Syntha Lab RU

Buyout, commission sale and consignment: operating cycle and cash

A comparison of three ways to hand goods to a retailer: buyout, commission sale and consignment. It shows who owns the goods, who carries the risk of unsold stock, when the brand gets paid and how much each side keeps; it is used to pick the scheme for each retailer and category.

Production, logistics, channels Brand and retail Verified: 2026-11-14

Open interactively →

Why this document

With buyout the stock risk sits with the retailer, with commission and consignment with the brand, and cash arrives later and not always in full. So the brand’s finance director and the retailer’s buyer compare the schemes: both want to know who ends up financing the stock and what margin remains after unsold goods are returned. The choice affects working capital, taxes and the moment revenue is recognized. The scheme is therefore picked on cash and risk, not habit: for a new, unproven collection, consignment can cost the brand more than a buyout discount.

At a glance

What is this document and why is it needed?
A comparison of three ways to hand goods to a retailer: buyout, commission sale and consignment. It shows who owns the goods, who carries the risk of unsold stock, when the brand gets paid and how much each side keeps; it is used to pick the scheme for each retailer and category.
Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
The scheme is chosen by the brand’s commercial director with finance and legal at the terms stage; run operationally by sales and accounting; for the retailer by the buyer and finance.
What mistakes are the most common?
Ignoring the brand’s unsold remainder under commission → result overstated → estimate the exit price and include it. Brand cash counted at shipment date instead of payment date → cash shortage → a payment schedule by sales dates and lag. No reconciliation of sales with the retailer’s till → differences and losses → regular reconciliation and audit rights.

For whom

Brand
With buyout the brand is paid sooner and carries no stock risk; with commission and consignment the goods stay on the brand’s balance sheet until sold: cash comes later, the risk of unsold goods and returns is higher, and so is the dependence on the retailer’s sales reporting. The choice depends on brand strength and channels.
Retail
With buyout the retailer invests cash in stock and bears the price-reduction risk; with commission and consignment the stock does not cost it cash, but it earns less (a commission) and takes on duties of storage, reporting and custody. Department stores and marketplaces often demand commission or consignment for new brands.

What it consists of

1. How the schemes differ

  • Buyout: a supply contract; ownership passes on delivery, the retailer pays under the terms and is responsible for stock.
  • Commission sale: the retailer sells in its own name at the brand’s (principal’s) expense and receives a commission as a percentage of sales; the goods remain the brand’s property.
  • Consignment: goods are placed in the retailer’s warehouse, ownership passes at the moment of sale to the end customer; the retailer pays the brand the wholesale price of what sold, and unsold goods are returned at the end of the period.

2. Cycle documents

  • Contract and price annex, transfer certificate, sales report (weekly or monthly), reconciliation, return certificate for unsold goods, invoice or transfer document for what sold.

3. Terms

  • Placement period, minimum stock and display, who sets the price, commission or transfer price, payment term and procedure, storage and custody liability, return and price-reduction procedure.

4. Stock control and reconciliation

  • Retailer: Monthly count of consigned stock; reconciliation of sales between till and report; separate records of goods held in custody.

What each side does

  • Brand: computes cash at 60, 120 and 180 days and the return risk, keeps stock records at the partner and reconciles sales reports with the customer cash data.
  • Retailer: is responsible for storage and safekeeping, keeps separate records of the goods of others, gives the sales report on schedule and pays on time; before signing checks whether the scheme is qualified as supply with the risk on it.

Brand and retailer: what differs in practice

  • Brand: keeps goods at the consignee on its balance sheet and records: reconciles stock, transfers and returns weekly and by document numbers.
  • Brand: sets a leftover limit per point and a return term so as not to accumulate dead stock in other stores.
  • Brand: controls the sale price by recommendation or a contract term within competition law: independent consignee discounts break the calculation.
  • Brand: assigns insurance and theft risk of goods at the point to the consignee and checks the policy.
  • Brand: in settlements counts the fee and VAT separately for each report and does not accept a report without a list of sold units.
  • Retailer: does not pay for goods before sale but is responsible for storage, safekeeping and display of the leftover.
  • Retailer: asks for the right to reject weak items and return them within an agreed term before the goods lose value.
  • Retailer: checks that the fee and term of transferring proceeds cover the cost of storing and servicing such goods.
  • Retailer: accounts for commission goods off balance and does not include them in turnover and reserves of its own stock.

How to read the result and what decisions follow

  • Compare the models by cash and risk: consignment keeps stock and waiting for cash with the brand but gives the retailer readiness to widen the range.
  • The crossing of lines on the result chart is the sold share below which buyout is better for the brand: use it as a threshold when choosing a model for a new category.
  • Decision: a model by channel and category, leftover limit, return term, reconciliation schedule and payment procedure for what has sold.

Control checks

  • The stock at the consignee equals shipped minus sold minus returned and agrees in the brand records and the consignee report.
  • Payment for sold units equals the number of units times the wholesale price (consignment) or the sale price less commission (commission).

Checklist before signing a commission or consignment agreement (unverified: a reference, not legal advice)

  • The contract type is named under the Civil Code and the content matches: title, report, fee, return (there is no separate type consignment in the code, unverified).
  • The leftover limit, return term and procedure, liability for safekeeping and stock-count procedure are written down.
  • The report and settlement term is defined and the tax consequences (VAT and revenue recognition) are agreed with accounting (unverified).

Where the data comes from

Data sourceFields
Contract and termsscheme, price, commission, payment term, placement period, return procedure
Retailer salessold by day and style, stock, customer returns
Accountingtransfer documents, invoices, payments, certificates, reconciliation
Warehousestock in custody, return certificates, counts

How to build it step by step

  1. Brand: Step 1: Choose the scheme by customer: a strong brand goes buyout, a new brand commission or consignment; record the reason.
  2. Brand: Step 2: Compute each side’s result from the sales forecast: brand cash at 60, 120 and 180 days and each party’s result.
  3. Step 3: Fix in the contract the placement period, commission, price, payment term and return procedure.
  4. Retailer: Step 4: Draw up the transfer certificate and keep separate records of goods in custody.
  5. Retailer: Step 5: Receive the sales report on schedule and reconcile with till data; pay or accept payment on time.
  6. Step 6: At the end of the period do a count, process the return and decide where unsold goods go (outlet, another customer, price reduction).

Formulas

MeasureFormulasNote
Brand: Brand result under buyoutResult = units × (wholesale price − cost)Stock risk is with the retailer; the brand is paid under the deferral terms.
Brand: Brand result under commissionResult = retailer sales × (1 − commission) + returned units × exit price − cost of the whole lotUnsold goods stay with the brand: estimate the exit price (outlet, sale).
Retailer: Retailer result under consignmentResult = units sold × (sale price excl. VAT − wholesale price)The stock costs the retailer no cash but takes space and labor.
Brand: Brand cash by day dΣ over sales periods whose payment date ≤ d of (units sold × the price the retailer pays)Payment date = end of period + days under the contract.

Formulas in notation

Brand result on buyout
R_b = Q × (W − C)
Example: RUB 1,250,000 right after the payment term.
Brand result on commission
R_b = S × P_n × (1 − k) + (Q − S) × V − Q × C
S units sold, P_n sale price excl. VAT, k commission, V value of returned leftover. Example: RUB 1,307,341.
Brand result on consignment
R_b = S × W + (Q − S) × V − Q × C
Sold units are paid at the wholesale price. Example: RUB 908,000.
Sold share above which commission beats buyout
s* = (W − V) / (P_n × (1 − k) − V)
Example: 58%. Below s* a wholesale sale is better for the brand.

Worked example

The same lot of 1,000 units under different schemes: result and brand cash

SchemeBrand, RUBRetailer, RUBBrand cash, day 60Day 120Day 180Brand unsold, units
Buyout (goods purchased)1,250,0001,576,9672,400,0002,400,0002,400,0000
Commission sale1,307,3411,156,757471,8351,415,5061,887,341380
Consignment (sold units paid at wholesale)908,0001,556,098372,0001,116,0001,488,000380

620 of 1,000 units sold (62%) at RUB 4,910 excl. VAT. Under buyout the brand receives RUB 2,400,000 on day 45 and a result of RUB 1,250,000; the retailer, reducing the price of the remainder by 50%, gets RUB 1,576,967. Under commission at 38% the brand result is RUB 1,307,341 (unsold 380 units exited at RUB 1,500), the retailer’s RUB 1,156,757. Under consignment the brand gets RUB 908,000 and the retailer RUB 1,556,098. Under commission cash arrives as sales happen with a 20-day lag.

Figures

Brand cash by day: buyout, commission, consignment
Line chart: Buyout: 0 → 2.4m; Commission: 0 → 1.89m; Consignment: 0 → 1.49m0500k1m2m2m3m050100150Buyout, 0: 0Buyout, 30: 0Buyout, 45: 2.4mBuyout, 60: 2.4mBuyout, 90: 2.4mBuyout, 120: 2.4mBuyout, 150: 2.4mBuyout, 180: 2.4mCommission, 0: 0Commission, 30: 0Commission, 45: 0Commission, 60: 472kCommission, 90: 944kCommission, 120: 1.42mCommission, 150: 1.89mCommission, 180: 1.89mConsignment, 0: 0Consignment, 30: 0Consignment, 45: 0Consignment, 60: 372kConsignment, 90: 744kConsignment, 120: 1.12mConsignment, 150: 1.49mConsignment, 180: 1.49mRUB
  • Buyout
  • Commission
  • Consignment
Data as a table
MeasureBuyoutCommissionConsignment
0000
30000
452.4m00
602.4m472k372k
902.4m944k744k
1202.4m1.42m1.12m
1502.4m1.89m1.49m
1802.4m1.89m1.49m

Brand cash by day: buyout, commission, consignment. Cumulative receipts: on buyout all cash arrives at once after the payment term, under commission and consignment as sales and settlements occur. Sold 62% of a lot of 1,000 pcs; buyout paid after 45 days, settlements over four periods with a lag of 20 days. Illustrative figures.

