Business form and regime at the start: sole proprietor or LLC, self-employment, automated simplified, simplified and general, and what is left to the owner
From the money from customers for the year, the costs, payroll and rates it counts for nine options (self-employed, a sole proprietor and an LLC on the simplified “income”, on “income minus costs”, on the automated simplified regime, on the general system) the tax, contributions, VAT and the tax on dividends, checks the admission against the limits (income, employees, resale for the self-employed) and shows what is left to the owner. It counts the start of a small brand or store: for the full load of a company with deductions and import VAT see the “Tax load” calculation. The rates and limits are set by fields and are illustrative: check them against the norms in force and with an accountant.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- Which form and regime leave the owner more money at your income and costs, whether self-employment and the automated regime fit the limits and how a sole proprietor differs from an LLC in what is left.
- What data is needed?
- Money from customers and costs for the year, payroll and the number of employees.
- How to read the result?
- Example on the default values (an illustrative brand: customer money RUB 9 million, costs RUB 6.3 million, no employees): the best allowed option is “Sole proprietor, simplified “income minus costs””, the owner is left with RUB 2.17 million (load 5.9% of customer money), at the worst allowed RUB 1.15 million; sole proprietor against LLC on “income”: RUB 280,800 in favor of the sole proprietor. Self-employment: income above the limit of the regime; sewing at a factory to your patterns: disputed, check. Example on the default values: The best allowed option: Sole proprietor, simplified “income minus costs”; Left to the owner at the best option: RUB 2.17 million; Load of the best option, % of customer money: 5.9%; Left at the worst allowed option: RUB 1.15 million. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
The form and the regime are chosen not by the rate but by what is left to the owner. A 6% tax on income sounds cheaper than 15% on profit, but at a high share of costs the second may turn out smaller. So the calculation follows a chain: money from customers minus costs, payroll, taxes, contributions, VAT and, for an LLC, the dividend tax paid when profit is withdrawn to the owner. A sole proprietor on the simplified regime has no such tax but has fixed contributions for oneself; a self-employed person has no contributions but has an income limit and a ban on resale. On the default values (customer money RUB 9 million, costs RUB 6.3 million, cost share 70%) the best allowed option is “Sole proprietor, simplified “income minus costs””: the owner is left with RUB 2.17 million. An LLC on “income” leaves RUB 280,800 less because tax is withheld on dividends. A sole proprietor’s contributions for oneself are RUB 144,000.
When to use it
Apply it before registration and with growth: when income approaches the limit of a regime, when employees appear, when you bring in a partner or prepare to sell the business. It does not replace an accountant: regional rates, reliefs, property tax and VAT on the simplified regime above the threshold are not included here, and the rates and limits in the fields are illustrative and need checking against the norms in force. For a complex structure (several entities, production and retail separately) see the “Tax load” and “Regime border” calculations and the document on the tax regime. For footwear, accessories and children’s the taxes are the same, the costs of certification and marking change.
How to read the result
Start with admission: self-employment and the automated regime may drop out by the limit, the number of employees or the type of goods, and then the row stays for comparison only. Then look at what is left to the owner, not at the load: the best option’s load is 5.9% of customer money, an LLC on the general system is noticeably higher, but the full difference is visible only in what is left. The gap between the best and the worst allowed, RUB 1.03 million a year, shows the price of a wrong choice. The headroom to the VAT threshold is RUB 11 million: while it is positive, simplified regimes without VAT are allowed; when it runs out, recalculate the price and the regime. Take the decision on the form together with the risk: liability for debts, partners and selling the business weigh no less than the difference in tax.
Common mistakes
Rates are compared instead of what is left. Self-employment is taken for the resale of purchased goods or for income above the limit. They forget that an LLC pays tax on dividends and count the profit as “theirs”. They do not enter their own costs and take the example. They do not watch the VAT threshold: with growth the regime changes. They take illustrative rates and limits as fact and do not check them against the norms in force and regional laws.
What data is needed?
- Money from customers and costs for the year, payroll and the number of employees.
- Tax rates, fixed contributions and the limits of the regimes for the current year from the norms in force.
