Price tiers: good, better, best
Calculates the average price and unit margin for a split of sales across tiers and shows the effect of shifting part of sales one tier up. Checks whether the step between tiers is noticeable to a customer.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- How to set prices within a category so that the customer climbs the tiers and average margin rises.
- What data is needed?
- For each tier: price and unit cost excl. VAT, share of pieces.
- How to read the result?
- Three tiers of 3,000, 4,500 and 7,000 with shares of 50, 35 and 15% give an average price of 4,125 and a unit margin of 2,470 (59.9% of price). A shift of 5 percentage points of pieces from each tier one tier up raises the average price to 4,325 and the margin to 2,610: +140 a piece and 1.4m for 10,000 pieces a season. Price steps of 50% and 56% are visible to a customer. Example on the default values: Average selling price — RUB 4,125; Average unit margin — RUB 2,470; Average margin in price — 59.9%; After the shift: average price — RUB 4,325.
Why and how to reason
A “good, better, best” ladder lets the buyer choose by wallet and lets the brand earn from those willing to pay more. Average price and margin depend on how many pieces sell on each rung. In the example there are three tiers: RUB 3,000 (margin 1,700, share 50%), RUB 4,500 (2,700, 35%), RUB 7,000 (4,500, 15%). Average price 0.5 × 3,000 + 0.35 × 4,500 + 0.15 × 7,000 = RUB 4,125; average margin 850 + 945 + 675 = RUB 2,470 (59.9% of price). If 5% of pieces move one rung up (base to middle, middle to top), average price is RUB 4,325, margin RUB 2,610: +RUB 140 per piece, on 10,000 pieces a season +RUB 1.4 million. The point of the shift is that top-tier margin is larger in roubles although its share in pieces is small.
When to use it
It comes in handy when building a category assortment and pricing a line: to check each tier has its own role and see the effect of lifting part of demand. Assumption: the shift happens without loss of volume (in life part will go to competitors). It does not fit a category where buyers look for one price nor exclusive lines without choice. Set the minimum noticeable price step (15%) for your market.
How to read the result
Look at average unit margin and the gain from the shift. If price steps are smaller than noticeable (here 0 of 2) the tiers are distinguishable and the buyer sees the difference, otherwise they will not feel better and will buy the base one. The top-to-bottom price ratio of 2.3 shows the width of the ladder. Decision: if the shift gives a noticeable gain, work on its causes (display, quality communication), not on the number: the shift will not happen by itself. Check that each tier has a clear reason for the buyer to choose it (material, fit, service life) and not only price: otherwise the shift upward will not happen and the numbers stay on paper.
Common mistakes
The usual mistakes: entering shares not as percent of total volume; counting the shift with no loss of volume; making tiers 5% apart in price with no difference in quality; ignoring that tier cost rises faster than price. A tier with a small share and large stock eats the whole gain. Do not enter a tier share as a percent of the category if the tool expects a share in pieces.
What data is needed?
- For each tier: price and unit cost excl. VAT, share of pieces.
- The shift in percentage points and, optionally, the season volume.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shift: share of all pieces moving one tier up | % | 5 | From each tier except the top, this many percentage points of pieces move to the next. Empty: zero. |
| Season sales in this category | pcs | 10,000 | For converting into money. Empty: money not calculated. |
| Minimum noticeable price step between tiers | % | 15 | A rule of thumb, replace with your experience. A smaller step is often not seen by a customer as another tier. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Average price | Σ tier share × tier price |
| Average margin | Σ share × (price − cost) |
| Shift | from each tier except the top, s percentage points of pieces move to the next (not more than its share) |
| Effect | margin after − margin before; in money × season volume |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Average selling price
- 4,125 ₽
- Average unit margin
- 2,470 ₽
- Average margin in price
- 59.9 %
- After the shift: average price
- 4,325 ₽
- After the shift: unit margin
- 2,610 ₽
- Margin gain per unit from the shift
- 140 ₽
- Margin gain per season
- 1.4 m ₽
- Price steps below the noticeable level
- 0
- Top tier price to bottom tier
- 2.33×
Tiers and shares of pieces
| Tier | Price | Unit margin | Price step | Share now | Share after |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 3,000 ₽ | 1,700 ₽ | — | 50 % | 45 % |
| Better | 4,500 ₽ | 2,700 ₽ | 50 % | 35 % | 35 % |
| Best | 7,000 ₽ | 4,500 ₽ | 56 % | 15 % | 20 % |
A shift one tier up works only if the upper tier explains its price (material, fit, brand). Test it with a pilot rather than a calculation: see “Pilot against control stores”.
Nuances and limits
- Tiers close in price merge in the customer’s eyes.
- A shift upwards holds only if the upper tier explains its price by material, fit or brand.
- Do not copy other people’s price tiers: set them with your position among competitors in mind.