Registering a business and choosing the form: sole proprietor or LLC, self-employment, automated simplified, simplified and general regimes
How to choose the form and the tax regime at the start of a brand or a store of clothing, footwear and accessories: a sole proprietor or an LLC, self-employment, the automated simplified regime, the simplified regime with the “income” and “income minus costs” objects, the general system. The document brings the admission by limits, taxes, contributions, VAT and the dividend tax into one figure, what is left to the owner, and leads from the decision to registration, an account, a cash register, electronic document flow and a contract with a platform.
Why this document
The form and the regime are chosen once and are costly to fix: the regime cannot be changed at any moment, a sole proprietor cannot be turned into an LLC without handing over the business, the income limit of self-employment or of the automated regime breaks the calculation with growth, and the dividend tax of an LLC is discovered at the first withdrawal of money. The founder, the CFO and the accountant read this document before registration and before going to platforms. It gives an order: admission by limits, what is left to the owner, risk and growth plans, registration. The “Business form and regime at the start” calculation counts nine options on your figures; for a company with deductions and import VAT see “Tax load”.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- How to choose the form and the tax regime at the start of a brand or a store of clothing, footwear and accessories: a sole proprietor or an LLC, self-employment, the automated simplified regime, the simplified regime with the “income” and “income minus costs” objects, the general system. The document brings the admission by limits, taxes, contributions, VAT and the dividend tax into one figure, what is left to the owner, and leads from the decision to registration, an account, a cash register, electronic document flow and a contract with a platform.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The founder and the accountant prepare, a lawyer checks the form, the charter and the contracts; the decision is made before registration and is reviewed when income approaches the limit of a regime, when staff are hired, when a partner joins and when going to wholesale buyers who need VAT to deduct.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Brand: chooses self-employment for sewing at a factory and for resale → the right to the regime is challenged and taxes are assessed → check admission with an accountant before the first sale. Retail: compares the rates “6% against 15%” → chooses what is costlier by the remainder → count what is left to the owner after contributions, VAT and the dividend tax. Brand: opens an LLC for “solidity” and discovers the dividend tax → withdrawing money costs more than for a sole proprietor → compare the remainder and the need for a legal entity (a partner, deals, a trademark).
For whom
- Brand
- A brand at the start sells through its own site and platforms and gives part of the work to a factory: what matters is admission by the type of goods (self-employment is not for resale), the share of documented production and advertising costs (a regime with costs), trademark rights and a partner joining (simpler with an LLC).
- Retail
- A retailer with a point of sale or an online store buys from suppliers, often with VAT, and applies an online cash register: what matters is the deduction of input VAT on wholesale purchases, the VAT threshold on the simplified regime, rent, the number of staff (contributions, limits of the automated regime) and the growth in the number of points.
What it consists of
Form and regime: two different choices
- The form (a sole proprietor or an LLC) sets liability for debts and the way money reaches the owner; the regime (self-employment, automated simplified, simplified, general) sets taxes and reporting. They are chosen separately but counted together, by what is left to the owner.
- A sole proprietor: an individual with registration; answers for debts with all property; there is no charter capital; on the simplified regime the profit belongs to the owner without a dividend tax, but there are fixed contributions for oneself.
- An LLC: a legal entity under the law on limited liability companies; a participant answers with the contribution; profit is withdrawn as dividends with a tax; it is simpler to sell a stake, bring in a partner and arrange rights to the trademark and contracts.
- Self-employment (professional income tax): for an individual without hired staff and within the annual income limit; a tax on every receipt, no reports and no contributions for oneself; resale of purchased goods is not allowed, sewing at a factory to your patterns is disputed: check the right with an accountant.
- The automated simplified regime: the tax office counts the tax and the staff contributions from the bank’s and the online cash register’s data; the rates are higher than on the simplified regime but there is less reporting; there are limits on income and headcount and bank conditions; check the conditions.
- Simplified “income”: a rate on income, the tax is reduced by contributions (with a cap); worthwhile at a low share of costs. “Income minus costs”: a rate on the difference, with a minimum tax; worthwhile at a high share of documented costs, for a brand buying goods and sewing it is often above a half.
- The general system: corporate income tax for an LLC and personal income tax for a sole proprietor plus VAT with deduction of input VAT; needed when buyers need VAT to deduct, when income is above the limit of the simplified regime or when there is much input VAT at a small markup.
- Above the income threshold a simplified-regime payer pays VAT (check the threshold and rates against the norms in force); neither the regime nor the form exempts from the online cash register, marking and certification of the goods.
How the decision depends on the side of the business
- Brand: if the goods are resold or sewn by third parties, self-employment drops out; then the choice is between a sole proprietor and an LLC on the simplified and the automated regimes, and the regime with costs wins at a cost share of customer money above a half.
- Retail: for a store with wholesale purchases from VAT payers and individual buyers the simplified regime without deduction makes input VAT part of the costs; if purchases with VAT are large, compare the general system on your own numbers.
