Cost of a motivation scheme: a percentage of sales or a bonus for the plan
Compares two bonus schemes for a store: a percentage of all sales and a percentage of sales above the plan. Shows the cost with contributions, the margin gain at the expected sales growth, the growth at which the scheme pays back and the loss at zero effect.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- Which bonus scheme is cheaper and whether it pays for what sells anyway.
- What data is needed?
- Revenue, margin, expected growth and contributions.
- How to read the result?
- Sales growth of 5% gives 135,000 of margin. Scheme A (1.5% of all sales) costs 122,850 with contributions, a net 12,150; scheme B (5% above a plan of 6.1 m) costs 13,000, a net 122,000. Scheme A pays back from growth of 4.53% and pays 117,000 even at zero growth. Example on the default values: Margin gain from the sales growth: RUB 135,000; Scheme A: bonus with contributions: RUB 122,850; Scheme A: net result: RUB 12,150; Scheme B: bonus with contributions: RUB 13,000. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
A bonus scheme should pay for what you want to get and not cost more than the effect. We compare two. Scheme A pays a percentage of all sales: 1.5% × 6.3 million × 1.3 (contributions 30%) = 122,850 a month. Scheme B pays a percentage of sales above plan: 5% × (6.3 million − 6.1 million) × 1.3 = 13,000. The effect of 5% sales growth is 300 thousand of revenue × 45% margin = 135,000. Result of scheme A = 135,000 − 122,850 = 12,150, of scheme B = 135,000 − 13,000 = 122,000. The main difference: if growth does not happen, scheme A still pays 117,000 a month (a permanent addition to costs) while scheme B pays nothing. The growth at which scheme A pays back = percent × (1 + contributions) ÷ (margin − percent × (1 + contributions)) = 1.95 ÷ 43.05 = 4.53%: scheme A pays only if growth is at least 4.5%.
When to use it
It comes in handy when choosing a pay system for stores, setting a plan and agreeing a bonus. It suits a retailer and a brand with retail. It does not replace a pilot: the expected sales growth is your estimate. Assumptions: contributions on bonus are constant; the plan under scheme B is fair and reachable; the scheme does not change behavior for the worse (discounts for the plan, pushiness). Check wording with an accountant and a lawyer.
How to read the result
First “loss at zero growth”: scheme A spends 117 thousand a month even if sales do not grow: this is the price of insurance, not a result-based bonus. Then “growth at which the scheme pays back”: compare with the store’s real potential. If growth is higher the scheme works; if lower it pays in vain. Scheme B is safer for the business but can demotivate if the plan is unrealistic. Best is a pilot in some stores with control ones (see “Chain pilot”): it will show real growth. Watch that staff do not chase the plan at any cost: discounts and pushiness hurt margin.
Common mistakes
Counting the bonus without contributions: it looks 30% cheaper. Setting the plan under scheme B below the real level: the scheme turns into scheme A. Not accounting for part of the growth that would have happened without the scheme. Paying on sales without deducting returns and sale items: staff sell what gives a bonus, not profit.
What data is needed?
- Revenue, margin, expected growth and contributions.
- Percentage of scheme A, of scheme B and the plan.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue a month without the scheme | ₽ | 6,000,000 | Excl. VAT (if you pay VAT and deduct it). Confirm your regime and rate with an accountant. |
| Gross margin | % | 45 | Margin share in revenue excl. VAT. |
| Expected sales growth from the scheme | % | 5 | An estimate, replace with a pilot result. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Contributions on the bonus | % | 30 | The general contribution rate of 30% (2026); enter your own. |
| Scheme A: a percentage of all sales | % | 1.5 | A bonus on every rouble of sales. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Scheme B: a percentage of sales above the plan | % | 5 | A bonus only on sales above the plan. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Plan for scheme B | ₽ | 6,100,000 | Monthly revenue from which the bonus starts. Above current sales: otherwise you pay for what sells anyway. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Bonus A | percentage × revenue with the scheme × (1 + contributions) |
| Bonus B | percentage × max(0; revenue with the scheme − plan) × (1 + contributions) |
| Result | sales growth × margin − bonus |
| Pay-back growth of A | percentage × (1 + contributions) ÷ (margin − percentage × (1 + contributions)) |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Margin gain from the sales growth
- 135,000 ₽Sales growth × gross margin.
- Scheme A: bonus with contributions
- 122,850 ₽
- Scheme A: net result
- 12,150 ₽
- Scheme B: bonus with contributions
- 13,000 ₽
- Scheme B: net result
- 122,000 ₽
- Scheme A: the growth at which it pays back
- 4.5 %
- Scheme A: loss at zero growth
- −117,000 ₽A bonus for sales that would have happened anyway.
- Scheme B: loss at zero growth
- 0 ₽Is non-zero only if the plan is below current sales.
The schemes at the expected growth
| Scheme | Bonus with contributions | In revenue | Net result | At zero growth |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: percentage of all sales | 122,850 ₽ | 1.95 % | 12,150 ₽ | −117,000 ₽ |
| B: percentage above the plan | 13,000 ₽ | 0.21 % | 122,000 ₽ | 0 ₽ |
Scheme A pays 117,000 ₽ a month even if sales do not grow: it is a permanent addition to costs. Scheme B pays only for growth above the plan.
Check that the scheme does not encourage the wrong things: discounts for the plan, pushing, disputes over customers. A bonus on sales net of returns and of clearance items is often fairer. A pilot in some stores with control stores (see “Pilot in a chain”) will show the real growth.
Norms (a guide as of 13.11.2026, check against the act text): Labour Code; Tax Code, part two. Check with an accountant and a lawyer.
Nuances and limits
- A plan below current sales turns the bonus into a supplement.
- Confirm sales growth with a pilot with control stores.