Legal due diligence of a brand or retailer and ESOP
A checklist and procedure for legal due diligence in a sale, investment or large deal, plus the mechanics of an employee option program. It is used to prepare data for the investor and to understand what price discount or warranties a buyer will demand for the risks found.
Why this document
An investor or buyer pays not for what the brand shows but for what documents confirm: rights to the mark, contracts, taxes, disputes, employment. So the owner, the lawyer and the finance director read the checklist, preparing for the deal months before talks start. Every risk found turns into a price discount, deferred payments or seller warranties. Gaps are therefore closed in advance, and the option program is drafted so that it does not create a dispute over shares when the company is sold.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- A checklist and procedure for legal due diligence in a sale, investment or large deal, plus the mechanics of an employee option program. It is used to prepare data for the investor and to understand what price discount or warranties a buyer will demand for the risks found.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Lawyer and CFO with external advisers; before a round or sale, then a remediation plan; the result goes into a report to the owner and the investor.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- A check right before the deal → no time to fix → start 6–9 months ahead (a guide). All risks lumped together → no priorities → weight and amount. An ESOP “by word” → dispute on exit → agreements and schedule.
For whom
- Brand
- For a brand the center is: trademark rights, licenses, contracts with factories and distributors, certificates and marking, tax structure, disputes, key employees and ESOP.
- Retail
- For a retailer: leases (term, indexation, termination), contracts with brands (returns, consignment), cash registers and personal data, licenses and marking of stock, staff employment issues.
What it consists of
Review blocks
- Corporate: articles, participants, resolutions, group structure, rights to shares, pledges, restrictions; authority checks.
- Intellectual property: marks, prints, designs, rights from designers and contractors (see ip), licenses (see licensing).
- Contracts: key customers, suppliers, leases, platforms, change-of-control clauses, penalties, returns (see contracts, commterms).
- Tax and accounting: regime, VAT, transfer prices, tax disputes, stock accounting and provisions (see taxregime, vat, inv-reserve).
- Compliance: certificates, marking, personal data (152-FZ), advertising (38-FZ), cash registers (54-FZ), platform rules (289-FZ).
- Employment and disputes: contracts, liability agreements, court cases and claims.
ESOP (option plan)
- There is no separate ESOP law in Russia: the plan is built via an option to conclude a contract (Civil Code Art. 429.2) or an option agreement (Art. 429.3) and a shareholders' agreement (Art. 67.2); article numbers not checked against the text.
- Parameters: pool (share of equity), strike price, vesting schedule, cliff, exit terms (good/bad leaver), taxes: personal income tax and contributions on exercise; clarify with a tax adviser.
What each side looks at
- Brand: as the seller of a stake or the investee prepares the data in advance: rights to marks and prints, contracts with factories and key customers (change of control, exclusivity), conformity and marking documents, the tax structure and disputes.
- Retailer: as the seller or buyer of a chain looks at lease contracts (term, indexation, termination, pledge), contracts with brands (returns, consignment, exclusivity), cash registers and personal data, stock and reserves, staff labor issues.
- Brand: for an option plan checks who receives options, on what terms and how this is reflected in corporate documents; computes dilution for the owner.
- Retailer: when buying stores checks premises rights, marking of stock, certificates and the declaration register: this is where hidden compliance costs are found.
Public sources for the first check
- The register of legal entities, the arbitration case file, the enforcement-proceedings database, pledge registers, the Rospatent register of marks and designs, the Rosaccreditation register of certificates and declarations, the marking system: each of them gives part of the picture, none replaces requesting documents from the company.
- Extracts and certificates are dated and kept in the data room (VDR) with an index: they later show what the buyer knew on the deal date.
Red flags by block
- Corporate block: participants and stakes differ from the register, the stake is pledged, decisions were taken without the required quorum, the group structure is not disclosed.
- Contract block: one customer gives more than a third of revenue, a termination right on change of control, uncapped penalties, unsigned contracts.
- Compliance block: no documents for part of the range, stock without marking codes, no consents for personal data processing, cash-register violations.
Brand and retailer: what differs in practice
- Retailer: a retailer checks lease contracts of stores: term, indexation, right to sublet, security deposit and early termination terms on change of control.
- Retailer: checks cash discipline and online cash registers, obligations under the loyalty program and gift cards.
- Retailer: looks at customer personal data: consents, storage, transfer to contractors and cross-border transfer.
How to read the result and what decisions follow
- Blocks with an above-average index are closed first: before the deal they change the price or terms, after the deal it is someone else money and your liability.
- Dilution shows the price of the pool decision: the larger the pool before the round the less remains for founders at the same investor share.
- Decision: the price, closing conditions, seller warranties, a holdback of part of the payment and a plan to cure findings before closing.
Control checks
- The sum of participant shares per the register and constitutive documents equals 100% and there are no pledges or encumbrances missing from the records.
- The number of findings in the report equals the sum of findings by block and each has an owner and a deadline.
Checklist before signing the deal (unverified: a reference, not legal advice)
- The list of findings is split by materiality and each has a solution: price, warranty, closing condition, holdback or withdrawal.
- Seller warranties and liability for hidden tax and contract risks are written into the share or stock purchase agreement (wording, unverified).
- ESOP terms and consents for transactions in the share are checked by a lawyer against the text of the charter and shareholders agreement (unverified).
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Virtual data room | constitutional documents, contracts, rights, taxes, certificates, cases |
| Registers and public data | company register, courts, Rospatent, enforcement proceedings |
| Management interviews | deal terms, disputes, obligations |
How to build it step by step
- Brand: Step 1: Draw up the request list by block and build the VDR.
- Retailer: Step 2: Check rights, documents and registers for each block.
- Brand: Step 3: Assess the probability and amount of each risk.
- Brand: Step 4: Assign a block weight (importance) and the number of findings.
- Brand: Step 5: Draw up a risk register and a remediation plan with owners and dates.
- Retailer: Step 6: Decide what to fix before the deal and what to reflect in the price or warranty.
- Brand: Step 7: If there is an ESOP, check agreements, schedule and taxes, and compute dilution.
- Step 8: A report for the owner and investor: key risks, price, timing.
- Brand: Step 9: Before the check the brand tidies the mark register, author and factory contracts and conformity documents: this shortens the timeline and the price discount.
- Retailer: Step 10: The retailer collects lease and brand contracts in advance into one table: term, indexation, termination, encumbrances.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Block risk index | Index = Weight × Number of findings | For ranking only; the cost of risk is assessed separately. |
| Price discount for risks | Discount = Σ (Probability × Amount) | Probabilities and amounts are entered by the lawyer. |
| Founders' share after the round | Founders = (1 − Pool) × (1 − Investor share) | The pool is created before the investment; if after, the result differs. |
| ESOP dilution | Dilution = Pool / (Capital before pool + Pool); owner stake after = Stake before × (1 − Dilution) | Example: a pool of 10% of final capital; an owner with 60% before the pool gets 60% × (1 − 0.10) = 54%. |
| Weighted block risk | Block risk = Block weight × Σ(Probability × Amount of the block findings) | The investor sets weights by block importance; the total risk is compared with the deal price and with the request for a seller warranty. |
Formulas in notation
- Founders share after the round
F = (1 − p) × (1 − q)
p ESOP pool before the round, q investor share. Example: 72.0%.- ESOP pool after the round
E = p × (1 − q)
Example: 8.0%. If the pool is created after the round the dilution differs.
Worked example
Risk index by block (weight × findings) and ESOP dilution: 10% pool before the round, 20% investor
| Block / holder | Weight or share | Findings | Index |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trademark and print rights | 5 | 2 | 10 |
| Certificates and marking | 4 | 3 | 12 |
| Contracts with major customers and suppliers | 4 | 1 | 4 |
| Tax risks (regime, splitting, VAT) | 5 | 2 | 10 |
| Employment and ESOP | 3 | 1 | 3 |
| Corporate documents and structure | 3 | 0 | 0 |
| Total index | 9 | 39 | |
| Founders after the round | 72.0% | ||
| ESOP pool after the round | 8.0% | ||
| Investor | 20.0% | ||
| Sum check | 100.0% |
The index only ranks blocks; assess the cost of risks separately; shares show dilution with the pool created before the round. Illustrative figures.
Figures
Data as a table
| Measure | Risk index |
|---|---|
| Trademark and print rights | 10 |
| Certificates and marking | 12 |
| Contracts with major customers and suppliers | 4 |
| Tax risks (regime, splitting, VAT) | 10 |
| Employment and ESOP | 3 |
| Corporate documents and structure | 0 |
Risk index by due-diligence block: weight times findings. The index ranks blocks and does not assess damage: blocks with the highest index are handled first.
Data as a table
| Number of findings | Block weight | |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | 5 | Trademark and print rights |
| 3 | 4 | Certificates and marking |
| 1 | 4 | Contracts with major customers and suppliers |
| 2 | 5 | Tax risks (regime, splitting, VAT) |
| 1 | 3 | Employment and ESOP |
| 0 | 3 | Corporate documents and structure |
Block weight and number of findings. The upper right corner holds blocks with a high weight and many findings: they are closed before signing the deal.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Founders before | +100 | 100 |
| ESOP pool | −10 | 90 |
| Investor round | −18 | 72 |
| Founders after | — | 72 |
Founders share before and after the ESOP pool and the investor round. The pool is created before the round and dilutes everyone, then the investor takes a share of the remainder; figures in percent of capital. Pool 10% before the round, investor 20%: founders 72.0%, pool after the round 8.0%. Illustrative figures.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: key risks: print rights, certificates, marking of stock, factory contracts.
- Footwear
- Footwear: marking and certificates, design rights, dependence on import factories and currency control. For footwear companies check size-level stock, lasts and tooling as assets and the rights to them at factories separately.
- Accessories
- Accessories: counterfeits and mark rights, licenses, jewelry restrictions (not checked).
- Kids
- Kids: TR CU 007/2011 certificates, marking, safety and advertising requirements, 10% VAT. In kids companies a separate block: conformity evidence, safety and parental consents for children data.
- Men
- The review list is set by the product and structure, not the audience; in a men business look at the concentration of large buyers and corporate contracts (uniforms, workwear), the repeatability of basic contracts and fabric delivery terms.
- Women
- The review list is the same; in women fashion also check the share of seasonal leftovers, rights to prints and collaborations with designers and the share of marketplace returns: this changes the stock valuation and the seller warranty terms.
Common mistakes
- A check right before the deal → no time to fix → start 6–9 months ahead (a guide).
- All risks lumped together → no priorities → weight and amount.
- An ESOP “by word” → dispute on exit → agreements and schedule.
- Corporate documents unchecked → deal challenge → authority and consents.
- The check starts with taxes without looking at brand rights and key-customer contracts → the main risk is found late → start with the blocks that revenue depends on.
- ESOP is papered only by correspondence → a dispute about stake and taxes → a written option and shareholder agreement with a vesting schedule.
Russian specifics
- Main norms of the block: Civil Code (contracts, parts 1–2; rights, part 4), Tax Code (Art. 54.1 on splitting not checked against the text). Rule: Civil Code part 2: Civil Code, part two (including Arts. 513, 713, 990, 1027).
- Personal data, advertising, registers: 152-FZ, 38-FZ, 54-FZ (by title). Rule: Law 152-FZ of 27.07.2006: Federal Law of 27.07.2006 No. 152-FZ on personal data.
- ESOP in Russia: no specific rule, constructions via option and shareholders' agreement; articles and taxes not checked.
- ESOP taxes: when an option is exercised the employee per unchecked data has income as a material benefit (personal income tax, and employer social contributions); the procedure, rates and accounting depend on the plan structure: check with a tax adviser, texts were not opened.
- Change of control and anti-assignment clauses in contracts with key customers and landlords are checked separately: they may give the counterparty the right to terminate when the business is sold. Rule: Civil Code part 1: Civil Code, part one (including Arts. 330, 424) (rule check not completed).