Commission or buyout: what pays the brand and the multi-brand store
Compares two ways of supplying a multi-brand store: a buyout of the batch at the wholesale price and commission (money after the sale, the leftover is returned). Shows the brand’s and the store’s profit at different sold shares and the share at which commission becomes better.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What pays the brand and the store more: buying the batch out or commission.
- What data is needed?
- Retail and wholesale price, cost, batch, sold share.
- How to read the result?
- A batch of 500 pieces, wholesale 2,900, retail 6,000, cost 1,500. Buyout gives the brand 0.68m (after the cost of waiting 30 days). Commission of 35% at 70% sold gives 0.65m after 75 days: the schemes are equal at a sold share of 71.5%. The store earns 1.01m on buyout and 0.74m on commission. Example on the default values: Brand: profit on buyout — RUB 678,548; Brand: profit on commission — RUB 654,514; Commission minus buyout for the brand — −RUB 24,034; Sold share at which the schemes are equal — 71.5%.
Why and how to reason
Buyout and commission split the leftover risk differently. With buyout the store pays the brand a wholesale price and carries the risk of unsold goods. With commission the brand gets money only after sale (net of the store’s commission), and the leftover returns to it. So for the brand buyout is guaranteed income: (2,900 − 1,500) × 500 = 700 thousand minus the cost of money over 30 days deferral 21.5 thousand = 678.5 thousand ₽. Commission depends on the sold share: at 70% the brand receives 0.65 × 6,000 × 500 × 70% = 1.365 million, minus cost of money for 75 days, minus batch cost 750 thousand, plus the returned leftover at RUB 600 (90 thousand), total 654.5 thousand. Commission is 24 thousand less than buyout. The schemes are equal at 71.5% sold: above it commission pays the brand more. The store gets 1.01 million on buyout and 735 thousand on commission.
When to use it
Reach for it when negotiating a supply scheme with a multi-brand store that finds it hard to buy the whole batch while you are sure of demand. Assumption: sold share and leftover value are honestly estimated; commission and terms are fixed in the contract. It does not fit goods that lose price fast (a returned leftover is worth almost nothing) nor a store that cannot ensure storage and sales reporting. The calculation also makes the store’s view fair.
How to read the result
The main number is the sold share at which schemes are equal (71.5%) against your estimate (70%). Near equality means the decision depends on other things: payment term, price freedom, image. If you are sure you will sell over 75–80%, commission pays the brand more, but then buyout is poor for the store and it needs something in return. The store earns 735 thousand on commission against 1.01 million on buyout: too low a commission kills its wish to sell. Offer a hybrid: buyout of the base range and commission for novelties and seasonal items. The store limits risk where demand is unknown and you keep guaranteed income.
Common mistakes
The usual mistakes: assuming the brand carries no risk under commission; ignoring the time to receive money; overstating the value of the returned leftover (goods come back dirty or off-season); ignoring that under commission the store may display goods worse. Do not forget return logistics. Do not take the residual value of a return equal to the price of the goods: returned goods are worth less.
What data is needed?
- Retail and wholesale price, cost, batch, sold share.
- The store’s commission, the residual value of returns, the store’s leftover price, the time to money and its cost.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Retail price excl. VAT | ₽ | 6,000 | Price excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026 (17.12.2025). The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant. |
| Wholesale price on buyout excl. VAT | ₽ | 2,900 | The price at which the store buys the batch. |
| Brand unit cost | ₽ | 1,500 | The brand’s unit cost excl. VAT from the costing; the commission and buyout schemes are compared by it. |
| Batch | pcs | 500 | How many pieces go to the multi-brand store. |
| Sold share in the base case | % | 70 | An estimate of how much will sell by the end of the period. The default is an example. |
| Store commission under the commission scheme | % | 35 | The share of the retail price excl. VAT the store keeps. |
| Residual value of returned goods for the brand | ₽ | 600 | How much the brand will get per returned unit (sale, own channel). Empty: zero. |
| Price at which the store sells leftovers under buyout | ₽ | 2,400 | After a seasonal discount. Empty: zero. |
| Payment term under buyout | days | 30 | From shipment to money. Empty: zero. |
| Time to money under commission | days | 75 | From shipment to settlement for what was sold. Empty: zero. |
| Brand cost of money | % | 18 | A loan rate or a yield a year; the cost of waiting for money is counted. Empty: zero. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Brand on buyout | (wholesale price − cost) × batch − wholesale revenue × rate × days ÷ 365 |
| Brand on commission | (1 − commission) × retail × sold × (1 − rate × days ÷ 365) − cost × batch + residual value × returns |
| Store on buyout | retail × sold + leftover price × unsold − wholesale price × batch |
| Equality | the sold share at which the brand’s profit on commission equals profit on buyout |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Brand: profit on buyout
- 678,548 ₽Independent of sales: the leftover risk is on the store.
- Brand: profit on commission
- 654,514 ₽
- Commission minus buyout for the brand
- −24,034 ₽
- Sold share at which the schemes are equal
- 71.5 %Above this share commission pays the brand more.
- Store: profit on buyout
- 1.01 m ₽
- Store: profit on commission
- 735,000 ₽Before the store’s costs of storage and selling.
Profit at different sold shares
| Sold | Brand: buyout | Brand: commission | Store: buyout | Store: commission | Better for the brand |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40 % | 678,548 ₽ | 181,151 ₽ | 470,000 ₽ | 420,000 ₽ | buyout |
| 50 % | 678,548 ₽ | 338,938 ₽ | 650,000 ₽ | 525,000 ₽ | buyout |
| 60 % | 678,548 ₽ | 496,726 ₽ | 830,000 ₽ | 630,000 ₽ | buyout |
| 70 % | 678,548 ₽ | 654,514 ₽ | 1.01 m ₽ | 735,000 ₽ | buyout |
| 80 % | 678,548 ₽ | 812,301 ₽ | 1.19 m ₽ | 840,000 ₽ | commission |
| 90 % | 678,548 ₽ | 970,089 ₽ | 1.37 m ₽ | 945,000 ₽ | commission |
| 100 % | 678,548 ₽ | 1.13 m ₽ | 1.55 m ₽ | 1.05 m ₽ | commission |
Buyout moves the leftover risk to the store and brings money at once; commission leaves the risk with the brand but usually pays more with good sales. VAT and the payment term depend on the contract: check it with a lawyer and an accountant and combine the calculation with “Wholesale terms”.
Nuances and limits
- Buyout moves the leftover risk to the store, commission leaves it with the brand.
- The sold share is an estimate: with weak sales commission loses.
- VAT and the payment term depend on the contract: check it with a lawyer and an accountant.