Management accounting: financial responsibility centers, overhead allocation, standard cost and the accounting policy
How to arrange internal accounting so that the head of each unit answers for their own numbers, overheads are distributed by a clear rule and the cost of a product is compared with a standard and shows where money is lost. The document answers: which structure of centers, which allocation keys and which standards to choose so that a decision to close a line, change a price or a channel rests on a stable calculation.
Why this document
The main gap in running a company is not a lack of reports but the lack of people accountable for the numbers. If overheads are simply divided by revenue, a line’s profit depends on its neighbors and the director does not know what they control. The finance director and the heads of units read this document when they build the structure of centers and choose rules. It explains how a cost center differs from a profit center, how an allocation key changes the sign of a line’s profit and how a standard and a variance show the cause of overspending. Without this, decisions to close a line are taken on a conditional number.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- How to arrange internal accounting so that the head of each unit answers for their own numbers, overheads are distributed by a clear rule and the cost of a product is compared with a standard and shows where money is lost. The document answers: which structure of centers, which allocation keys and which standards to choose so that a decision to close a line, change a price or a channel rests on a stable calculation.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The finance director is responsible for the structure of centers, the keys and the management accounting policy; unit heads for their own numbers; updated every quarter and before the budget; the owner sees it.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Dividing all overheads by revenue → successful lines look weaker and small lines that are costly to handle look better → choose the key by the cause of the cost and compare three keys. Closing a line by allocated profit → the overheads stay and fall on the others → decide by contribution and by how much of the overheads will go away. Changing keys mid-year → trends show a change of rules → introduce changes from the start of a period and recompute the past.
For whom
- Brand
- Brand: centers are built around the collection chain (design, buying, production, warehouse, sales channels); the standard cost of a product from fabric, trims and sewing gives a norm and the workshop and warehouse overheads are allocated to products by hours and orders.
- Retail
- Retailer: centers are built around stores, the online channel, the distribution center and buying by category; the overheads of rent, IT and the distribution center are allocated to stores and categories by area, turnover and number of operations and norms for losses and logistics replace production standard costing.
What it consists of
Financial responsibility centers
- A cost center: the head answers for costs within a budget and norms (warehouse, IT, accounting); the center has no revenue so it is assessed by variance from the budget and by service quality.
- A revenue center: the head answers for revenue and market share but not for costs (a wholesale sales department); assessment goes by the revenue plan and customer quality.
- A margin center and a profit center: the head answers for revenue and direct costs (margin) or for profit after overheads (a channel, a brand, a store); the metrics must depend on the head’s decisions.
- An investment center: the head also answers for invested capital (a new store, a production line); assessment goes by return on capital and payback.
- Brand: the centers are usually design and development, materials buying, production, the warehouse and each sales channel (wholesale, own retail, online, marketplaces); production and the warehouse are cost centers, channels are profit centers.
- Retailer: the centers are the store (a profit center), online (a profit center), the distribution center (a cost center), buying by category (a margin center); a region is a level above stores with its own profit.
Overhead allocation and standard cost
- Direct and indirect costs: direct costs go to the line without allocation (fabric, sewing, goods purchase), indirect ones must be divided; fixed and variable ones affect whether the cost disappears when a line is closed.
- Allocation keys: revenue (simple but punishes successful lines), units (fits homogeneous goods), area (rent and warehouse), hours or operations (the ABC approach, the most causal); the key is chosen by its link to the cost.
- Full and truncated cost: full includes a share of overheads and is needed for long-run pricing, truncated (direct costing) includes only variable costs and is needed for deciding whether to take an extra order.
- Standard cost: a norm for fabric and labor use and planned prices per unit of the product; actuals are compared with the standard and the difference is split into price, usage and capacity variances.
- Transfer prices between centers: the price at which production “sells” a product to a channel; it divides profit between centers and so is agreed in advance and not revised within the period.
- Brand: workshop overheads are divided by standard hours, warehouse overheads by orders and shipment lines, marketing by channel revenue; if some keys are not backed by data, leave that part as a separate unallocated line.
- Brand: the standard cost is built from the specification (fabric use including cutting waste, trims, operations) and revised every season; a standard without revision turns into an excuse for variances.
- Retailer: distribution center overheads are divided by cartons or lines, rent by area and turnover, IT and head office by the number of stores; norms for losses and write-offs replace production standards.
- Retailer: closing a store by allocated profit is wrong if the overheads stay; the decision is taken by the store’s contribution before overheads and by how much of the overheads will go away.
