Investment in collections and projects
Whether launching a collection, equipment or a new channel pays back.
About the topic
A brand spends big money on things that do not pay back immediately: a collection launch, workshop equipment, a new channel, a shop. It is important to understand that a rouble today and a rouble in a year are not the same thing, because money can be invested or borrowed. The topic teaches you to evaluate a project so as not to fool yourself with an optimistic payback period, and to answer the question: is it worth investing at all.
The main tool is discounting. Future receipts are brought to today by dividing by (1 + rate) to the power of the year. Example: an investment of RUB 10 million, receipts of 4, 5 and RUB 5 million by year, rate 20%. The present values of 3.33, 3.47 and RUB 2.89 million sum to RUB 9.70 million. Net present value (NPV) is 9.70 − 10 = −RUB 0.30 million: at this rate the project does not pay back. At 15% the present values 3.48 + 3.78 + 3.29 = 10.55, and NPV is +RUB 0.55 million. The internal rate of return (IRR), at which NPV is zero, is about 18%. So the answer depends on the rate, and the rate (the price of your capital plus a risk premium) must be discussed before the calculation, not fitted to the result.
The simple payback period (how many years to recover the investment without discounting) is 2.2 years here: in two years 9 million is returned, 1 of the 5 million of the third year remains. The discounted period is longer: in three years only 9.70 of 10 is returned. So the first number soothes, the second is more honest.
So that a project does not look better than it is, flows include what is often forgotten: money frozen in the run and in leftovers before the first revenue, taxes, repeat investments (replacing equipment), and revenue is counted with discounts on part of the run. Then sensitivity is checked: what happens with sales 20-30% below plan and at neighboring rate values. A batch returns within a season, a project is measured in years, and they must not be confused. The decisions of the topic: whether to launch a project, in what scale, how to distribute the investment by quarter and when the need for money peaks, how the project return relates to the cost of capital (WACC). Start with the batch break-even, then build flows by year and compute NPV at three rates.
Key ideas
A rouble today and a rouble tomorrow
Money over time has a price because it can be invested or borrowed. Discounting divides a future rouble by (1 + rate) to the power of the year: at 20% a million in a year is worth RUB 833 thousand today, in two years RUB 694 thousand. So a project that returns money late is worth less.
NPV: is it worth investing
If the budget is limited, projects are compared by NPV per rouble invested. Project A: investment RUB 10 million, NPV +0.55 million, that is 0.055 per rouble. Project B: investment RUB 3 million, NPV +0.30 million, that is 0.10 per rouble. For RUB 9 million you can fit three B projects with a total NPV of RUB 0.9 million against 0.55 million for one A.
IRR and payback period
IRR depends strongly on time. You invested RUB 10 million and got back 14.4 million: after two years IRR is 20% (the square root of 1.44 is 1.2), and after three years it is 12.9% (the cube root of 1.44). The sum is the same, but one extra year lowers the rate by 7 points. What matters is not only how much comes back but also when.
What goes into flows
Flows include money frozen in the run and in leftovers, taxes, repeat investments and revenue with discounts. If RUB 1.5 million is invested in stock in year zero and returned only at the end, NPV falls noticeably. Omitting these items makes a project look better than it is.
Sensitivity and rate
The safety margin can be calculated directly. At a 15% rate, the discounted inflows are RUB 10.55 million against an investment of 10 million, and NPV disappears if flows fall by 1 − 10 / 10.55 ≈ 5%. This is a thin margin: a forecast error of 10% for a new collection is quite possible, and then at this rate it is better to start the project with a smaller step.
How to work through it
- Define the project and the alternative: what happens if nothing is invested.
- Compute batch break-even as input: how much must be sold to recover the run.
- Build flows by year: investment, revenue, costs, taxes, frozen stock, repeat investments.
- Choose a rate: cost of capital plus a risk premium, and write down where it comes from.
- Compute NPV, IRR, simple and discounted payback.
- Test sensitivity: sales 20-30% below plan and neighboring rates.
- Distribute the investment by quarter and find the peak funding need.
- Compare the project return with WACC and decide: launch, change scale or postpone.
Where to start
First collection break-even: how much must be sold to recover the run; then the investment project by year with NPV and payback. All calculations of this topic come from other topics: “Investment project: NPV, IRR and payback”, “Collection break-even and order size”, “WACC: cost of capital, ROIC against WACC and economic profit”.
Calculations in this topic
Investment project: NPV, IRR and payback
Appraises a project from its cash flows: opening a store, launching a collection, buying equipment. Calculates net present value, internal rate of return and payback.
Whether the project pays back with the time value of money and what its return is.
Collection break-even and order size
Calculates how many units you must sell to recover development and launch, and shows profit at different sell-through of the run.
How many units you must sell to recover development and launch.