- What you sell: own production, sewing at a factory or resale; the share of income from individuals.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Money from customers for the year | ₽ | 9,000,000 | Everything received from customers and platforms for the year, with VAT if it is in the price. For footwear, accessories and children’s take your own data. The example value is illustrative. |
| Costs for the year without payroll | ₽ | 6,300,000 | Goods, platform commission, logistics, advertising, rent, other: how much is actually paid, together with suppliers’ VAT. The example value is illustrative. |
| Share of costs with input VAT | % | 60 | What part of the costs was paid to suppliers who charged VAT: on the general system it is deducted, on the simplified regime it stays in costs. The example value is illustrative. |
| VAT rate | % | 22 | The VAT rate of your country: needed for the general system; 22% for Russia, check for your item. |
| Employees’ pay for the year | ₽ | 0 | The payroll of hired employees without contributions; zero if you work alone. The example value is illustrative. |
| Employees | people | 0 | The number of hired workers: it decides self-employment (not allowed), the automated regime (a headcount limit) and the contribution deduction on the simplified regime. |
| What you sell | Sewn at a factory to your patterns | For the self-employed the resale of purchased goods is not allowed, sewing at third parties is disputed: choose your case and check the right with an accountant. | |
| Share of income from individuals | % | 0 | For the self-employed the rate depends on the payer: from individuals lower, from sole proprietors and companies higher. A platform that pays you counts as a company: then the share is 0. |
| Simplified “income” | % | 6 | The base rate; regional laws may change it. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Simplified “income minus costs” | % | 15 | The base rate; many regions lower it. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Minimum tax, simplified “income minus costs” | % of income | 1 | Paid if the tax at the rate is below this share of income. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Automated simplified “income” | % | 8 | The rate of the automated simplified system with the “income” object; a condition: a partner bank, the tax office counts the taxes. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Automated simplified “income minus costs” | % | 20 | The rate of the automated simplified system with the “income minus costs” object. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Minimum tax, automated simplified | % of income | 3 | The minimum tax with the “income minus costs” object. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Self-employment tax from individuals | % | 4 | The rate of the professional income tax if an individual pays. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Self-employment tax from sole proprietors and companies | % | 6 | The rate of the professional income tax if a sole proprietor or a company pays (a platform included). Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| LLC corporate income tax | % | 25 | The main corporate income tax rate for companies; reliefs and regional parts are not included. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Personal income tax up to the threshold | % | 13 | The personal income tax rate on dividends and for a sole proprietor on the general system within the annual income threshold. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Personal income tax above the threshold | % | 15 | The higher personal income tax rate on the part of income above the threshold. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Annual income threshold for personal income tax | ₽ | 2,400,000 | The amount of income for the year above which the higher rate applies. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Fixed contributions of a sole proprietor for oneself | ₽ | 57,000 | The annual fixed sum of a sole proprietor’s contributions for oneself: an illustrative value, take it from the current notice. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Extra contribution above the income threshold | % | 1 | The share of income above the threshold that a sole proprietor adds to the fixed sum. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. For regimes with costs the base may be counted differently: check. |
| Income threshold for the extra contribution | ₽ | 300,000 | Income for the year above which the extra percentage accrues. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Payroll contribution tariff | % | 30 | The general payroll contribution tariff; a reduced tariff for small business does not apply to everyone. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| A sole proprietor on the automated regime pays contributions for oneself | Yes, as on the simplified regime (cautious) | Check the procedure for a sole proprietor’s own contributions on the automated regime; by default they are counted as on the simplified regime, a cautious assumption (unverified). | |
| Annual income limit of a self-employed | ₽ | 2,400,000 | Above the limit the right to the professional income tax is lost. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Annual income limit on the simplified regime | ₽ | 490,500,000 | The value for 2026, indexed further; above the limit the simplified regime is lost. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Annual income limit on the automated regime | ₽ | 60,000,000 | Above the limit the automated regime cannot be used. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Employee limit on the automated regime | people | 5 | More employees than this the automated regime does not allow. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
| Income threshold for VAT on the simplified regime | ₽ | 20,000,000 | Above the threshold a simplified-regime payer pays VAT; it is not in the comparison, the calculation shows the headroom to the threshold. Check against the norms in force and with an accountant. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Admission | income, employees and type of goods against the limits of the regime |
| Regime tax | Simplified: income × rate − contributions (capped) or (income − costs) × rate not below the minimum; automated: the smaller of two; self-employed: income × rate |
| Contributions | Sole proprietor: fixed + extra above the threshold + payroll contributions; LLC: payroll only |
| VAT on the general system | VAT in customer money − input VAT of costs |
| Left to the owner | money − costs − payroll − taxes − contributions − VAT − dividend tax (for an LLC) |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- The best allowed option
- Sole proprietor, simplified “income minus costs”
- Left to the owner at the best option
- 2.17 m ₽
- Load of the best option, % of customer money
- 5.9 %
- Left at the worst allowed option
- 1.15 m ₽
- Gap between the best and the worst allowed
- 1.03 m ₽
- Allowed options out of nine
- 8
- Self-employment: admission
- income above the limit of the regime; sewing at a factory to your patterns: disputed, check
- Sole proprietor against LLC on simplified “income”: gap in what is left
- 280,800 ₽A plus means more is left to the sole proprietor: with an LLC part goes to the dividend tax.
- Simplified “income” against “income minus costs” for a sole proprietor: gap in load
- −12,600 ₽A plus means “income minus costs” costs more.
- Fixed and extra contributions of a sole proprietor for oneself
- 144,000 ₽
- Headroom to the VAT threshold on the simplified regime (minus: exceeded)
- 11 m ₽
- Cost share of customer money
- 70 %
Data as a table
| Measure | Left |
|---|---|
| Self-employed (professional income tax), no sole proprietor | 2.16m |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income” | 2.16m |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income minus costs” | 2.17m |
| Sole proprietor, automated simplified regime (the better rate option) | 2.02m |
| Sole proprietor, general regime (personal income tax and VAT) | 1.42m |
| LLC, simplified “income”, dividends | 1.88m |
| LLC, simplified “income minus costs”, dividends | 2m |
| LLC, automated simplified regime (the better rate option), dividends | 1.88m |
| LLC, general regime (corporate income tax and VAT), dividends | 1.15m |
- Tax
- Contributions
- VAT
- Dividend tax
Data as a table
| Measure | Tax | Contributions | VAT | Dividend tax |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Self-employed (professional income tax), no sole proprietor | 540k | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income” | 396k | 144k | 0 | 0 |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income minus costs” | 383k | 144k | 0 | 0 |
| Sole proprietor, automated simplified regime (the better rate option) | 540k | 144k | 0 | 0 |
| Sole proprietor, general regime (personal income tax and VAT) | 212k | 128k | 941k | 0 |
| LLC, simplified “income”, dividends | 540k | 0 | 0 | 281k |
| LLC, simplified “income minus costs”, dividends | 405k | 0 | 0 | 298k |
| LLC, automated simplified regime (the better rate option), dividends | 540k | 0 | 0 | 281k |
| LLC, general regime (corporate income tax and VAT), dividends | 440k | 0 | 941k | 171k |
Nine options
| Option | Admission | Tax | Contributions | VAT | Dividend tax | Load, % of customer money | Left to the owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Self-employed (professional income tax), no sole proprietor | income above the limit of the regime; sewing at a factory to your patterns: disputed, check | 540,000 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 6 % | 2.16 m ₽ |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income” | allowed | 396,000 ₽ | 144,000 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 6 % | 2.16 m ₽ |
| Sole proprietor, simplified “income minus costs” | allowed | 383,400 ₽ | 144,000 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 5.9 % | 2.17 m ₽ |
| Sole proprietor, automated simplified regime (the better rate option) | allowed | 540,000 ₽ | 144,000 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 7.6 % | 2.02 m ₽ |
| Sole proprietor, general regime (personal income tax and VAT) | allowed | 212,019 ₽ | 127,770 ₽ | 941,311 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 14.2 % | 1.42 m ₽ |
| LLC, simplified “income”, dividends | allowed | 540,000 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 280,800 ₽ | 9.1 % | 1.88 m ₽ |
| LLC, simplified “income minus costs”, dividends | allowed | 405,000 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 298,350 ₽ | 7.8 % | 2 m ₽ |
| LLC, automated simplified regime (the better rate option), dividends | allowed | 540,000 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 280,800 ₽ | 9.1 % | 1.88 m ₽ |
| LLC, general regime (corporate income tax and VAT), dividends | allowed | 439,672 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 941,311 ₽ | 171,472 ₽ | 17.2 % | 1.15 m ₽ |
Self-employment does not fit: income above the limit of the regime; sewing at a factory to your patterns: disputed, check. The row is shown for comparison and does not enter the choice.
This is the start of a small business, not a full tax model: regional reliefs, advances, prior-year losses, property tax, VAT on the simplified regime above the threshold and special contribution tariffs are not included. The choice of form is decided not only by tax: liability for debts (a sole proprietor answers with all property), selling the business and bringing in partners are easier with an LLC, and access to platforms, tenders and bank limits depends on the form and regime. For footwear, accessories and children’s the taxes are the same, but marking and certification add costs: include them in the costs.
Nuances and limits
- Choosing by the rate (“6% against 15%”) rather than by what is left after all contributions and taxes.
- Taking self-employment for the resale of purchased goods or for income above the limit: the right to the regime is lost.
- Forgetting that an LLC pays dividend tax when withdrawing money while a sole proprietor on the simplified regime does not.
- Not looking at the headroom to the VAT threshold and at the limits: the regime changes with growth.