A buyer session: the brand scorecard, the agenda and the order terms
A buyer session is a meeting of a brand and a store at which they decide whether to take the brand into the range, in what volume and on what terms. The document gives a scenario of an hour-long session (preparation, agenda, decisions, minutes), a brand scorecard for the buyer with weights, stop criteria and thresholds, and a list of the terms that are negotiated. The economics of the choice “buyout or commission” and the economics of a brand at a retailer are counted by separate Lab calculations; here they are linked but not repeated.
Why this document
A session lasts an hour while the decision costs months of sales: if the buyer is not prepared they take by impression, and if the brand is not prepared it loses the place over a trifle. The scorecard turns impression into comparable points, the agenda does not let the talk drift away from money, the minutes fix what was decided. The document is read by the brand’s founder, the commercial director, the buyer and the category manager; both sides use the same table so that the dispute goes about numbers rather than mood.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- A buyer session is a meeting of a brand and a store at which they decide whether to take the brand into the range, in what volume and on what terms. The document gives a scenario of an hour-long session (preparation, agenda, decisions, minutes), a brand scorecard for the buyer with weights, stop criteria and thresholds, and a list of the terms that are negotiated. The economics of the choice “buyout or commission” and the economics of a brand at a retailer are counted by separate Lab calculations; here they are linked but not repeated.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The scorecard is kept by the store’s buyer or category manager before and after the session; the brand’s package (line sheet, price list, terms) is prepared by the brand’s commercial director; the minutes are signed by both sides.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Brand: Come with a company presentation instead of samples and figures: the buyer leaves with an impression, not with data for a decision. Brand: Promise support and terms orally: after the session they do not get into the minutes and a season later nobody remembers them. Brand: Not knowing the store’s margin at your retail price: the buyer counts it himself and finds discrepancies before you.
For whom
- Brand
- For a brand the session is a sale: it shows demand, the product, the store’s margin and delivery reliability, and comes with samples and a ready proposal on terms.
- Retail
- For a retailer the session is a selection: the buyer checks the brand against the role of the category and the purchase budget, sets scores on the scorecard and decides: into the order, a trial order or decline.
What it consists of
Preparing for the session
- Brand: The brand package: the platform on one page, a line sheet with styles and sizes, the wholesale and retail price list, the minimum order, delivery terms, payment and return terms.
- Brand: Samples and documents: samples of key models, declarations or certificates, marking data; come to the session with what can be touched and checked.
- Brand: Proof of demand: sales in own channels, repeat orders, reviews, return data; without them the talk about demand stays words.
- Brand: A calculation of the store’s margin at the recommended retail price: the buyer will make it anyway, better show it first.
- Retailer: The role of the category and the budget: how much money and space is allocated, which positions must be covered, which brands already stand nearby.
- Retailer: The scorecard with weights and stop criteria is filled before looking at the brand; the questions are written in advance for weak criteria.
- Retailer: The store’s data on similar brands: sales, returns, margin after discounts; this is the basis for comparing the offer.
An hour-long agenda
- 0–5 minutes: introductions and the aim: a decision on a trial order, the range or the terms; who makes the decision for each side.
- 5–15 minutes: the brand, the buyer and demand: the platform on one page and the proof of demand, without a company presentation.
- 15–30 minutes: the collection and samples: the buyer looks at samples, sizes, fit, seams and marking, noting questions.
- 30–40 minutes: prices and margin: the retail and wholesale price, the store’s margin after discounts; the question “how much will be left” is closed by a figure.
- 40–50 minutes: terms: the size of a trial order, deferral, a return of unsold goods, rotation, the delivery term, marketing support.
- 50–60 minutes: risks, decisions and the next step: what was decided, what stays open, who and by what date; the minutes are sent the same day.
Brand scorecard for a buyer
- Retailer: Eight criteria with weights summing to 100: demand and awareness, product and fit, price and store margin, terms, delivery reliability, marketing support, quality and returns, documents.
- Retailer: Scores from 0 to 5 are set by facts: samples, prices, delivery history, documents; a score of 5 means “better than required”, not “I like it”.
- Retailer: Stop criteria: a minimum on product, delivery reliability, quality and documents; below the minimum the decision is “stop” until the criterion is fixed.
- Retailer: Decision thresholds: a total not below the order threshold — into the order; between the thresholds — a trial order of a small volume; below — decline; the thresholds are set by the category policy.
- Brand: The brand fills in the same scorecard for itself in advance: a weak criterion is closed with a term (support, return, rotation), not with an assurance.
Terms that are negotiated
- Brand: A trial order: a small volume, a clear review date and a success criterion (the share sold by the date); without a criterion a trial order stays forever.
- Brand: Payment: prepayment, deferral and a discount for early payment; the price of deferral is counted through the cost of money, not by eye.
- Retailer: A return of unsold goods and rotation: what is returned, by what date, at whose expense; it lowers the risk of a trial order and the price for it.
- Retailer: Buyout or commission: the scheme is chosen by calculation, not by habit; both Lab calculations (buyout against commission and the economics of a brand at a retailer) give a sum for the talks.
- Retailer: Marketing support and a retro bonus: the sum, the calculation base and the term; in the minutes, not in an oral agreement.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| The brand package | The line sheet, price list, minimum order, terms, payment conditions, samples, documents. |
| The store’s data | The role and budget of the category, sales and margin of similar brands, returns, shelf space. |
| Delivery history and reviews | The share of orders delivered on time, returns for quality, reviews from other stores. |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Retailer: define the role of the category and the purchase budget; the scorecard criteria weights depend on them.
- Step 2: Retailer: fix the criteria, weights, stop minimums and decision thresholds before looking at the brand.
- Step 3: Brand: assemble the brand package, samples and proof of demand; count the store’s margin at the recommended price.
- Step 4: Brand: fill in the scorecard for yourself and note weak criteria: prepare a term for each that lowers the store’s risk.
- Step 5: Hold the session by the hour-long agenda: samples, prices and terms are discussed with figures on the table.
- Step 6: Retailer: set the scores right after the session by facts, not by aftertaste; check the stop criteria.
- Step 7: Retailer: compare the total with the thresholds and decide: into the order, a trial order or decline; write down where the brand loses most points.
- Step 8: Brand: receive the proposal on terms and recount the economics: the brand’s margin under buyout and under commission, the price of deferral and returns.
- Step 9: Sign the minutes with a review date and the success criterion of the trial order; after the term compare the fact with the scorecard.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Points of a criterion | points = weight × score ÷ 5 ÷ sum of weights × 100 | The maximum of a criterion equals its share in the sum of weights. |
| Total of a brand | total = the sum of points over criteria, maximum 100 | Brands of one category with the same weights are compared. |
| Decision | a stop → stop; total ≥ the order threshold → into the order; ≥ the trial threshold → a trial order; otherwise decline | The thresholds are illustrative and set by the category policy. |
Worked example
The scorecard of label A and the current brand B, an illustrative case
| Criterion | Weight | Score A | Score B | Points A | Points B |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Demand and brand awareness | 15 | 2 | 4 | 6 | 12 |
| Product, range and fit | 20 | 4 | 4 | 16 | 16 |
| Price and margin for the store | 20 | 4 | 3 | 16 | 12 |
| Terms: deferral, returns, rotation | 10 | 3 | 4 | 6 | 8 |
| Delivery reliability and lead time | 15 | 3 | 4 | 9 | 12 |
| Brand marketing support | 10 | 3 | 4 | 6 | 8 |
| Quality and return rate | 5 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 |
| Documents, certificates and marking | 5 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 4 |
| Total of 100 | 100 | — | — | 68 | 75 |
The total of A is 68 of 100, of B 75; thresholds 70 (into the order) and 55 (a trial order). Stop criteria for A: 0, for B: 0. A falls between the thresholds: a trial order; 2 points are missing to the order threshold, and the most points (9) are lost on the criterion “Demand and brand awareness”. For B the decision is “into the order”. A’s delivery reliability stands exactly on the minimum of 3, and this is the main risk of the trial order. All numbers are illustrative.
Figures
- Label A
- Brand B
Data as a table
| Measure | Label A | Brand B |
|---|---|---|
| Demand and brand awareness | 6 | 12 |
| Product, range and fit | 16 | 16 |
| Price and margin for the store | 16 | 12 |
| Terms: deferral, returns, rotation | 6 | 8 |
| Delivery reliability and lead time | 9 | 12 |
| Brand marketing support | 6 | 8 |
| Quality and return rate | 4 | 3 |
| Documents, certificates and marking | 5 | 4 |
Points by criterion: label A and brand B, of 100. The gap is mostly in demand and awareness; label A wins on price and store margin, so the bargaining is about support and returns.