WACC: cost of capital, ROIC against WACC and economic profit
Calculates the weighted average cost of capital from the shares, the cost of equity and debt after tax, then compares it with ROIC and finds economic profit (EVA); the table shows how WACC and EVA change at another debt share.
What the company’s capital costs, whether the business earns more than that cost and how much economic profit it creates.
Self-check questions
- What happens if we invest nothing and how is the project better than that?
- Do the flows include frozen stock, taxes and repeat investments?
- What rate was used, what does it consist of and who approved it?
- What is NPV at rates 3-5 points higher and lower?
- What are the simple and the discounted payback periods?
- What happens if sales are 20-30% below plan?
- What part of revenue goes at a discount and is it accounted for?
- When is the peak funding need and where will the money come from?
- Is the project return above the brand’s cost of capital?
Knowledge check
Multiple-choice questions. The correct answer and the explanation follow each question.
What does a positive NPV of a project mean?
- A. The project will pay back in less than a year
- B. The project earns more than the discount rate requires
- C. The undiscounted sum of flows exceeds the investment, and that is enough
- D. The IRR of the project equals the discount rate
Correct answer: B. The project earns more than the discount rate requires. NPV = the sum of flows divided by (1 + rate) to the power of the year, minus the investment; a plus means the discounted flows exceed the investment. The undiscounted sum of flows exceeds the investment in almost any project, yet at a high rate the NPV can still be negative. An IRR equal to the rate means NPV = 0, not a plus. Payback speed does not follow from the sign of NPV.
An investment of RUB 6 million today, net flows by year of 2.0, 3.0 and RUB 3.5 million (after tax), discount rate 20%. What is the NPV?
- A. +RUB 2.5 million
- B. +RUB 0.93 million
- C. +RUB 0.22 million
- D. −RUB 0.22 million: the project does not return the required rate
Correct answer: D. −RUB 0.22 million: the project does not return the required rate. Discounted flows: 2.0 / 1.2 = 1.67; 3.0 / 1.44 = 2.08; 3.5 / 1.728 = 2.03; the sum is RUB 5.78 million, NPV = 5.78 − 6 ≈ −RUB 0.22 million. +2.5 comes without discounting (8.5 − 6); +0.93 at a 10% rate instead of 20%; +0.22 is simply the wrong sign.
Price RUB 5,000, cost RUB 2,000, returns 4%, other variable costs RUB 300 per unit, fixed collection costs RUB 3,096,000. How many units must be sold to break even?
- A. 1,200 units
- B. 1,147 units
- C. 1,238 units
- D. 1,032 units
Correct answer: A. 1,200 units. Contribution per unit (5,000 − 2,000) × 0.96 − 300 = RUB 2,580; 3,096,000 / 2,580 = 1,200 units. 1,147 comes without returns (contribution RUB 2,700); 1,238 if returns come off the price only (5,000 × 0.96 − 2,000 − 300 = RUB 2,500); 1,032 if only the cost is subtracted from the price (contribution RUB 3,000).
Contribution per unit is RUB 2,580, fixed collection costs RUB 3,096,000, the batch is 2,500 units, 70% sold. What is the profit before the unsold remainder?
- A. RUB 3.35 million
- B. RUB 4.52 million
- C. RUB 1.42 million
- D. RUB 1.63 million
Correct answer: C. RUB 1.42 million. Sold 2,500 × 0.7 = 1,750 units; contribution 1,750 × 2,580 = RUB 4,515,000; minus fixed RUB 3,096,000 = RUB 1,419,000. 3.35 million comes from treating the whole batch as sold; 4.52 from forgetting the fixed costs; 1.63 from taking a contribution of RUB 2,700 without returns. The leftover at cost freezes money and is not part of this profit.
Capital structure: 60% equity at a cost of 24%, 40% debt at 15% before tax, income tax 25%. The ROIC of the business is 19.5%. What is true?
- A. WACC is 20.4%, spread −0.9 pp: the business does not cover the cost of capital
- B. WACC is 18.9%, spread +0.6 pp: the business earns more than the cost of capital
- C. Spread +4.5 pp against the 15% debt rate: growth on debt is unconditionally profitable
- D. Spread −4.5 pp against the 24% cost of equity: the business destroys value
Correct answer: B. WACC is 18.9%, spread +0.6 pp: the business earns more than the cost of capital. WACC = 0.6 × 24% + 0.4 × 15% × (1 − 0.25) = 14.4 + 4.5 = 18.9%; ROIC 19.5% is 0.6 pp higher. 20.4% comes without the tax shield (14.4 + 6.0) and reverses the conclusion. Comparing only with the debt rate or only with the cost of equity gives a distorted spread: the cost of capital is a weighted figure. Check the income tax rate with your accountant.
Common mistakes
Mistake: Leaving frozen run, leftovers and taxes out of flows
What it costs: The project seems more profitable
How to avoid: Count money as it really moves.
