Organization and incentives: RACI, KPI/OKR, bonuses, store payroll
The document sets who is responsible for what (RACI), what measures it (KPI/OKR) and how pay depends on it: the commercial bonus is tied to gross profit and turnover rather than revenue, and store payroll is built from hours needed. Decision: pay scheme, headcount and shifts, training program.
Why this document
HR, commercial and finance directors read this when they approve bonuses, headcount and store schedules. It matters because people do what they are paid for: a bonus on revenue pushes discounts and swells stock, a bonus on gross profit and turnover makes people watch margin and inventory. RACI ends the arguments about who decides, and payroll built from required hours stops you overpaying quiet hours and understaffing the peak. Without it, incentives work against the strategy.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- The document sets who is responsible for what (RACI), what measures it (KPI/OKR) and how pay depends on it: the commercial bonus is tied to gross profit and turnover rather than revenue, and store payroll is built from hours needed. Decision: pay scheme, headcount and shifts, training program.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Maintained by the HR director with the commercial and finance directors; the KPI scheme is approved by the owner or board and reviewed yearly and after a strategy change. For stores the schedule and payroll are kept by the store manager, the network summary by the operations director.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Bonus on revenue -> discounts for volume, margin falls -> tie to gross profit, turnover and full-price share. Too many measures -> nobody knows what matters -> 4–6 per role, weights from 15%. Measures outside the role control -> demotivation and disputes -> keep only what the role can change by decision.
For whom
- Brand
- For a brand, incentives revolve around product and margin: designers and product managers own full-price sell-through and fewer unsold styles, sourcing owns cost and lead times, commercial owns gross profit by channel, wholesale managers own receivables and repeat orders. The bonus must be linked to profit rather than volume.
- Retail
- For a retailer most staff work in stores: a salesperson pay scheme (salary plus sales percentage, team and personal bonus), payroll as a share of revenue, shifts matched to traffic, turnover and product training. Head office is measured by gross profit, turnover, availability and stock accuracy.
What it consists of
1. RACI by process
- Matrix: rows are processes (assortment planning, buying, pricing, receiving, replenishment, markdown, hiring, scheduling), columns are roles; each cell is R (does), A (accountable, exactly one per row), C (consulted), I (informed).
- Checks: exactly one A per row, no role with R in more than 40% of rows (overload), no row without R.
2. KPI and OKR
- KPI: 4–6 measures per role, each with weight, formula, data source, frequency and thresholds (floor, plan, cap). Gross profit carries at least a third of weight for the commercial role.
- OKR: a qualitative objective and 2–4 measurable key results per quarter; OKR is not tied directly to pay, or targets get sandbagged.
3. Commercial bonus scheme
- Bonus = base x sum of (weight x achievement), achievement capped; gate: if gross profit is below the plan threshold (for example 90%), no bonus is paid.
- Counter-volume measures: turnover and full-price share protect against discount-driven revenue; top-SKU availability protects against over-saving on stock.
4. Store payroll and shifts
- Retailer: Hours needed = opening hours x average floor staff x days; headcount = hours needed / hours per employee per month (from the production calendar).
- Retailer: Payroll/revenue, output per employee and per hour, overtime share, peak traffic coverage, turnover and replacement cost.
5. Training, EVP and ESOP
- Product training: fabrics, fit, care, season collection; a test and clearance for independent work; training is linked to conversion and average ticket.
- EVP (employer value proposition): pay, growth, product discount, schedule, culture. ESOP: shares or options as a retention tool for key staff, not a salary substitute; it needs a company valuation and legal structuring.
6. Brand and retailer: roles and metrics
- Brand: Brand roles: designer, technologist, production manager, wholesale sales manager, showroom. Production block KPIs: share of styles on calendar, share of lots without defects (AQL), material purchase forecast accuracy.
- Retailer: Retailer roles: buyer, category manager, planner, store director, salesperson, visual merchandiser. Buying KPIs: sell-through, full-price share, turnover, top-SKU availability, dead-stock share.
- Brand: Wholesale manager: a bonus on shipments, but with gates on paid receivables (overdue above a threshold zeroes part of the bonus) and on client returns and claims; otherwise wholesale is grown through payment terms.
- Retailer: Store director: a bonus on store gross profit with gates on losses (shrink) and turnover; a revenue-only bonus encourages discounts and rent per m² growth.
- Brand: Training and qualification: the technologist and quality manager train on test and acceptance standards; the result is measured by the rate of lots returned to the factory and repeat samples.
- Retailer: Floor staff training: collection knowledge, care, size grid, fitting script; clearance for solo work after a test, with test results tied to conversion and UPT per salesperson.
- Brand: ESOP and long-term incentives: for a growing brand equity stakes retain key product and production roles; vesting terms and share valuation are agreed with a lawyer (unverified).
- Retailer: Retailer seasonal staff: hiring before peaks, a fixed term, fast training, KPIs for peak days; turnover is counted separately for permanent and seasonal employees.
How to read the result and which decisions follow
- The bonus is RUB 1,256,728 at a sum of weighted achievement of 104.7%. “Full-price sales share, %” pulls it down (93.5%). Decision: the bonus must be tied to KPIs the manager influences, and the gross-profit gate protects against a bonus for turnover growth at the cost of margin.
- Brand: KPIs follow the chain product, sale, cash: gross profit, inventory turnover, full-price share, top-SKU availability. Decision: the production team has KPIs on quality and deadlines with a separate gate so that speed is not bought at the cost of defects.
- Retailer: in stores KPIs depend on visitors and staffing: by the formula for 12 stores at 30 days and 2.5 people on the floor about 5.4 FTE are needed. Decision: tie the store bonus to conversion, ticket and shrinkage, not only revenue, and limit it with a ceiling.
- Brand: the sensitivity table shows that at actual profit -20% the payout is RUB 0 thousand because of the gate, and at +20% RUB 1.353 million because of the ceiling. Decision: the ceiling sets the payroll overrun risk; check it on scenarios before approving the scheme.
- Retailer: the cost of replacing an employee is about RUB 170,000 (two monthly salaries in the assumption), the store payroll share is 8.5% of revenue. Decision: count retention as money: turnover is more expensive than a moderate premium.
Formula derivation and sensitivity tables
- Derivation of the bonus formula. Each KPI has a weight w_i, the weights sum to 1. Achievement a_i = fact / plan is limited by the ceiling cap. The weighted sum S = Σ w_i × a_i equals 1 when all plans are met, so Bonus = Base × S pays the base at plan and grows with over-achievement up to Base × cap.
- Derivation for a lower-is-better KPI: for the score to grow as the fact falls, a_i = plan / fact is taken; at a fact half the plan a_i = 2, so the ceiling is mandatory.
- Derivation of the gate: Bonus = Base x S x 1[a_GP >= g], where 1[.] is an indicator; the gate g = 0.9 turns a linear scheme into a stepped one: at a_GP = 0.89 the payout is 0, at 0.90 already RUB 0 (code).
- Numeric payout sensitivity table, RUB thousand (rows actual profit -20..+20%, columns actual turnover -20..+20%): -20%: 0 / 0 / 0 / 0 / 0; -10%: 1,138 / 1,171 / 1,204 / 1,237 / 1,266; 0%: 1,191 / 1,224 / 1,257 / 1,290 / 1,319; +10%: 1,244 / 1,277 / 1,310 / 1,342 / 1,371; +20%: 1,287 / 1,320 / 1,353 / 1,386 / 1,415.
- Brand: the KPI weight sets the price of an error: a change of weight by 10 pp changes the payout by 0.1 x (a_i - 1) of the base; do not set a weight above what the KPI owner really influences.
Control checks
- Check: the weights sum to 100%, the payout equals the base times the sum of weighted achievement (RUB 1,256,728, code).
- Brand: the bonus scheme is approved by a local act and the employment contract; check bonus terms and the procedure for changing them against labor law (unverified).
- Retailer: schedules and overtime are computed under labor law; the load formula is planning, not norming (unverified).
- Brand: the ceiling and gate must be recorded before the period starts; a rule changed after the fact destroys trust in the scheme.
- Retailer: take KPI data from the accounting system, not from the report of the KPI owner; otherwise a conflict of interest arises.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Accounting system and sales reports | Gross profit, revenue, receipts, stock, turnover by employee, store, category |
| HR records and timesheets | Headcount, salaries, accruals, contributions, leave, overtime, exits |
| Footfall counters and tills | Entries by hour, conversion, receipts by hour and day |
| Recruitment and training data | Time to fill, hiring cost, test results, time to reach target output |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1. Describe processes and roles; fill the RACI and apply the rules (one A, no empty R).
- Step 2. Choose 4–6 measures per role tied to the role decisions; drop those the role cannot influence.
- Step 3. Set weights, thresholds and cap; check that the maximum payout is affordable at the cap.
- Step 4. Add gates on gross profit and availability; document how measures are computed and who confirms them.
- Step 5. Back-test the scheme on past data: what would have been paid last quarter and what behavior it rewards.
- Retailer: Step 6. Compute store hours needed from hourly traffic; build the schedule within working-time limits.
- Retailer: Step 7. Compute store payroll with contributions and compare with its share of revenue; check output per hour.
- Step 8. Measure turnover and replacement cost; find causes in exit data and surveys.
- Step 9. Start product training with a test; link test results to conversion.
- Step 10. Review plan and actual under the scheme quarterly and re-check weights and thresholds yearly.
- Brand: Step 11. Brand: tie the wholesale manager KPI to paid revenue and returns and the technologist KPI to the defect-free lot share; check that no role is responsible for both discounts and quality.
- Retailer: Step 12. Retailer: set store director KPIs on gross profit, losses and turnover; reconcile the shift schedule with the hourly traffic curve at least once a season.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Measure achievement | Achievement = min(actual / plan; cap) for higher-is-better; = min(plan / actual; cap) for lower-is-better | The cap (for example 130%) guards against payouts for lucky over-performance; a lower threshold zeroes the contribution. |
| Bonus | Bonus = base x sum (weight_i x achievement_i) if gates passed, else 0 | Weights sum to 100%; gates are on profit so volume is not bought with discounts. |
| Retailer: Headcount need | Headcount = opening hours x days x average floor staff / employee hours per month | Add a reserve for leave and sickness; for variable traffic compute by hour. |
| Retailer: Payroll to revenue | Payroll share = (headcount x employee cost with contributions) / store revenue | Employee cost includes insurance contributions; the share depends on format and category. |
| Replacement cost | Replacement = hiring + training + lost output during ramp-up | For salespeople it is often several monthly salaries; the number in the example is notional. |
Formulas in notation
- KPI achievement
a_i = min(fact_i / plan_i, cap)
For higher-is-better KPIs; for lower-is-better a_i = min(plan_i / fact_i, cap); cap is the ceiling (1.3 in the example).- Required store staff
FTE = Stores × Days × Floor staff / Hours
Monthly hours per employee under the schedule; the formula gives workload, not headcount.- Store payroll share
s = Heads × Cost / Revenue × 100
Heads is the number of employees, Cost the cost of an employee per month.
Worked example
Exercise: commercial director quarterly bonus
| Measure | Weight | Plan | Actual | Achievement | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gross profit, RUB m | 40% | 120.0 | 132.0 | 110.0% | 44.0% |
| Inventory turnover, turns per year | 25% | 3.2 | 3.5 | 109.4% | 27.3% |
| Full-price sales share, % | 20% | 62.0 | 58.0 | 93.5% | 18.7% |
| Top-SKU availability, % | 15% | 92.0 | 90.0 | 97.8% | 14.7% |
| Sum of weighted achievement | 104.7% | ||||
| Payout, RUB (base 1,200,000) | 1,256,728 |
Notional: the gate (gross profit at least 90% of plan) was passed; the sum of weighted achievement is 104.7%, payout RUB 1,256,728. Gross profit above plan lifts the bonus, but weak full-price share and availability pull it down: the scheme does not let profit be bought with discounts. A 6-person store: floor need is 5.4 FTE at 2.5 people on the floor for 12 hours a day; payroll RUB 510,000 a month is 8.5% of revenue of RUB 6.0m; replacing one employee is estimated at RUB 170,000. Numbers are notional.
Figures
- Achievement
- Weighted contribution
Data as a table
| Measure | Achievement | Weighted contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Gross profit, RUB m | 110 | 44 |
| Inventory turnover, turns per year | 109 | 27.3 |
| Full-price sales share, % | 93.5 | 18.7 |
| Top-SKU availability, % | 97.8 | 14.7 |
KPI achievement and contribution to the bonus. Plan achievement for each KPI and the contribution with weight: full-price share is below plan and pulls the bonus down.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Base | — | 1.2m |
| Gross profit, RUB m | +48k | 1.25m |
| Inventory turnover, turns per year | +28.1k | 1.28m |
| Full-price sales share, % | −15.5k | 1.26m |
| Top-SKU availability, % | −3,913 | 1.26m |
| Payout | — | 1.26m |
Bonus bridge: from base to payout. The bonus base and deviations by KPI from 100% achievement; the total is the payout in roubles.
Data as a table
| Measure | Payout |
|---|---|
| 80% | 0 |
| 85% | 0 |
| 90% | 0 |
| 95% | 1.18m |
| 100% | 1.21m |
| 105% | 1.23m |
| 110% | 1.26m |
| 120% | 1.3m |
| 130% | 1.35m |
Payout and the gross-profit gate. Payout at different gross-profit achievement: below 90% the bonus is zeroed regardless of the other KPIs.
- 0 … 1,415 RUB k
Data as a table
| Turnover -20% | Turnover -10% | Turnover 0% | Turnover +10% | Turnover +20% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Profit -20% | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Profit -10% | 1,138 | 1,171 | 1,204 | 1,237 | 1,266 |
| Profit 0% | 1,191 | 1,224 | 1,257 | 1,290 | 1,319 |
| Profit +10% | 1,244 | 1,277 | 1,310 | 1,342 | 1,371 |
| Profit +20% | 1,287 | 1,320 | 1,353 | 1,386 | 1,415 |
Payout as the actuals shift: profit and turnover. Payout in RUB thousand as actual gross profit and turnover change by ±10% and ±20%: a sensitivity estimate of the scheme.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Productivity and turnover are measured against seasonal peaks: in apparel hall load varies 2-3 times between February and December (an assumption), so schedules follow hourly traffic, not the average shift. Salesperson KPIs: conversion, UPT (units per transaction), set share; a bonus as a percentage of revenue pushes sellers to discounted items, so add a weight for the full-price share. Product training: fabrics, fit, care, a collection change every 6-8 weeks.
- Footwear
- A footwear seller needs foot-measuring skill and last-based fitting: KPIs such as “share of fittings with a second pair brought out” and “size returns” matter more than conversion alone. Back-room work is heavier: boxes, fitting, finding sizes; compute labor hours with a storage adjustment (for example +10-15% over floor time, an assumption). Link motivation to size-run completeness on the shelf: a broken run hurts sales more than low traffic.
- Accessories
- Sales are mostly quick and expensive per unit: fewer labor hours per receipt but a higher price of error (theft, mix-up, substitution). Add losses and count accuracy to KPIs, not only revenue; display zones need a schedule with mandatory presence. Gift advice and wrapping are seasonal: before holidays (for example the winter holidays, 8 March, 23 February) temporary staff and training 1-2 weeks before the peak are required.
- Kids
- Peaks fall on the back-to-school season (July-September) and New Year; the rest of the year productivity is low, so the share of temporary and seasonal staff is higher. The seller must know the height run (6 cm step) and age groups and fit by height with a growth allowance. Expectations for work with children and parents are higher: courtesy in queues, fitting-room safety. Judge turnover by hiring season: seasonal hires cannot be compared with permanent staff.
- Men
- Productivity per employee is steadier, the ticket is higher thanks to suits and outerwear, and the impulse share is lower. A menswear seller influences add-on sales more (a shirt with a suit, a belt, shoes): the key KPI is UPT and the add-on share. The customer spends less time in the store, so service must be faster; a conversion bonus is more useful here than one on visit counts. Tailoring services (alterations) are a separate line with its own price and lead time.
- Women
- Traffic and the weekend peak are higher, with more merchandising and re-merchandising for trends: staff load rises at collection changes and markdowns. Stylists and consultants influence the average ticket more; client-base KPIs help (share of clients with a profile, repeat visits). Fit returns are higher, so training includes fit consulting and vanity sizing. Discount sensitivity is higher: the bonus scheme must curb selling for revenue at a discount, otherwise the full-price share falls.
Common mistakes
- Bonus on revenue -> discounts for volume, margin falls -> tie to gross profit, turnover and full-price share.
- Too many measures -> nobody knows what matters -> 4–6 per role, weights from 15%.
- Measures outside the role control -> demotivation and disputes -> keep only what the role can change by decision.
- Payroll cut without traffic analysis -> lost sales at peak -> hourly traffic shifts and payroll as a share of revenue with a conversion check.
- ESOP instead of salary -> key people leave over low current income -> ESOP as an addition, with vesting terms and legal structuring.
Russian specifics
- Normal working time is no more than 40 hours a week; shift schedules and timesheets must respect this (Art. 91 of the Labor Code). Rule: Labor Code Art. 91: Labor Code, Art. 91 (working time).
- Overtime is paid at no less than 1.5 times for the first two hours and no less than twice thereafter (Art. 152 of the Labor Code); include this in payroll for tight schedules. Rule: Labor Code Art. 152: Labor Code, Art. 152 (overtime pay).
- Insurance contribution rates and the cap base change; take current values from the norm registry for payroll and check them at the calculation date. Rule: Tax Code Art. 427: Tax Code, Art. 427 (reduced contribution tariffs) (rule check not completed).
- Brand: with in-house production and civil-law contracts with self-employed people and sole traders check for signs of an employment relationship; consequences of requalification and contributions are unverified, a lawyer assesses them.
- Retailer: store shift schedules, night and holiday hours, working-time records and overtime follow the Labor Code; check surcharge calculation and schedule approval with HR (details unverified).