The session agenda, minutes. Most time goes to samples, then to price and terms: the buyer decides by the goods and the money, not by a presentation.
| Stage | Start, min. | Length, min. |
|---|---|---|
| Introductions and the aim of the session | 0 | 5 |
| Brand, buyer and demand | 5 | 10 |
| Collection and samples | 15 | 15 |
| Prices, margin and recommended retail | 30 | 10 |
| Terms: order, payment, returns | 40 | 10 |
| Risks and brand support | 50 | 5 |
| Decisions and the next step | 55 | 5 |
How the decision is made by the scorecard. The stop criterion is checked before the total: it does not depend on the sum of points.
- Scores by criterion → A stop?
- A stop? → Total of 100; A stop or below the trial threshold: decline
- Total of 100 → Total not below the order threshold: into the order; Between the thresholds: a trial order; A stop or below the trial threshold: decline
- Total not below the order threshold: into the order
- Between the thresholds: a trial order
- A stop or below the trial threshold: decline
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- In apparel the main criteria are fit and the size run, material and the delivery term; the buyer looks at samples in different sizes and at seams. Returns for fit go into the criterion “quality and returns”, and the rotation of sizes is agreed separately.
- Footwear
- In footwear the weight of the size grid, the last and wear is higher; the stop criterion on quality is stricter because a return of footwear is expensive. Samples are tried on several feet, and the terms of returning unsold goods and rotating sizes are discussed in more detail than in apparel.
- Accessories
- In accessories material, hardware and packaging matter, and the average receipt is lower, so the minimum order and the turnover speed weigh more. The gift season requires delivery in advance; the criterion “delivery term” gets a larger weight and the brand prepares display samples.
- Kids
- In children’s the stop criterion on documents and material safety is the strictest: without certificates the decision is “stop”. The buyer checks the size run by height, the marking and seams; the criterion “demand” includes data on parents’ repeat purchases because the child grows.
- Men
- In the men’s segment the weight of the criterion “product and fit” is higher and of “marketing support” lower: people buy on demand, not under a campaign. The buyer compares with the nearest brands on price and material and looks at the delivery reliability of basic positions.
- Women
- In the women’s segment the range is wider and image and season influence more: the weight of “demand and awareness” and “marketing support” is higher, the criterion “product” is assessed by the whole capsule. The buyer watches overlap with the brands on the shelf so as not to sell the same at another price.
Common mistakes
- Brand: Come with a company presentation instead of samples and figures: the buyer leaves with an impression, not with data for a decision.
- Brand: Promise support and terms orally: after the session they do not get into the minutes and a season later nobody remembers them.
- Brand: Not knowing the store’s margin at your retail price: the buyer counts it himself and finds discrepancies before you.
- Retailer: Change weights and thresholds after looking at the brand: the scorecard turns into a justification of a decision made in advance.
- Retailer: Take a trial order without a success criterion and a term: the “trial” order is repeated until it becomes the main one without a decision.
- Retailer: Not checking documents before the session: a brand with a beautiful sample and without a declaration turns out to be a stop, but after the time has been spent.
Russian specifics
- Retailer: Wholesale contracts, deferral and returns of unsold goods are drawn up in a supply contract; check the deferral terms and their link with the payments legislation with a lawyer.
- Brand: Light-industry goods are subject to mandatory marking and conformity confirmation; check the requirements of technical regulation TR CU 017/2011 for your product group before the session. Rule: CU Commission decision 876 of 09.12.2011: TR CU 017/2011 on safety of light-industry products (Customs Union Commission Decision of 09.12.2011 No. 876).
- Brand: Children’s goods require conformity to TR CU 007/2011; without declarations a brand does not pass the stop criterion on documents. Rule: CU Commission decision 797 of 23.09.2011: TR CU 007/2011 on safety of products for children and adolescents (Customs Union Commission Decision of 23.09.2011 No. 797).
- Retailer: The recommended retail price is not binding on a store, but agreements on a minimum price may violate the competition law; check the wording with a lawyer.
- Retailer: For supplies from and to the EAEU countries VAT and documents are arranged differently; check the terms, taxes and rates for each country before signing. Rule: Treaty Annex 18 of 29.05.2014: Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union, Annex No. 18 (indirect taxes).