Syntha Lab RU

Zero-based budget: cost packages, priority and the effect of cut-off by level

Takes cost packages with priority, cost and effect, funds the mandatory ones and then by priority up to the limit, shows the cut-off line, the money saved and the effect of the cut packages; the table compares budget levels from 100% to 70% of the request.

Forecast and budget For whom: Chief financial officers, chief operating officers and owners when building the annual expense budget and when cutting costs.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
Which cost packages to fund within the limit, where the cut-off line runs and how much effect is lost per rouble saved.
What data is needed?
Cost packages: cost, priority, the mandatory flag.
How to read the result?
On the default data the request is 68,000,000 (the operating costs of Model B), of which mandatory 46,200,000 (67.9%). A 90% limit is 61,200,000: funded 58,600,000 (the mandatory ones and “Marketing: keeping channels” 12,400,000), the cut-off line before “Marketing: growth and new channels”; cut 9,400,000 (2 packages), lost effect 11,000,000, that is 1.17 per rouble saved. At the 85-70% levels keeping channels is cut too: saving 21,800,000, effect of the cut 51,000,000 (2.34 per rouble). The request is 3.3% above the prior budget. Example on the default values: Requested in total: RUB 68 million · 6 packages; Mandatory packages: RUB 46.2 million; Budget limit: RUB 61.2 million · 90% of the request; Funded: RUB 58.6 million. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

A budget “last year plus a percentage” carries past decisions into the future even if they are not needed. Zero-based budgeting makes you justify each cost package: why it is needed, what it costs and what it gives. Packages are split into mandatory (rent, payroll, accounting: always funded, 46.2 million) and optional, which are ranked by priority and by effect per rouble of cost. A limit of 90% of the request is 61.2 million on a request of 68 million. After mandatory ones 15 million remain, and packages go from the top down while they fit. The first package that does not fit and everything below it are cut. 58.6 million is funded, 9.4 million cut, the effect of the cut packages is 11.0 million, that is 1.17 per rouble of saving. This is the price of the decision: cutting the budget, you lose the effect.

When to use it

It fits when preparing the annual budget, when cutting costs and when distributing limited money between teams. Do not use it if the effect of packages cannot be assessed: the calculation relies on your estimates, which may be inflated. Assumptions: packages are independent, the effect of a package is linear, mandatory ones are set by a flag, priorities are assigned before the calculation. The method works well once every few years, and in between it is enough to review the most expensive packages.

How to read the result

Look at the cut-off line and the effect per rouble of saving. If it is 1.17 and more, the saving costs more than the effect lost, and the limit should be reviewed or other packages cut. If the effect is less than one rouble, the saving is justified. The first cut package (6.2 million) shows what you sacrifice first: check that it is not strategic. The table of levels from 100 to 70% shows how the loss of effect grows with each percent of cut. An overspend of the limit by mandatory packages is a signal that the limit is unrealistic. Write down who approves the cut-off line and by which criteria: without it an argument about packages turns into an argument about people.

Common mistakes

The usual mistakes: giving all packages the same priority, inflating effects “so they are not cut”, classing mandatory as optional, ignoring links between packages (cutting advertising while keeping what depends on it). Check effects against last period’s facts, not the team’s expectations.

What data is needed?

  • Cost packages: cost, priority, the mandatory flag.
  • The package effect (margin or avoided loss) and optionally the prior budget.
  • The limit as a share of the request.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Budget limit%90The share of the sum of requested packages within which you are ready to fund. Your decision, not a norm. The example value is illustrative.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Mandatorypackages flagged 1 are always funded
Rankingpriority ascending, then effect per rouble of cost descending
The limitsum of the request × the limit share; the mandatory ones are deducted first
Cut-off linegoing down while a package fits; the first that does not fit and all below are cut
Effectthe effect of the cut ones; divided by the saving; levels 100-70% are compared

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Requested in total
68 m ₽ · 6 packages
Mandatory packages
46.2 m ₽Not cut: rent, staff, law, contracts.
Budget limit
61.2 m ₽ · 90 % of the request
Funded
58.6 m ₽
Cut
9.4 m ₽ · 2 packages
Effect of the cut packages
11 m ₽The sum of your effect estimates for packages below the cut-off line.
Effect per rouble saved
1.17×How much effect you lose per rouble saved: above one means the cut is not worthwhile.
First cut package
6.2 m ₽ · Marketing: growth and new channels
Overrun of the limit by mandatory packages
0 ₽
Request against the prior budget
3.3 %The change of the request against the prior budget for packages where it is given.
Mandatory share of the request
67.9 %

Effect of cut-off by budget level

Level, % of requestLimitFundedSavingPackages cutEffect of the cutEffect per rouble savedMandatory covered
100 %68 m ₽68 m ₽0 ₽00 ₽—yes
95 %64.6 m ₽58.6 m ₽9.4 m ₽211 m ₽1.17×yes
90 % (yours)61.2 m ₽58.6 m ₽9.4 m ₽211 m ₽1.17×yes
85 %57.8 m ₽46.2 m ₽21.8 m ₽351 m ₽2.34×yes
80 %54.4 m ₽46.2 m ₽21.8 m ₽351 m ₽2.34×yes
70 %47.6 m ₽46.2 m ₽21.8 m ₽351 m ₽2.34×yes

The cut-off line: “Marketing: growth and new channels” and below (2 packages) do not fit the limit 61.2 m ₽. Saving 9.4 m ₽, lost effect 11 m ₽.

The priorities and effects are your expert estimates: test them against the previous period and with the package owners. The cut-off line is strict: a package below the first one that does not fit is not funded even if it is cheap. Amounts excl. VAT.

Nuances and limits

  • Estimate the package effect before the decision: without it the cut goes by feel.
  • Do not make mandatory what is merely habitual: mandatory is not cut.
  • For footwear, accessories and children’s the seasonal packages (season marketing, warehouse, returns) differ in size: take your own packages and not the example.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →