A niche and an item on a platform: capacity, competition, the newcomer’s expected sales, a pilot batch and the entry point
From a table of niches (demand per month, the number of sellers with sales, the share of the ten leaders, price, cost) it counts the capacity of the niche, the share of an average seller and the expected sales of a new seller, the size of the pilot batch, the profit of the pilot and the time to sell out, the entry point (how many units a month are needed for the contribution to cover the fixed costs of an item) and the decision “go, test or no”. Take demand and the number of sellers from the platform’s analytics, set the platform’s holdbacks and advertising as one share: the exact figure comes from the “Marketplace unit economics” calculation.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- Whether the niche is large enough, whether the leaders have taken it, how much a newcomer will sell, what the pilot batch should be and whether to enter.
- What data is needed?
- Demand a month, the number of sellers with sales and the share of the ten leaders from the platform’s analytics.
- How to read the result?
- Example on the default values (four illustrative niches, holdbacks and ads 35% of the price, newcomer coefficient 60%): the best by return is “Cotton shirt dress”, the decision is “go: order the pilot batch”; capacity RUB 68.6 million a month, a newcomer sells about 72 units, the contribution per unit RUB 851, the pilot batch 150 units for RUB 257,500, the return 34%; niches “go, test, no”: 2, 1, 1. Example on the default values: The best niche by the pilot return: Cotton shirt dress; Decision on the best niche: go: order the pilot batch; Capacity of the niche per month: RUB 68.6 million; Newcomer’s expected sales, units a month: 72. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
A niche seems large when you look at turnover, but a newcomer gets not the turnover but its own share. The calculation goes in three steps. First the capacity: demand a month × price. Then competition: the ten leaders take a noticeable share, the other sellers divide the remainder, and the share of an average seller is (1 − the leaders’ share) ÷ (sellers − 10). Finally the newcomer: without reviews and history it takes only a part of this share, so expected sales = demand × the share of an average seller × the newcomer coefficient. From them follow the pilot batch (sales × months of cover), the profit of the pilot and the entry point: how many units a month are needed for the unit contribution to cover the fixed costs. On the default values the niche “Cotton shirt dress” has a capacity of RUB 68.6 million a month, and a newcomer sells about 72 units at a contribution of RUB 851: a pilot of 150 units, an investment of RUB 257,500, a return of 34%.
When to use it
Apply it before choosing an item and before ordering the first batch: when you compare several ideas or categories, when you check whether to enter a niche with high competition. It suits when you have the platform’s analytics on demand and the number of sellers; without it take cautious estimates and count the result as a range. It does not replace unit economics: set the holdbacks and advertising as one share and take the exact figure from the “Marketplace unit economics” calculation. For footwear, accessories and children’s demand, sizes and returns are their own, so take your category’s data and allow for a higher returns coefficient.
How to read the result
The decision is made of three checks. The unit contribution must be positive: otherwise the price does not cover the cost and the holdbacks. The return of the pilot must be no lower than your threshold: the best niche has 34%. And the expected sales must exceed the entry point with a margin: here 2 times at an entry point of 35 units a month. If the margin is between 1 and the threshold, the niche goes as “a test with a small volume”: order the minimum and check the assumptions. If the share of the ten leaders is above the maximum, a special reason to enter is needed: price, brand or a unique item. The time to sell out the pilot is 2.1 months: if it is longer than two or three, the batch is large for your demand. After the pilot replace the assumptions with facts.
Common mistakes
They take the demand of the whole niche as their own sales. They do not look at the leaders’ share and the number of sellers. They take a pilot batch for a year instead of one or two months. They do not count the fixed costs of an item, and the unit contribution drowns in them at small sales. They take the price of the cheapest competitors instead of the price of the niche core. They ignore the season: demand from one month of the seasonal peak overstates everything else.
What data is needed?
- Demand a month, the number of sellers with sales and the share of the ten leaders from the platform’s analytics.
- The shelf price, the cost in the warehouse and the share of holdbacks and advertising (from “Marketplace unit economics”).
- The batch step, the test budget, the fixed costs of an item and the decision criteria.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| VAT rate in the price | % | 22 | The VAT rate included in the shelf price; 0 if you are not a VAT payer and the price equals revenue. 22% for Russia, check for your item. |
| Platform and advertising: share of the shelf price | % | 35 | Commission, logistics, storage, returns and advertising together as a percentage of the shelf price. The exact figure comes from “Marketplace unit economics”. The example value is illustrative. |
| Newcomer coefficient to an average seller | % | 60 | What part of the share of an average seller outside the leaders a newcomer takes in the first months: without reviews and history usually below a hundred percent. The example value is illustrative. |
| Months of sales in the pilot batch | months | 2 | For how many months of expected sales you take the pilot batch: the fewer, the lower the risk and the more frequent the re-orders. The example value is illustrative. |
| Batch step (multiple) | units | 10 | The minimum batch and the order multiple at the factory or in a case: the batch is rounded up to a whole number of steps. The example value is illustrative. |
| Advertising test budget | ₽ | 40,000 | How much you spend on launching the card: internal ads, reviews, photos. Subtracted from the profit of the pilot. The example value is illustrative. |
| Fixed costs of an item per month | ₽ | 30,000 | Photos, content, subscriptions, the share of a manager’s work per item per month; the contribution of a unit must cover them. The example value is illustrative. |
| Minimum return of the pilot | % | 20 | The profit of the pilot to the money invested below which the batch is not ordered. The example value is illustrative. |
| Minimum margin over the entry point | times | 1.5 | How many times the expected sales must exceed the entry point to go without reservations. The example value is illustrative. |
| Maximum share of the ten leaders | % | 70 | Above this share the leaders own the niche and a newcomer needs a special reason to enter. The example value is illustrative. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Capacity | demand a month × shelf price |
| Share of an average seller | (1 − leaders’ share) ÷ (sellers − 10) |
| Newcomer’s expected sales | demand × share of an average seller × newcomer coefficient |
| Contribution per unit | price ÷ (1 + VAT) − cost − platform and ad share × price |
| Pilot batch and profit | batch = sales × months of cover, rounded up to the step; profit = batch × contribution − ad test |
| Entry point and decision | units needed = fixed costs ÷ contribution; go if the return, the margin and the leaders’ share are within the criteria |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- The best niche by the pilot return
- Cotton shirt dress
- Decision on the best niche
- go: order the pilot batch
- Capacity of the niche per month
- 68.6 m ₽
- Newcomer’s expected sales, units a month
- 72
- Contribution per unit after cost, holdbacks and ads
- 851 ₽
- Pilot batch, units
- 150
- Investment in the pilot: goods and the ad test
- 257,500 ₽
- Profit of the pilot when sold out
- 87,709 ₽
- Return of the pilot on the money invested
- 34 %
- Time to sell out the pilot, months
- 2.1
- The entry point: units a month needed
- 35
- Expected sales to the entry point, times
- 2
- Niches: go, test, no
- 2, 1, 1
Data as a table
| Measure | Return of the pilot |
|---|---|
| Cotton shirt dress | 34 |
| Palazzo trousers | 18 |
| Linen suit | 30 |
| Basic oversize hoodie | −68 |
- Expected sales
- Entry point
Data as a table
| Measure | Expected sales | Entry point |
|---|---|---|
| Cotton shirt dress | 72 | 35 |
| Palazzo trousers | 47 | 44 |
| Linen suit | 65 | 28 |
| Basic oversize hoodie | 4 | 46 |
Niches: from demand to the decision
| Niche | Capacity per month | Sellers per 1,000 units of demand | Expected, units a month | Contribution per unit | Batch, units | Profit of the pilot | Return | Margin over the entry point, times | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cotton shirt dress | 68.6 m ₽ | 5.7 | 72 | 851 ₽ | 150 | 87,709 ₽ | 34 % | 2 | go: order the pilot batch |
| Palazzo trousers | 85.8 m ₽ | 6.8 | 47 | 682 ₽ | 100 | 28,172 ₽ | 18 % | 1.1 | test with a small volume and check |
| Linen suit | 46.8 m ₽ | 6.2 | 65 | 1,082 ₽ | 130 | 100,613 ₽ | 30 % | 2.3 | go: order the pilot batch |
| Basic oversize hoodie | 158.4 m ₽ | 43.8 | 4 | 650 ₽ | 10 | −33,501 ₽ | −68 % | 0.1 | no: do not enter |
In 1 niches the ten leaders take more than 70%: entering them without a special advantage (price, brand, a unique item) is risky.
This is an estimate of the order of magnitude on analytics data: demand, the number of sellers and the leaders’ share change from month to month and with the season, and a newcomer without reviews usually gets less than the average share. The pilot is needed to check the assumptions with small money, not to confirm the calculation. For footwear, accessories and children’s demand, returns and sizes are their own: take your category’s data.
Nuances and limits
- Taking the whole demand of the niche: a newcomer gets the share of an average seller and with a coefficient.
- Not looking at the leaders’ share: at high concentration many sellers share the remainder.
- Taking the first batch for a year of sales: a pilot should be for one or two months.
- Ignoring the fixed costs of an item: the contribution per unit does not cover them at small sales.