Brand result and the sold share
Line chart: Buyout: 1.25m → 1.25m; Commission: 813k → 1.74m; Consignment: 620k → 1.16m600k800k1m1m1m2m2m30405060708090example shareBuyout, 30: 1.25mBuyout, 40: 1.25mBuyout, 50: 1.25mBuyout, 60: 1.25mBuyout, 70: 1.25mBuyout, 80: 1.25mBuyout, 90: 1.25mCommission, 30: 813kCommission, 40: 968kCommission, 50: 1.12mCommission, 60: 1.28mCommission, 70: 1.43mCommission, 80: 1.59mCommission, 90: 1.74mConsignment, 30: 620kConsignment, 40: 710kConsignment, 50: 800kConsignment, 60: 890kConsignment, 70: 980kConsignment, 80: 1.07mConsignment, 90: 1.16mRUB
  • Buyout
  • Commission
  • Consignment
Data as a table
MeasureBuyoutCommissionConsignment
301.25m813k620k
401.25m968k710k
501.25m1.12m800k
601.25m1.28m890k
701.25m1.43m980k
801.25m1.59m1.07m
901.25m1.74m1.16m

Brand result and the sold share. On buyout the result does not depend on the retailer sales; under commission and consignment it grows with the sold share and loses on leftover valued at the return price. Commission beats buyout for the brand at a sold share above 58%.

Result of the parties at a 62% sold share
Bar chart: Buyout 1.25m, Commission 1.31m, Consignment 908k0500k1m2m2mBuyoutBuyoutBrand: 1.25m1.25mRetailer: 1.58m1.58mCommissionCommissionBrand: 1.31m1.31mRetailer: 1.16m1.16mConsignmentConsignmentBrand: 908k908kRetailer: 1.56m1.56mRUB
  • Brand
  • Retailer
Data as a table
MeasureBrandRetailer
Buyout1.25m1.58m
Commission1.31m1.16m
Consignment908k1.56m

Result of the parties at a 62% sold share. The brand and retailer results differ under the three models; leftover under commission and consignment returns to the brand at the return price.

Specifics by category

Apparel
Apparel: the scheme depends on seasonality; seasonal remnants under commission return at season end and the exit price is usually lower; the calendar matters.
Footwear
Footwear: size remnants are harder to sell, so under commission the risk of returned broken size runs is high; rotation between stores is commonly built in.
Accessories
Accessories: long established on consignment (corners, department stores); high unit value and theft risk call for secure storage and counting.
Kids
Kids: seasonality by age and short size life; fast return of unsold goods matters more than for adults.
Men
Menswear: core items survive the season so consignment and commission lead to smaller losses; remnants can roll to the next season.
Women
Womenswear: fast fashion change and more sales; under commission the exit price of the remainder is critical, under buyout the retailer’s risk and demands for markdown support.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring the brand’s unsold remainder under commission → result overstated → estimate the exit price and include it.
  • Brand cash counted at shipment date instead of payment date → cash shortage → a payment schedule by sales dates and lag.
  • No reconciliation of sales with the retailer’s till → differences and losses → regular reconciliation and audit rights.
  • No separate records of goods in custody → confusion with the retailer’s own stock → separate locations or statuses.
  • Confusing consignment with commission in the contract → different ownership transfer and tax consequences → describe the moment of ownership transfer and settlement.

Russian specifics

  • The commission contract is governed by Ch. 51 of the Civil Code (Art. 990 et seq.): the commission agent sells in its own name at the principal’s expense; ownership stays with the principal. Rule: Civil Code part 2: Civil Code, part two (including Arts. 513, 713, 990, 1027).
  • There is no separate contract type for consignment in Russia: it is drawn up as a supply contract with a condition on the moment ownership passes, or as commission; agree the exact characterization and tax consequences (VAT, revenue recognition) with the accountant and lawyer; not verified in Lab.
  • The retailer issues the till receipt to the end customer; receipt data are reconciled with the report to the principal. Rule: Law 54-FZ of 22.05.2003: Federal Law of 22.05.2003 No. 54-FZ on the use of cash registers.

Open interactively →