Registration and the first steps
- Choose the form and the regime by the calculation, then file the registration application; the activity is given by codes (for trade in clothing, footwear and accessories and for sewing the codes differ): check the list with the registrar.
- Open a current account; the automated regime needs a bank connected to it; file the application or notice of the regime on time: check the terms and the procedure with an accountant, a missed term leaves you on the general system.
- Retail needs an online cash register, check the exceptions under the law on cash register equipment; connect electronic document flow with suppliers and register as a participant of the “Chestny Znak” marking system before the first turnover of goods subject to marking.
- Conclude the contract with a platform and suppliers on the form and regime you chose: a change of form later means new contracts, new codes and a trademark moved to a new rightholder.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Revenue and cost forecast | money from customers for the year, costs, the share of costs with input VAT, payroll and the number of employees |
| Norms and rates for the current year | simplified, automated and self-employment rates, a sole proprietor’s fixed contributions, regime limits, the VAT threshold (from the norms in force and from an accountant) |
| Growth plans and partners | a partner or investor joining, wholesale buyers with VAT, channel plans, selling the business |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Brand: write down what exactly you sell and who sews: own production, sewing at a factory to your patterns or resale; the answer decides the admission of self-employment.
- Step 2: Retail: collect the forecast of customer money and costs for the year and the share of purchases from VAT payers; without this share the general system and the simplified regime cannot be compared.
- Step 3: Brand: enter the rates and limits for the current year from the norms in force and check them with an accountant; regional simplified-regime rates may be below the base ones.
- Step 4: Retail: run the calculation and mark the allowed options: income and headcount against the limits, the type of goods against the ban on resale.
- Step 5: Brand: compare what is left to the owner, not the rates; write down the difference between the best and the worst allowed option, this is the price of a wrong choice for a year.
- Step 6: Retail: check the headroom to the VAT threshold on the simplified regime and recalculate for next year’s revenue: if the threshold will be crossed, decide in advance what to do with the price and the regime.
- Step 7: Brand: add what is not in the calculation: liability for debts, a partner joining, trademark rights, the requirements of a platform and a bank; with close remainders risk decides.
- Step 8: Retail: register, open an account, file the application of the regime on time, connect the cash register, electronic document flow and marking, then conclude contracts; recalculate at every approach to a limit.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| What is left to the owner | L = M − C − P − T − K − V − D | M: customer money, C: costs, P: payroll, T: regime tax, K: contributions, V: VAT payable, D: the dividend tax of an LLC. |
| Simplified “income” for a sole proprietor without staff | T = max(0; M × rate − K_self); K_self = F + 1% × max(0; M − threshold) | F: the fixed sum for the year; with staff the tax can be reduced by no more than a half. |
| Simplified “income minus costs” | T = max((M − C − P − K) × rate; M × minimum tax) | The minimum tax is paid even at a loss; the rate and the minimum are regional. |
| VAT on the general system | VAT = M × t ÷ (1 + t) − C × share × t ÷ (1 + t) | t: the VAT rate; the price for the buyer is the same, VAT inside; share: the part of costs with input VAT. |
Formulas in notation
- A sole proprietor’s contributions for oneself
K_self = F + p × max(0, M − S)
F: the fixed sum for the year, p: the share of income above the threshold S; on simplified “income” they reduce the tax.
Worked example
Nine options at customer money of RUB 9m and costs of RUB 6.3m a year, no staff, default rates; all values conditional, RUB
| Option | Admission | Tax | Contributions | VAT | Dividend tax | Left to the owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Self-employed (professional income tax), no sole proprietor | no: income above the limit, factory sewing is disputed | 540,000 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2,160,000 |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income” | yes | 396,000 | 144,000 | 0 | 0 | 2,160,000 |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income minus costs” | yes | 383,400 | 144,000 | 0 | 0 | 2,172,600 |
| Sole proprietor, automated simplified regime (the better rate option) | yes | 540,000 | 144,000 | 0 | 0 | 2,016,000 |
| Sole proprietor, general regime (personal income tax and VAT) | yes | 212,019 | 127,770 | 941,311 | 0 | 1,418,899 |
| LLC, simplified “income”, dividends | yes | 540,000 | 0 | 0 | 280,800 | 1,879,200 |
| LLC, simplified “income minus costs”, dividends | yes | 405,000 | 0 | 0 | 298,350 | 1,996,650 |
| LLC, automated simplified regime (the better rate option), dividends | yes | 540,000 | 0 | 0 | 280,800 | 1,879,200 |
| LLC, general regime (corporate income tax and VAT), dividends | yes | 439,672 | 0 | 941,311 | 171,472 | 1,147,544 |
The best allowed option here is a sole proprietor on simplified “income minus costs”: the costs are 70% of customer money. A sole proprietor on “income” leaves almost as much, and an LLC on “income” RUB 280,800 less because of the dividend tax. On the general system about half as much is left. The rates, limits and fixed contributions are illustrative: check them.
