Overdraft, factoring or inventory loan: which is cheaper
Compares three ways to cover a cash need for a term by total cost with fees and by effective annual rate. Bank terms are individual: enter rates from your own offers.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What is cheaper by full cost: overdraft, factoring or an inventory loan.
- What data is needed?
- The amount and term of the need.
- How to read the result?
- Compare the effective annual rate and the cost for the term together with what must be provided: invoices or stock. An option with an empty rate is excluded. Example on the default values: Cheapest by cost — RUB 444,521 · Overdraft; Effective annual rate of the cheapest — 27%; Difference from the dearest — RUB 50,913 · Factoring; Effective rate: Overdraft — 27%.
Why and how to reason
Three ways to cover a cash shortfall cost differently, and the contract rate does not show the full price: fees are not in it and the term can be short. So the full cost over your term and the effective annual rate (cost ÷ amount, annualized) are compared. You need RUB 10 million for 60 days. Overdraft: 10 × 24% × 60 ÷ 365 = 394.5 thousand + limit fee 0.5% (50 thousand) = 444.5 thousand ₽, effectively 27.0% a year. Factoring: to receive 10 million as an advance at 90% you need invoices of 11.1 million; commission of 1.5% of them (166.7 thousand) plus interest 328.8 thousand = 495.4 thousand, that is 30.1%. Inventory loan: 312.3 thousand + fee 1.5% (150 thousand) = 462.3 thousand, 28.1%. The cheapest is the overdraft; difference from the dearest 50.9 thousand ₽.
When to use it
Use it when you need money for a short term (seasonal purchase, cash gap) and banks or factors have given terms. Enter rates from your own offers: terms are individual. It does not fit long multi-year loans (schedule and collateral matter), floating-rate loans without a forecast, nor the decision whether to borrow: it compares ways, not whether money is needed. Keep in mind the options have different requirements: invoices, collateral, limit.
How to read the result
Look at cost in roubles and effective rate, but check what is required: factoring needs invoices of 11.1 million, the loan needs stock collateral of 20 million, the overdraft needs a limit. The cheapest option you cannot obtain is worth nothing. A difference of 50.9 thousand ₽ is small: then choose by speed and flexibility. A short term makes fixed fees dearer on an annual basis. Remember factoring may remove non-payment risk. Ask the bank and the factor for written terms with a full list of fees and recalculate the effective rate: the total is often several points above the stated one.
Common mistakes
The usual mistakes: comparing only rates; forgetting fees; missing that factoring charges also on the 10% not advanced; entering the loan term instead of the real need term; ignoring collateral requirements. Check that rates are annual. Do not enter the loan term instead of the term for which the money is really needed.
What data is needed?
- The amount and term of the need.
- Rates and fees from the bank and factor offers.
- The factoring advance and the collateral share of an inventory loan.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash needed | ₽ | 10,000,000 | How much money is needed for the term; for factoring it is the amount of receivables assigned. |
| For how many days | days | 60 | For how many days the money is needed. |
| Rate | % a year | 24 | A bank rate is usually above the key rate (the Bank of Russia key rate was 14.00% on 23.10.2026 (check the current one, next decision 18.12.2026)): use the terms from the bank’s offer. The default is an example. |
| Limit fee | % of amount | 0.5 | The bank’s fee for an overdraft limit in percent of the limit: from the contract; empty means zero. |
| Rate on the advance | % a year | 20 | The annual rate for the advance in factoring (financing fee), in percent. Take it from your contract. |
| Advance | % of invoice | 90 | Optional; if empty 100%. |
| Factor fee | % of invoice | 1.5 | The factor’s fee in percent of the invoice (the amount the buyer owes): from the factor’s offer; empty means zero. |
| Rate | % a year | 19 | The annual rate on a loan or overdraft from the bank contract, in percent. |
| Arrangement fee | % of amount | 1.5 | The loan origination fee in percent of the amount: from the loan agreement; empty means zero. |
| Loan to collateral value | % | 50 | Optional. Collateral stock needed: amount ÷ this share. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Overdraft | Amount × rate × days ÷ 365 + amount × fee |
| Factoring | Invoice × fee + amount × rate × days ÷ 365; invoice = amount ÷ advance |
| Inventory loan | Amount × rate × days ÷ 365 + amount × fee |
| Effective rate | Cost ÷ amount × 365 ÷ days |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Cheapest by cost
- 444,521 ₽ · Overdraft
- Effective annual rate of the cheapest
- 27 %
- Difference from the dearest
- 50,913 ₽ · Factoring
- Effective rate: Overdraft
- 27 %
- Effective rate: Factoring
- 30.1 %
- Effective rate: Inventory loan
- 28.1 %
Comparison of options
| Option | Cost for the term | Effective annual | What is needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overdraft | 444,521 ₽ | 27 % | An account limit |
| Factoring | 495,434 ₽ | 30.1 % | Invoices for 11.1 m ₽ |
| Inventory loan | 462,329 ₽ | 28.1 % | Stock pledged worth 20 m ₽ |
Compare full cost with fees, not the rate. A short peak is not covered by a long loan, and stock that does not sell is not worth financing at all. The rates in the example are illustrative, not market terms.
Nuances and limits
- Comparing the rate without fees.
- Taking a long loan for a short peak.
- Financing stock that does not sell.