high cost and import share, import VAT: more often the general regime. Imported footwear and accessories carry large import VAT: on the simplified regime at a special rate it is not deducted and enters cost.
Accessories
Accessories: smaller turnover and higher margin, the simplified regime wins with low input VAT.
Kids
Kids: 10% VAT lowers output tax and changes the regime comparison. With a 10% rate on kids goods input VAT at 22% creates a refundable position: check the deduction conditions and the declaration register.
Men
The regime is set by turnover and cost structure, not audience; the practical difference: a men line with a high share of basics and fewer markdowns gives steadier profitability, which makes the regime comparison less sensitive to the markdown share.
Women
The regime is set by turnover and cost structure; fast women fashion gives a high share of markdowns and returns, pre-tax profitability is lower, and this shifts the regime choice: compute the threshold on the women line separately from the men line.

Common mistakes

  • Splitting a business across stores to keep the simplified regime → assessment under Tax Code Art. 54.1 → a structure with business purpose.
  • Choosing a regime by rate, not input VAT → overpayment → compare the full burden.
  • Missed the VAT threshold → arrears and fines → monitor cumulative income.
  • Intra-group prices off-market → tax authority adjustment → price documentation.
  • The regime is chosen for simplicity, not by the share of input VAT → overpaid taxes or lost large customers → compute both regimes on your data.
  • Entities are split off without functions and resources → signs of artificial splitting → every entity gets its own role, staff and market-priced contracts.

Russian specifics

  • Corporate income tax rate 25% (Art. 284, 176-FZ). Rule: Tax Code Art. 284: Tax Code, Art. 284 (corporate income tax rates).
  • VAT exemption threshold for the simplified regime RUB 20 million (Art. 145, 228-FZ). Rule: Law 228-FZ of 04.07.2026: Federal Law of 04.07.2026 No. 228-FZ (income threshold under Art. 145 of the Tax Code).
  • Simplified regime: tax base and minimum tax (Art. 346.18), rates (Art. 346.20). Rule: Tax Code Art. 346.18: Tax Code, Art. 346.18 (tax base on the simplified regime) (rule check not completed).
  • Reduced SME contribution tariff: Art. 427, 104-FZ, order 4125-r; the list was not checked. Rule: Tax Code Art. 427: Tax Code, Art. 427 (reduced contribution tariffs) (rule check not completed).
  • Business splitting: Tax Code Art. 54.1 and court practice (not checked against the text).
  • Special VAT rates on the simplified regime 5% and 7% without input VAT deduction: not checked against the text, thresholds 272.5 and RUB 490.5 million for 2026; check the thresholds and transition rules with a tax adviser before use. Rule: Tax Code Art. 145: Tax Code, Art. 145 (VAT exemption) (rule check not completed).
  • The simplified-regime exemption threshold was checked against the text of 228-FZ: RUB 20 million for 2025–2028 by prior-year income and RUB 20 million for 2026–2029 within the year; the “2025–2028 versus 2026–2029” discrepancy is explained by these two paragraphs of Art. 145. Rule: Law 228-FZ of 04.07.2026: Federal Law of 04.07.2026 No. 228-FZ (income threshold under Art. 145 of the Tax Code).

Open interactively →