The management accounting policy and incentives
- There is no regulatory framework for management accounting: the company itself approves the structure of centers, keys, transfer pricing rules, the reporting frequency and rights to change; it is free practice and not a statutory duty.
- Tax and statutory accounting follow their own rules (Art. 252 of the Tax Code and accounting standards) and management accounting must not break them; the reconciliation of management and statutory profit must tie by item.
- Versioning: any change to keys or the structure of centers is introduced from the start of a period and accompanied by a recomputation of the past on the same basis, otherwise trends show a change in rules.
- Incentives by center: a head’s bonus is tied to the metrics they control and other centers’ overheads are shown below the line of controllable profit.
Brand and retailer: what to count differently
- Brand: the center report is built by collections and seasons and not by calendar months: development and material costs come before revenue and the profit of a month is misleading.
- Brand: the “wholesale” and “own retail” channels draw different overheads: wholesale requires shipments and receivables, retail requires stores and staff; do not divide them with one common key.
- Brand: show defects and dead stock on a separate line at the center that generates them (production, buying, design) and do not dissolve them in the common cost.
- Brand: to choose what to sew in-house and what to outsource compare full and truncated cost: for an own workshop fixed costs do not disappear when orders fall.
- Retailer: the center report is built by stores and categories from cash register data; comparability (LFL) requires the same set of points and periods.
- Retailer: store rent is a direct cost of the center while the distribution center and the office are overheads; do not allocate rent by revenue or a bad location looks better.
- Retailer: online and offline share the warehouse and marketing; keys by orders and by visits differ and the same pool gives different channel profits.
- Retailer: for category managers tie the bonus to gross margin and stock turnover and not to revenue, otherwise the category grows at the expense of discounts.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| The general ledger and cost breakdown by item | direct costs, overheads by center, periods |
| Driver data: units, hours, orders, area, shipment lines | driver volume by line and center |
| Specifications and use norms, purchase prices | material norm, price, standard hours, losses |
| Plan and actual sales by channel and line | revenue, units, returns |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Draw the structure of centers and assign for each an owner and a type (cost, revenue, margin, profit, investment).
- Step 2: Divide costs into direct and indirect, fixed and variable; for indirect ones identify the cause that generates them.
- Step 3: Choose a key for each overhead pool by causal link and data availability; for the rest keep a simple key and mark it conditional.
- Step 4: Compute line profit with three keys and compare; if the sign of profit changes, decisions on the line cannot rest on this number.
- Step 5: Set standards per product: material and labor norms, planned prices; compute the standard cost.
- Step 6: Every month compare actuals with the standard and split the difference into price, usage and capacity variances; look for the cause at the responsible center.
- Step 7: Fix the rules in the management accounting policy: keys, frequency, transfer prices, the order of change.
- Step 8: Reconcile management profit with statutory profit: the difference must be explained by a list of items.
- Step 9: Show the owner the centers’ contribution before overheads, profit after overheads and the main variances from norms; take closure decisions by contribution.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Line overhead by key | Overhead_i = Pool × Base_i ÷ Σ Base_j | Base: revenue, units, hours, orders or area; the sum over lines equals the pool. |
| Line profit | Profit_i = Revenue_i − Direct_i − Overhead_i | The contribution before overheads does not depend on the key. |
| Price variance | ΔP = (Actual price − Standard price) × Actual quantity | A plus means overspending. |
| Usage variance | ΔU = (Actual quantity − Standard quantity) × Standard price | The two variances add up to actual minus standard cost. |
Formulas in notation
- Overhead allocation
O_i = Pool * b_i / Σ_j b_j
Pool: the common overhead pool; b_i: the base of line i under the chosen key; Σ_j b_j: the sum of the base over all lines.- Variances from standard
ΔC = (p_a - p_s)·q_a + (q_a - q_s)·p_s
p: price, q: quantity, subscripts a and s: actual and standard; the first term is the price variance, the second the usage variance.
