Cash flow statement: direct and indirect method
A report of where cash came from and where it went, split into operating, investing and financing activity. It explains why there is profit but no cash. It drives decisions on whether cash will cover purchases, payroll and taxes, and when to raise financing.
Why this document
Profit and cash diverge: goods are bought and sit in stock, wholesale is shipped on deferred payment, tax is paid later. The cash flow statement shows that gap in roubles. The finance director sees in which week cash runs out, the bank checks what you will repay the loan with, and the owner learns whether dividends are safe. That is why a growing, profitable business can still stall: rising inventory and receivables take cash faster than margin brings it in.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- A report of where cash came from and where it went, split into operating, investing and financing activity. It explains why there is profit but no cash. It drives decisions on whether cash will cover purchases, payroll and taxes, and when to raise financing.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The finance director or treasurer; actuals monthly, a 13-week forecast weekly; to the owner monthly together with the P&L, to the bank on request.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Cash is planned from profit → growth of inventory and advances is invisible, a cash gap appears → build the indirect cash flow and the “profit → cash” bridge. VAT mixed with revenue in one line → turnover and payments float by 22% → separate VAT and show budget payments as a separate line. An annual cash flow without a quarterly split → the minimum balance is hidden → split by weeks in the purchasing season.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand pays for fabric, sewing and import 3 to 9 months before sale and receives wholesale money with a 30 to 60 day deferral: between paying the factory and receiving the customer’s payment lies an end-to-end cash gap. In Model B profit is RUB 21.051 million but cash grew only RUB 2.351 million over the year: inventory took 7,324, loan repayment and dividends 12,000. Within the year the balance falls to −RUB 3.5 million in the second quarter, when purchasing runs ahead of sales.
- Retail
- A retailer gets money at once (till, acquiring in 1 to 2 days) and pays suppliers with a deferral, so the cash cycle is shorter, but the season makes the balance wave-like: before the season come purchases and payment of rent and capex, the main revenue falls in the fourth quarter. In Model R cash fell by RUB 18.234 million over the year despite a profit of 11,662: capex 18,300, loan repayment and dividends, inventory growth. The in-year minimum is −RUB 15.898 million in the third quarter: an overdraft or deferral of payments is needed.
What it consists of
Three sections
- Operating activities: receipts from customers, supplier payments, payroll, rent, taxes, interest. The key section: it shows whether the business earns cash by itself.
- Investing: capital expenditure (store fit-out, equipment, IT), purchase and sale of assets. For a retailer it is refurbishment and openings, for a brand tooling and IT.
- Financing: loans, their repayment, dividends, owner contributions.
Direct method
- Lines are actual cash flows by payment type: taken from the bank statement and till, classified by line. It shows which payments consumed cash and suits the payment calendar.
- Receipts from customers = revenue incl. VAT − increase in receivables ± change in loyalty liabilities. Payments to suppliers = purchases incl. VAT − increase in payables + increase in advances.
Indirect method
- Starts with net profit and adjusts: plus non-cash expenses (depreciation, reserve), minus growth of working capital (receivables, inventory, advances), plus growth of payables and other liabilities. It explains where profit went.
- Both methods must give the same operating cash flow; a difference means an error in classification or in the balance sheet.
The “profit → cash” bridge and seasonality
- The bridge: net profit → adjustments → cash flow. The main fashion consumers are inventory (purchasing runs ahead of sales), advances to factories and wholesale receivables. Use the “Profit versus cash” calculation.
- Seasonality: spread the annual cash flow by quarters or weeks using shares of receipts and payments, find the minimum balance and arrange financing in advance.
- The 13-week cash flow template: the rows are those of the direct method (receipts from customers, payments to suppliers, rent and marketing, payroll, VAT, corporate income tax, interest, capex, loans); columns: weeks 1 to 13 with “plan” and “actual” columns for each week. Closing balance of the week = opening balance + receipts − payments; week N+1 opens with the actual of week N, not the plan. A “minimum over 13 weeks” line and a “need = buffer − minimum” line sit under the table.
- The quarterly split in the example is conventional: taxes, interest and payroll are spread evenly, while VAT and corporate income tax are in fact paid on a calendar (VAT by the 28th of the month after the quarter in equal parts, corporate income tax advances monthly; the dates were not checked against the Tax Code text). So the in-year minimum depends on the chosen shares: in a working model replace the shares with dates from the payment calendar.
Brand and retailer: what is computed differently
- Brand: the largest flows are the factory prepayment and receipts from wholesale with a 45-day deferral and from platforms with 14 days: the minimum cash of -3,500 falls in the second quarter, before seasonal receipts.
- Retailer: cash arrives from the till and acquiring in 1 to 2 days while payments to brands run with a 60-day deferral; the minimum of -15,898 falls in the third quarter before the fourth-quarter peak, when a stock-backed line is needed.
Brand: how the document differs and what to add
- Brand: pays for fabric and sewing 3 to 9 months before sale: the main outflow falls in the first half of the season and wholesale receipts come later; the quarterly cash minimum of −RUB 3.5 million falls in Q2.
- Brand: receipts differ in speed: wholesale with a 45-day deferral, marketplace 14 days, own site at once; the wholesale deferral is the main shift between P&L and cash.
- Brand: the advance to the factory (5% of purchases in the model) leaves at order, not at shipment; at a 30% advance the cash minimum goes noticeably deeper, which is tested as a separate scenario.
- Brand: foreign-currency payments to factories are valued at the payment-date rate, not the order-date rate; the difference is shown in a separate line so it is not mixed with the operating result.
- Brand: marketplace payouts arrive net of commission, logistics, storage and penalties; in the direct method show the receipt and the deductions separately, otherwise the channel looks cheaper.
- Brand: wholesale partner returns and credit notes reduce the receipts of the next period; they are booked in the period of agreement and are provided for in the cash forecast in advance.
- Brand: import VAT and duty leave at the moment of import, before the goods are sold; the recoverable tax returns with a lag and temporarily freezes cash on top of the purchase price.
- Brand: loan repayment and dividends (RUB 6,000 and 6,000 thousand) are placed in quarters with a cash cushion rather than evenly; in the base schedule they fall in the second and fourth.
Retailer: how the document differs and what to add
- Retailer: revenue arrives at once through the till and acquiring (T+1 or T+2), receivables are only RUB 3.41 million; the gap is created by inventory and rent, not customers.
- Retailer: seasonality: the fourth quarter brings 30% of receipts while purchasing and rent run evenly; the cash minimum of −RUB 15.898 million falls in Q3, ahead of the peak.
- Retailer: the 60-day supplier deferral finances inventory: each 10 days of shortening takes RUB 9.097 million out of circulation (see “Working capital”).
- Retailer: rent is paid ahead on a schedule rather than from revenue: a fixed outflow of about RUB 3.528 million a month, which makes a weak-sales month dangerous for the cash balance.
- Retailer: bonuses: accrual of points defers part of revenue: the customer cash is received while revenue is recognized later; so growth of the bonus liability (RUB 1.046 million for the year) enters the indirect method with a plus sign and increases the flow; redemption of points later reduces future revenue without receipts.
- Retailer: store capex (RUB 15 million plus VAT of 3,300) goes to the investing section and leaves before opening; the payback flow arrives years later, so it is separated from the operating flow.
- Retailer: online returns reduce receipts in the period of the return and come with last-mile cost; the forecast for the weeks after a sales peak needs a separate outflow for returns.
- Retailer: cash in transit between the till, collection and the current account is shown in a separate line; otherwise the account balance will not agree with the cash book at the report date.
How to read the result and which decisions follow
- The quarterly cash minimum is below the monthly fixed base (payroll, rent, administrative): a credit line or a postponed payment is needed; the decision is made before the season purchase, not at the moment of the gap.
- Cash conversion (CFO ÷ EBITDA) in the base is 55% for the brand and 52% for the retailer; below 50% two periods in a row (a guide) means cash is stuck in stock or receivables: look at working capital and payment terms.
- Free cash flow after debt service is negative: dividends and new stores or collections are funded by debt; the decision: cut payouts first, then inventory, and only then borrow.
Control checks
- Closing cash in the cash flow equals the balance sheet figure and the sum of bank and till balances at the report date.
- The direct method minus the indirect equals VAT on capex (brand 880, retailer 3,300): otherwise a working-capital line is missing.
- Typical traps: VAT included now with, now without the tax, interest placed in both operating and financing flow, currency purchase shown as an expense, transfers between own accounts shown as receipts.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Bank statements and till (actual payments) | date, amount, counterparty, purpose, cash flow line |
| P&L and balance sheet (for the indirect method) | profit, depreciation, receivables, inventory and payables at the start and end |
| Shipment and payment schedule (wholesale), supplier schedules | shipment dates, deferral terms, payment dates under orders, advances |
| Calendar of taxes and mandatory payments | VAT, corporate income tax, contributions, due dates |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Set up a cash flow line list (1 to 2 levels) and link every payment purpose to it: without a list the report cannot be repeated.
- Step 2: Collect bank and till payments for the period and classify by line; exclude internal transfers between your own accounts.
- Step 3: Build the direct cash flow in the three sections; check that the closing balance equals the sum of balances on accounts and in the till.
- Step 4: Build the indirect cash flow from net profit and reconcile operating cash flow with the direct method; explain the difference.
- Step 5: Make the “profit → cash” bridge as one picture: profit, then large adjustments (inventory, receivables, advances, payables), then cash.
- Step 6: Split the annual plan by quarters and weeks: first receipts by sales seasonality and payment terms, then payments by the schedule of suppliers, payroll, rent and taxes.
- Step 7: Find the minimum balance and its date; compare with a buffer (for example 30 days of fixed costs) and compute the funding need.
- Step 8: Prepare scenarios (sales −10%, customer deferral +15 days, FX +10%) and show the minimum balance in each.
- Step 9: Agree the funding plan: what to take (overdraft, credit line, factoring), when and for how long; fix the decision before the purchasing season starts.
- Step 10: Every week reconcile plan and actual in the 13-week cash flow and refresh the forecast.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Operating cash flow (indirect) | OCF = NP + D&A + Reserve − ΔReceivables − ΔInventory − ΔAdvances + ΔPayables + ΔOther liabilities | Δ = closing minus opening value; take inventory before the reserve (the reserve is already added back). This formula gives OCF without VAT on capex: the full OCF that ties to the direct method is in the next line. |
| Full OCF with VAT on capex | OCF = NP + D&A + Reserve − ΔReceivables − ΔInventory − ΔAdvances + ΔPayables + ΔOther liabilities + VAT on capex, where VAT on capex = Capex excluding VAT × rate | Input VAT on fixed assets is deducted and reduces the payment to the budget: this is a saving in operating flow (the “VAT to the budget, net” line in the direct method), while the capex itself is shown in investing flow including VAT. So the indirect method needs a separate line; without it the methods differ by exactly this amount. An alternative is to show capex excluding VAT in investing flow and to leave input VAT in settlements with the budget inside operating flow. |
| Receipts from customers | Receipts = Revenue × (1 + VAT) − ΔReceivables + ΔLoyalty liabilities | For commission sales the base is the sum you actually receive from the principal or platform. |
| Free cash flow | FCF = OCF (with the VAT-on-capex offset) + ICF, where ICF = −capex including VAT | Both flows are on the same basis (incl. VAT), so FCF equals “OCF minus capex incl. VAT” and does not depend on where VAT on capex is classified. It pays interest on loans (if not in OCF), dividends and repays debt. |
| Funding need | Need = Buffer − Minimum balance within the year | If the minimum is above the buffer there is no need; compute by weeks, a quarterly minimum hides peaks. |
Formulas in notation
- Direct method
CFO = Recv − Pay_sup − Pay_opex − Pay_pers − Pay_tax − Int
Recv is receipts from customers, Pay_sup is payments to goods suppliers, Pay_opex is other operating payments, Pay_pers is payroll with contributions, Pay_tax is VAT and corporate income tax, Int is interest.- Indirect method
CFO = NP + D + ΔRes − ΔAR − ΔInv − ΔAdv + ΔAP + ΔPP + ΔVAT + ΔTax + ΔBon + VAT_cap
Start from net profit NP, add the non-cash D and ΔRes, then subtract growth of working-capital assets and add growth of liabilities. The term VAT_cap is the VAT on capex: it sits in ΔVAT as a deduction but is classified as investing, so it is added back in operating cash flow (880 in the brand example); without it the indirect total does not match the direct method.- Change in cash
ΔCash = CFO + CFI + CFF; Cash_1 = Cash_0 + ΔCash
CFI is the investing flow (capex with VAT), CFF is the financing flow (loans, repayments, dividends).- Cash conversion
Conv = CFO / EBITDA
The share of EBITDA that reached cash after tax, interest and working capital; a low value means frozen cash.
Worked example
End-to-end example: cash flow of the brand and the retailer, direct and indirect method, RUB thousand
| Line | Brand (Model B) | Retailer (Model R) |
|---|---|---|
| DIRECT METHOD | ||
| Receipts from customers (incl. VAT) | 252,098 | 623,030 |
| Payments to goods suppliers (incl. VAT, with advances) | −118,102 | −330,889 |
| Payments for expenses with VAT (rent, marketing, logistics, IT) | −56,690 | −136,354 |
| Other payments without VAT (acquiring) | −689 | −8,163 |
| Payroll with contributions | −33,911 | −93,260 |
| VAT to the budget (net) | −12,832 | −22,132 |
| Corporate income tax | −6,863 | −5,916 |
| Interest | −3,780 | −8,250 |
| FX differences on currency settlements (realized; 0 in the base case) | 0 | 0 |
| Cash flow from operations | 19,231 | 18,066 |
| Capital expenditure (incl. VAT) | −4,880 | −18,300 |
| Loan repayment | −6,000 | −10,000 |
| Dividends | −6,000 | −8,000 |
| Change in cash for the year | 2,351 | −18,234 |
| Opening cash | 12,000 | 20,000 |
| Closing cash | 14,351 | 1,766 |
| INDIRECT METHOD (the “profit → cash” bridge) | ||
| Net profit | 21,051 | 11,662 |
| + Depreciation | 3,200 | 11,000 |
| + Change in reserve (non-cash) | 439 | 672 |
| − Increase in receivables | −33 | −410 |
| − Increase in inventory (at cost, before reserve) | −7,324 | −8,394 |
| − Increase in supplier advances | 123 | −3,443 |
| + Increase in trade payables | 781 | 4,579 |
| + Increase in payroll, VAT, tax and loyalty liabilities | 114 | −900 |
| + VAT on capex (offset in budget settlements) | 880 | 3,300 |
| Cash flow from operations (indirect) | 19,231 | 18,066 |
| Difference between methods (must be 0) | 0 | 0 |
| SEASONALITY: closing cash by quarter | ||
| End of quarter 1 | 6,275 | 5,827 |
| End of quarter 2 | −3,500 | −11,266 |
| End of quarter 3 | 5,009 | −15,898 |
| End of quarter 4 | 14,351 | 1,766 |
| Minimum within the year | −3,500 | −15,898 |
The two methods differ by zero: for the brand 19,231 by the direct and 19,231 by the indirect method, for the retailer 18,066 and 18,066. The closing cash (14,351 and 1,766) equals the cash line in the balance sheet: this is the end-to-end check of the three statements. The quarterly split uses seasonality shares (brand receipts 22/24/26/28%, retailer 22/23/25/30%): an assumption for the example, replace it with your data.
Figures
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Net profit | — | 21,051 |
| Depreciation | +3,200 | 24,251 |
| Inventory reserve | +439 | 24,690 |
| Receivables | −33 | 24,657 |
| Inventory | −7,324 | 17,333 |
| Supplier advances | +123 | 17,456 |
| Payables | +781 | 18,237 |
| Payroll, VAT, tax, bonuses | +114 | 18,351 |
| Capex excl. VAT | −4,000 | 14,351 |
| Loan and dividends | −12,000 | 2,351 |
| Change in cash | — | 2,351 |
Profit-to-cash bridge, brand (Model B). There is profit but cash grew less: inventory, receivables, capex, loan repayment and dividends take the difference. The steps add up to the change in cash in the document table.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Net profit | — | 11,662 |
| Depreciation | +11,000 | 22,662 |
| Inventory reserve | +672 | 23,334 |
| Receivables | −410 | 22,924 |
| Inventory | −8,394 | 14,530 |
| Supplier advances | −3,443 | 11,087 |
| Payables | +4,579 | 15,666 |
| Payroll, VAT, tax, bonuses | −900 | 14,766 |
| Capex excl. VAT | −15,000 | −234 |
| Loan and dividends | −18,000 | −18,234 |
| Change in cash | — | −18,234 |
Profit-to-cash bridge, retailer (Model R). At the retailer inventory and payables pull in opposite directions and cash fell over the year despite a positive profit.
- Brand
- Retailer
Data as a table
| Measure | Brand | Retailer |
|---|---|---|
| Start | 12,000 | 20,000 |
| Q1 | 6,275 | 5,827 |
| Q2 | −3,500 | −11,266 |
| Q3 | 5,009 | −15,898 |
| Q4 | 14,351 | 1,766 |
Cash balance by quarter within the year. Within the year the balance goes negative before the year ends positive: the gap is visible only by quarter.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: two seasons a year, purchasing 4 to 6 months ahead; the expense peak at the start of the season, the receipts peak at the end; the cash minimum before the season.
- Footwear
- Footwear: longer production and more prepayments to factories, a costlier size inventory: the cash gap is wider than in apparel; factoring or a stock-backed line is needed more often.
- Accessories
- Accessories: weaker seasonality (a holiday peak), higher turnover, a shorter cash cycle; for jewelry the cost of materials is more significant.
- Kids
- Kids: sharp peaks (back to school, winter) and a large share of preorders; payments for materials and certification fall in the quiet period.
- Men
- Menswear: steadier sales and fewer seasonal spikes, so the gap is smaller and the forecast more accurate.
- Women
- Womenswear: more collections and drops, more frequent re-supplies and price reductions: a more volatile cash flow, a weekly forecast is needed.
Common mistakes
- Cash is planned from profit → growth of inventory and advances is invisible, a cash gap appears → build the indirect cash flow and the “profit → cash” bridge.
- VAT mixed with revenue in one line → turnover and payments float by 22% → separate VAT and show budget payments as a separate line.
- An annual cash flow without a quarterly split → the minimum balance is hidden → split by weeks in the purchasing season.
- Internal transfers counted as receipts → turnover overstated → exclude transfers between own accounts.
- Customer deferrals taken from the contract, not from the actual → receipts overestimated → compute the actual payment term from history (DSO).
- Dividends and loan repayment planned in the month of the cash minimum → a gap → schedule them after the seasonal peak.
Russian specifics
- The cash flow statement is part of financial statements under FSBU 4/2023; it has operating, investing and financing activities. The management cash flow is broader: with VAT, by line and by week. Rule: Order 157n of 04.10.2023: Ministry of Finance Order of 04.10.2023 No. 157n (FSBU 4/2023 Financial statements) (rule check not completed).
- Import payments pass currency control: take into account repatriation periods and contract documents; compute a foreign payment with the rate and the bank fee. Rule: Law 173-FZ of 10.12.2003: Federal Law of 10.12.2003 No. 173-FZ on currency regulation and control (rule check not completed).
- VAT is paid to the budget after the quarter in equal parts over the following three months (under the general Tax Code rule); check the exact term and procedure against the current edition of the Code.
- If part of sales goes under commission or agency terms, platform money (deductions, returns, penalties) goes on separate lines; fix the scheme in the accounting policy. Rule: Civil Code part 2: Civil Code, part two (including Arts. 513, 713, 990, 1027) (rule check not completed).