Brand scorecard for a buyer: weighted criteria, stop criteria and a decision by thresholds
From a table of criteria (weight, a score from 0 to 5 for each of the two brands, a minimum per criterion) it counts a total out of 100, the number of triggered stop criteria, the difference between the brands and a decision by thresholds: into the order, a trial order or decline. It shows on which criteria the brand loses most points so you know what to bargain over. The buyer sets the scores from their own data and samples: the calculation only adds up judgments and does not replace them.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What total score a brand gets on pre-set criteria, whether it has a stop criterion, what to decide (an order, a trial order, decline) and what to bargain over.
- What data is needed?
- The criteria and weights of your category policy, the minimums per criterion (stop).
- How to read the result?
- Example on the default values (eight criteria, thresholds 70 and 55): brand A scores 68 of 100, brand B 75; the difference −7; the decision on A: a trial order; A loses most points on the criterion “Demand and brand awareness: 9” points. Example on the default values: Total of brand A: 68 of 100; Total of brand B: 75 of 100; Difference A − B: −7 points; Stop criteria for A: 0. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
A buyer chooses a brand not by one feature but by a bundle: product, price, terms, reliability, demand. The scorecard turns the bundle into a number so that brands can be compared by one ruler and the decision explained. Each criterion gets a weight (importance) and a score from 0 to 5. The points of a criterion equal weight × score ÷ 5, the total is the sum, at most 100. A stop criterion is needed because the average lies: a brand with an excellent product and delivery failures will get a decent total, but it cannot be taken. So a criterion has a minimum: below it the decision is “stop” regardless of the total. On the default values brand A scores 68 of 100, brand B 75; the order threshold is 70, the trial one 55, so A gets “a trial order” and B gets “into the order”. A loses most points on the criterion “Demand and brand awareness”: 9.
When to use it
Use it when you choose brands for the range, prepare for a buyer session or explain to a purchasing committee why one brand is taken and another is not. Do not use it instead of samples and figures: scores without facts turn the scorecard into an opinion. Assumptions: the criteria add up linearly, the thresholds and weights are illustrative and set by the category policy. For children’s add safety and certificates, for footwear the size grid and the last, for accessories the material and hardware. Fix the criteria and weights before looking at the brands.
How to read the result
Look at the stop criteria first, then the total. Stops for A: 0, so no minimum is violated and the total of 68 reads honestly. Next compare with the thresholds: 2 points are missing to the order threshold, this is the zone of bargaining. The scorecard hints what to bargain over: lift the criterion where the most points are lost (demand and awareness) with terms rather than words, for example marketing support, a return of unsold goods or rotation. Trailing brand B by 7 points explains why B is taken into the order while A is tried. The decision: a trial order with clear terms and a review date.
Common mistakes
Typical mistakes: changing the weights after seeing the total and fitting the scorecard to the decision; not setting stop criteria; setting scores by impression without samples, prices and delivery history; comparing brands of different price levels by the same weights; counting a total of 68 as “almost 70” and taking it into the main order although the threshold means another volume of risk.
What data is needed?
- The criteria and weights of your category policy, the minimums per criterion (stop).
- The scores of two brands by facts: samples, prices, delivery history, terms, documents.
- The decision thresholds: “into the order” and “a trial order”.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| The “into the order” threshold | points of 100 | 70 | A total not below this number: the brand goes into the main order. The threshold is set by your category policy; here illustrative. The example value is illustrative. |
| The trial-order threshold | points of 100 | 55 | A total between this number and the order threshold: a small trial order with return terms. Below: decline. The example value is illustrative. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Points of a criterion | weight × score ÷ 5 ÷ sum of weights × 100 |
| Total | the sum of points over criteria, maximum 100 |
| Stop | a score below the criterion minimum: stop regardless of the total |
| Decision | total ≥ the order threshold — into the order; ≥ the trial threshold — a trial order; otherwise decline |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Total of brand A
- 68 of 100
- Total of brand B
- 75 of 100
- Difference A − B
- −7 points
- Stop criteria for A
- 0
- Stop criteria for B
- 0
- Decision for brand A
- a trial order
- Decision for brand B
- into the order
- The criterion where A loses most points
- Demand and brand awareness: 9
- Sum of weights
- 100 %
- Points to the order threshold for A
- 2
- Brand A
- Brand B
Data as a table
| Measure | Brand A | Brand B |
|---|---|---|
| Demand and brand awareness | 6 | 12 |
| Product, range and fit | 16 | 16 |
| Price and margin for the store | 16 | 12 |
| Terms: deferral, returns, rotation | 6 | 8 |
| Delivery reliability and lead time | 9 | 12 |
| Brand marketing support | 6 | 8 |
| Quality and return rate | 4 | 3 |
| Documents, certificates and marking | 5 | 4 |
Criteria and points
| Criterion | Weight | Score A | Score B | Points A | Points B | Stop for A |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Demand and brand awareness | 15 % | 2 | 4 | 6 | 12 | no |
| Product, range and fit | 20 % | 4 | 4 | 16 | 16 | no |
| Price and margin for the store | 20 % | 4 | 3 | 16 | 12 | no |
| Terms: deferral, returns, rotation | 10 % | 3 | 4 | 6 | 8 | no |
| Delivery reliability and lead time | 15 % | 3 | 4 | 9 | 12 | no |
| Brand marketing support | 10 % | 3 | 4 | 6 | 8 | no |
| Quality and return rate | 5 % | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 | no |
| Documents, certificates and marking | 5 % | 5 | 4 | 5 | 4 | no |
The scorecard does not forecast sales: it orders judgements and shows where to bargain. The thresholds and weights are set by your category policy; the same scores give different decisions for different buyers. For children’s and footwear add criteria: safety and the size grid.
Nuances and limits
- Changing the weights after seeing the total: the scorecard turns into a justification of a decision.
- Not setting stop criteria: a good total hides a failure on safety or lead time.
- Setting scores by impression without samples and figures.