Worked example
The same overheads with three keys: line profit (illustrative data, RUB)
| Line | Contribution before overheads | Profit: by revenue | Profit: by units | Profit: by driver |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Outerwear | 24,000,000 | 17,076,923 | 21,471,910 | 22,500,000 |
| Footwear | 16,000,000 | 11,384,615 | 12,629,213 | 12,250,000 |
| Accessories | 5,500,000 | 4,115,385 | 1,455,056 | −500,000 |
| Kids | 7,500,000 | 5,423,077 | 2,443,820 | 3,750,000 |
| Total | 53,000,000 | 38,000,000 | 38,000,000 | 38,000,000 |
| Standard: material cost at the norm | 6,240,000 | |||
| Standard: actual material cost | 6,987,000 | |||
| Material price variance | 357,000 | |||
| Material usage variance | 390,000 |
The inputs are illustrative: overheads of 15 m RUB across four lines; the driver is the number of orders handled. The line “Accessories” changes sign: under the driver key it is loss-making, under the revenue and units keys it is not. Below: a material norm of 2.4 m per product at RUB 520 a meter, actual 2.55 m at RUB 548, an output of 5,000 products.
Figures
- Key: revenue
- Key: units
- Key: driver
Data as a table
| Measure | Key: revenue | Key: units | Key: driver |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outerwear | 17,077 | 21,472 | 22,500 |
| Footwear | 11,385 | 12,629 | 12,250 |
| Accessories | 4,115 | 1,455 | −500 |
| Kids | 5,423 | 2,444 | 3,750 |
Line profit under three allocation keys. Bars of one line on both sides of zero show that the conclusion depends on the key and not on the economics: this is how accessories behave.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Standard cost | +6,240 | 6,240 |
| Price variance | +357 | 6,597 |
| Usage variance | +390 | 6,987 |
| Actual cost | — | 6,987 |
The material cost bridge: from the standard to the actual. Overspending consists of the purchase price above the standard and fabric use above the standard; each has its own responsible unit.
Centers and overhead allocation. Cost centers pass overheads to profit centers by keys; a center’s profit is computed after allocated overheads and the contribution before them.
- Warehouse (cost center) → Keys: orders, area, revenue
- IT and office (cost center) → Keys: orders, area, revenue
- Keys: orders, area, revenue → Wholesale (profit center); Online (profit center); Retail (profit center)
- Wholesale (profit center)
- Online (profit center)
- Retail (profit center)
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: most of the cost is fabric and sewing, so the standard for fabric use and cutting waste gives the largest variances; a key by standard hours is more accurate than revenue.
- Footwear
- Footwear: a noticeable share of cost is lasts, tooling and soles; tooling overheads are divided by the number of models and sizes and not by revenue because it grows with the model and not with the price.
- Accessories
- Accessories: many small SKUs so warehouse overheads by shipment lines make the line noticeably more expensive than by revenue; here the driver key most often changes the conclusion.
- Kids
- Kids: the size range is wide and the share of returns and relabelling higher; divide returns handling overheads by the number of return lines and not by units.
- Men
- Men: stable basic models with a long life; standards change less often and material price variances read as a signal for buying.
- Women
- Women: a short cycle and many models so norms for new models are approximate; read the usage variance in the first season as a norm error and not as workshop inefficiency.
Common mistakes
- Dividing all overheads by revenue → successful lines look weaker and small lines that are costly to handle look better → choose the key by the cause of the cost and compare three keys.
- Closing a line by allocated profit → the overheads stay and fall on the others → decide by contribution and by how much of the overheads will go away.
- Changing keys mid-year → trends show a change of rules → introduce changes from the start of a period and recompute the past.
- Setting a standard once and never revising it → variances become permanent and interest nobody → revise standards every season.
- Rewarding a head for a metric they do not influence → numbers get massaged → tie the bonus to controllable profit.
Russian specifics
- Management accounting is not regulated by normative acts: the keys, the structure of centers and the standards are approved by the head of the company in an internal document.
- Tax accounting of costs follows Arts. 252 and 254 of the Tax Code and may differ from management accounting; show the difference in the reconciliation. Rule: Tax Code Art. 252: Tax Code, Art. 252 (expenses: justification and classification).
- Brand: if the brand applies the inventory standard (FSBU 5/2019), the standard cost in management accounting must tie to the actual measurement of inventory; fix the difference in the policy. Rule: Order 180n of 15.11.2019: Ministry of Finance Order of 15.11.2019 No. 180n (FSBU 5/2019 Inventories).
- Retailer: when cash registers and online cash registers (54-FZ) are used, sales data by store and item come from the cash system; reconcile them with the accounts at the center level. Rule: Law 54-FZ of 22.05.2003: Federal Law of 22.05.2003 No. 54-FZ on the use of cash registers.
- Transfer prices between related companies of a group are checked by the tax office under the rules on controlled transactions (not checked); internal prices between centers of one company are not of interest to the tax office.