Figures
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Customer money | +9,000 | 9,000 |
| Costs | −6,300 | 2,700 |
| Tax | −383 | 2,317 |
| Contributions | −144 | 2,173 |
| Left to the owner | — | 2,173 |
From customer money to what is left to the owner: a sole proprietor on simplified “income minus costs”. Costs take 70% of the money, tax and contributions about another 6%; what is left to the owner is the last column.
Data as a table
| Measure | Left for the year |
|---|---|
| Self-employed (professional income tax), no sole proprietor | 2,160 |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income” | 2,160 |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income minus costs” | 2,173 |
| Sole proprietor, automated simplified regime (the better rate option) | 2,016 |
| Sole proprietor, general regime (personal income tax and VAT) | 1,419 |
| LLC, simplified “income”, dividends | 1,879 |
| LLC, simplified “income minus costs”, dividends | 1,997 |
| LLC, automated simplified regime (the better rate option), dividends | 1,879 |
| LLC, general regime (corporate income tax and VAT), dividends | 1,148 |
How much is left to the owner at each of the nine options. The general system with VAT and an LLC with dividends leave noticeably less; self-employment is shown for comparison but is not allowed by the limit.
The path from the decision to the first sale. First the calculation and admission, then registration, an account and the regime, then the cash register, document flow, marking and the contract with a platform.
- Calculation and admission → Registration
- Registration → Account and regime
- Account and regime → Cash register and document flow; Marking
- Cash register and document flow → Contract with a platform
- Marking → Contract with a platform
- Contract with a platform
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: sewing at a factory to your patterns makes self-employment disputed, and the costs of fabric, sewing and advertising are usually high; so simplified “income minus costs” is often compared with “income” at your cost share.
- Footwear
- Footwear: costs are higher because of lasts, tooling and certification, size returns eat the margin; the cost share of customer money is usually higher and the regime with costs wins more often; marking is mandatory.
- Accessories
- Accessories: the cost is low, the markup high, there are fewer costs; “income” is often better, but check the VAT threshold: turnover on small receipts grows fast.
- Kids
- Children’s: a reduced VAT rate is possible by a list and confirmation, and on the general system it changes the calculation; certification under the technical regulation adds costs, and an organization buyer (a kindergarten, a school) asks for VAT to deduct.
- Men
- Men’s: stable demand and basic items, lower costs and returns; the tax choice is decided by channels and wholesale: for wholesale buyers with VAT check the general system.
- Women
- Women’s: a wide collection and seasonal discounts, higher size returns; advertising and photography costs are large, and the regime with costs is usually better when these costs are documented.
Common mistakes
- Brand: chooses self-employment for sewing at a factory and for resale → the right to the regime is challenged and taxes are assessed → check admission with an accountant before the first sale.
- Retail: compares the rates “6% against 15%” → chooses what is costlier by the remainder → count what is left to the owner after contributions, VAT and the dividend tax.
- Brand: opens an LLC for “solidity” and discovers the dividend tax → withdrawing money costs more than for a sole proprietor → compare the remainder and the need for a legal entity (a partner, deals, a trademark).
- Retail: does not watch the VAT threshold on the simplified regime → with growth suddenly pays VAT on prices without it → count the headroom by cumulative income and build VAT into the price in advance.
- Brand: takes illustrative rates and limits from the example as fact → counts on outdated numbers → enter the rates and limits of the current year and region and check with an accountant.
Russian specifics
- Brand: an LLC is created and operates under the law of 08.02.1998 No. 14-FZ “On limited liability companies”; a participant answers within the contribution, the procedure for withdrawing profit as dividends is set by the charter and the law. Rule: Law 14-FZ of 08.02.1998: Federal Law of 08.02.1998 No. 14-FZ “On limited liability companies”.
- Retail: retail trade applies an online cash register under the law of 22.05.2003 No. 54-FZ “On the use of cash register equipment”; check the exceptions and the procedure for online trade against the current text. Rule: Law 54-FZ of 22.05.2003: Federal Law of 22.05.2003 No. 54-FZ on the use of cash registers.
- Retail: the threshold of exemption of a simplified-regime payer from VAT is RUB 20m of income (Art. 145 of the Tax Code, law of 04.07.2026 No. 228-FZ); above the threshold VAT is paid at the general or a special rate: check the text of the act. Rule: Law 228-FZ of 04.07.2026: Federal Law of 04.07.2026 No. 228-FZ (income threshold under Art. 145 of the Tax Code).
- Brand: the rates of the professional income tax, the annual income limit of a self-employed person, the ban on resale and the admission of sewing by third parties: check with an accountant under the law in force; in the example the rates and the limit are illustrative.
- Retail: the conditions of the automated regime (limits on income and headcount, a partner bank, the procedure for a sole proprietor’s own contributions), regional simplified-regime rates and a sole proprietor’s fixed contributions for the year: check against the norms in force; in the calculation they are fields.