Mistake: Taking a rate without a risk premium
What it costs: NPV is positive on paper
How to avoid: Add a premium and test neighboring rates.
Mistake: Counting revenue at full price although part of the run will go at a discount
What it costs: Income is overstated
How to avoid: Use the average price after discounts.
Mistake: Mixing batch and project payback
What it costs: A batch returns within a season, a project is measured in years
How to avoid: Count them separately.
Mistake: Evaluating a project at one rate
What it costs: Not seeing that the decision is borderline
How to avoid: Compute at several rate and sales values.
Russia and the EAEU
In Russia the project calculation depends on taxes and rates. Corporate income tax is 25%; on the simplified regime tax is taken on income (6%) or on income minus expenses (15%), and this changes the flows: equipment and run costs reduce tax in different ways. VAT on equipment purchases is deductible for payers, and import VAT on imported equipment too; for non-payers VAT goes into cost. Depreciation, useful life and accounting regime affect the tax shield, ask your accountant.
The discount rate is tied to the brand’s real cost of money: the key rate and bank terms change, so the rate forecast should be tested by scenario. Equipment leasing is recorded under FSBU 25/2018 (leases), which changes the balance sheet and covenants. For light-industry projects support measures exist: soft loans from the Industrial Development Fund, subsidies and leasing programs through the Ministry of Industry and Trade; terms, limits and requirements change, check the current ones.
Chestny ZNAK marking and certification add investment to the launch of each new item. If part of purchases comes from abroad, add exchange-rate risk and currency control (law 173-FZ). For a shop opening count rent, fit-out, a cash register under law 54-FZ and the time to reach planned revenue.
For a project in another EAEU country taxes and the rate change. Indicative figures as of 14 November 2026, verify with a local accountant: corporate income tax in Belarus 20%, in Kazakhstan 20% (CIT), in Armenia 18%, in Kyrgyzstan 10%; VAT 20, 16, 20 and 12% respectively. In Kyrgyzstan the garment industry has reliefs on contributions and income tax tied to the average wage from 1 January 2026 to 1 January 2030 (indicative, per the tax service clarification of 13.01.2026). Simplified regimes by country: indicative as of 14.11.2026, check the text of the act. A discount rate in the national currency and exchange-rate risk make comparison with a Russian project non-trivial: count the flow in the project currency and decide conversion separately.
Categories and audiences
- Apparel
- On apparel: a project is often a new collection or line, and investments are seasonal and return within one or two seasons. The main risk is in leftovers and discounts, so build them into revenue. Equipment (cutting, printing) pays back with steady load; count the average, not the peak.
- Footwear
- In footwear: a project is heavier on capital because lasts, molds and tooling are expensive and pay back only through run size, and the payback period is longer. The size run freezes money in stock. A below-plan sales scenario is especially dangerous here because of high fixed costs.
- Accessories
- For accessories: the launch investment is usually smaller and leftover storage is longer, so the project is less risky and pays back faster. But the effect is often about image and hard to measure. For leather and bag lines tooling and material give a significant share of the investment.
- Kids
- If it is children’s wear: certification and marking add a fixed investment per model, and seasonality is tied to school. Leftovers lose value faster because the child grows, so the return period should be shorter.
- Men
- In a men’s project (extending the basics range, equipment for recurring items) the flows can be built from past seasons of the same models. So sales scenarios differ less, and “minus 20%” is often enough. Set the rate premium modestly but not at zero, and check equipment load separately: idle time eats NPV faster than a price cut.
- Women
- For a women’s line, flows for a new collection rest on less history: the models are different every season, so sales are estimated from analogs and early sales rather than from past figures of the same models. Include a “minus 30%” scenario and staged investment: a small first batch, expansion according to actual sales. The risk premium here is higher.
Questions this topic answers
- Will launching a new collection, equipment or channel pay back, allowing for the run, leftovers and seasonality?
- How much cash is frozen in the run and leftovers before the first revenue?
- What is the project’s return and when will it return the investment?
- What happens if sales come in 20–30% below plan?
- How does the investment spread over quarters and when is the cash need at its peak?
Key measures and terms
Study first
What next
Related: “Order size and break-even”, “Revenue, profit and costs”, “Taxes and VAT”.
Documents on this topic
- Business plan of a brand and a retailer: sections, assumptions, presenting to an investor and a bank
- Investment case: opening a store, a line, IT (NPV, IRR, payback)
- Capital: WACC, ROIC, dividends and reinvestment
- Brand licensing and collaborations: royalty, minimum guarantee, economics and contract
- Legal due diligence of a brand or retailer and ESOP
- Financial mathematics: time value, NPV, IRR, MIRR, annuity, leasing and currency
- State support for light industry and development fund loans: map of measures, conditions, application and effect calculation
- Group structure, dividends and CFC: how to arrange the ownership of a brand and a retailer and what to check