Syntha Lab RU

Overdraft, factoring or inventory loan: which is cheaper

Compares three ways to cover a cash need for a term by total cost with fees and by effective annual rate. Bank terms are individual: enter rates from your own offers.

Owner’s cash and management dashboard For whom: Finance directors and owners who need cash for a peak.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What is cheaper by full cost: overdraft, factoring or an inventory loan.
What data is needed?
The amount and term of the need.
How to read the result?
Compare the effective annual rate and the cost for the term together with what must be provided: invoices or stock. An option with an empty rate is excluded. Example on the default values: Cheapest by cost — RUB 444,521 · Overdraft; Effective annual rate of the cheapest — 27%; Difference from the dearest — RUB 50,913 · Factoring; Effective rate: Overdraft — 27%.

Why and how to reason

Three ways to cover a cash shortfall cost differently, and the contract rate does not show the full price: fees are not in it and the term can be short. So the full cost over your term and the effective annual rate (cost ÷ amount, annualized) are compared. You need RUB 10 million for 60 days. Overdraft: 10 × 24% × 60 ÷ 365 = 394.5 thousand + limit fee 0.5% (50 thousand) = 444.5 thousand ₽, effectively 27.0% a year. Factoring: to receive 10 million as an advance at 90% you need invoices of 11.1 million; commission of 1.5% of them (166.7 thousand) plus interest 328.8 thousand = 495.4 thousand, that is 30.1%. Inventory loan: 312.3 thousand + fee 1.5% (150 thousand) = 462.3 thousand, 28.1%. The cheapest is the overdraft; difference from the dearest 50.9 thousand ₽.

When to use it

Use it when you need money for a short term (seasonal purchase, cash gap) and banks or factors have given terms. Enter rates from your own offers: terms are individual. It does not fit long multi-year loans (schedule and collateral matter), floating-rate loans without a forecast, nor the decision whether to borrow: it compares ways, not whether money is needed. Keep in mind the options have different requirements: invoices, collateral, limit.

How to read the result

Look at cost in roubles and effective rate, but check what is required: factoring needs invoices of 11.1 million, the loan needs stock collateral of 20 million, the overdraft needs a limit. The cheapest option you cannot obtain is worth nothing. A difference of 50.9 thousand ₽ is small: then choose by speed and flexibility. A short term makes fixed fees dearer on an annual basis. Remember factoring may remove non-payment risk. Ask the bank and the factor for written terms with a full list of fees and recalculate the effective rate: the total is often several points above the stated one.

Common mistakes

The usual mistakes: comparing only rates; forgetting fees; missing that factoring charges also on the 10% not advanced; entering the loan term instead of the real need term; ignoring collateral requirements. Check that rates are annual. Do not enter the loan term instead of the term for which the money is really needed.

What data is needed?

  • The amount and term of the need.
  • Rates and fees from the bank and factor offers.
  • The factoring advance and the collateral share of an inventory loan.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Cash needed₽10,000,000How much money is needed for the term; for factoring it is the amount of receivables assigned.
For how many daysdays60For how many days the money is needed.
Rate% a year24A bank rate is usually above the key rate (the Bank of Russia key rate was 14.00% on 23.10.2026 (check the current one, next decision 18.12.2026)): use the terms from the bank’s offer. The default is an example.
Limit fee% of amount0.5The bank’s fee for an overdraft limit in percent of the limit: from the contract; empty means zero.
Rate on the advance% a year20The annual rate for the advance in factoring (financing fee), in percent. Take it from your contract.
Advance% of invoice90Optional; if empty 100%.
Factor fee% of invoice1.5The factor’s fee in percent of the invoice (the amount the buyer owes): from the factor’s offer; empty means zero.
Rate% a year19The annual rate on a loan or overdraft from the bank contract, in percent.
Arrangement fee% of amount1.5The loan origination fee in percent of the amount: from the loan agreement; empty means zero.
Loan to collateral value%50Optional. Collateral stock needed: amount ÷ this share.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
OverdraftAmount × rate × days ÷ 365 + amount × fee
FactoringInvoice × fee + amount × rate × days ÷ 365; invoice = amount ÷ advance
Inventory loanAmount × rate × days ÷ 365 + amount × fee
Effective rateCost ÷ amount × 365 ÷ days

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Cheapest by cost
444,521 ₽ · Overdraft
Effective annual rate of the cheapest
27 %
Difference from the dearest
50,913 ₽ · Factoring
Effective rate: Overdraft
27 %
Effective rate: Factoring
30.1 %
Effective rate: Inventory loan
28.1 %

Comparison of options

OptionCost for the termEffective annualWhat is needed
Overdraft444,521 ₽27 %An account limit
Factoring495,434 ₽30.1 %Invoices for 11.1 m ₽
Inventory loan462,329 ₽28.1 %Stock pledged worth 20 m ₽

Compare full cost with fees, not the rate. A short peak is not covered by a long loan, and stock that does not sell is not worth financing at all. The rates in the example are illustrative, not market terms.

Nuances and limits

  • Comparing the rate without fees.
  • Taking a long loan for a short peak.
  • Financing stock that does not sell.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →