Syntha Lab RU

Returns, non-pickup and fines on platforms: causes, losses by size, defects and logistics

A breakdown of what happens to goods after an order on a platform: how refusal, non-pickup and return differ, how to count losses by size and cause, which fines for defects and logistics occur and how to contest them. It decides where to change the size grid, the card and the packing and how much to put into the price for returns.

Production, logistics, channels Brand and retail Verified: 2026-11-14

Open interactively →

Why this document

Returns in fashion cannot be removed, but they can be broken down by cause to see which of them depend on you. If you look only at the overall return rate, it looks like “buyer behavior”. If you split by size, color, lot and cause, it shows that a part of the losses is created by the grid, a part by quality, a part by the card, and each can be treated. The marketplace manager, the product manager and the finance person read this document: the first finds problem items, the second fixes the grid and patterns, the third counts the cost of returns. It gives an order of diagnosis and shows how losses grow from the center of the size run to the edges.

At a glance

What is this document and why is it needed?
A breakdown of what happens to goods after an order on a platform: how refusal, non-pickup and return differ, how to count losses by size and cause, which fines for defects and logistics occur and how to contest them. It decides where to change the size grid, the card and the packing and how much to put into the price for returns.
Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
The marketplace manager with the product manager and the finance person; a weekly returns report, a review of causes monthly; the results go to production and into the card.
What mistakes are the most common?
Only the overall return share is watched → the problem size is not visible → analysis by size, color and lot. Returns are treated with a discount → margin falls, the cause remains → fix the grid and the card. A fine is accepted without a basis → unjustified deductions accumulate → request the document and contest on time.

For whom

Brand
The brand sees the cause in the product: patterns, fit, fabric, the size table; a size return gives a signal to fix the grid, and a defect goes to the factory and to acceptance.
Retail
The retailer sees the cause in the range and presentation: an incomplete size run, other brands with different fits, description errors; try-on returns hit harder on season remainders.

What it consists of

What refusal, non-pickup and return are

  • Refusal: the buyer refused at delivery or did not pick up the order; the goods returned to the warehouse before buyout; forward and reverse logistics are paid, there is no sale
  • Non-pickup: the order was not bought out: cancellation, non-receipt or refusal; for the calculation the buyout share matters, that is kept ÷ ordered
  • A return after receipt: the buyer returned the goods within the term provided by law and platform rules; revenue is reduced, logistics and acceptance fall on the seller by the scheme rules
  • Defect and return with a defect: goods with a production defect or damage in delivery; responsibility is determined by the cause, for defects the seller is usually liable, for damage in delivery compensation is possible
  • Resale: a good return goes back on sale, with wear or signs of use it is written off; the share fit for sale determines the real cost of a return

Fines and deductions

  • A defect fine: the platform deducts money when the buyer returned goods with a defect; photos and an act are needed to check or contest
  • A logistics fine: a missed shipment term, wrong packing, wrong marking and size; prevention through a packing regulation and scanning
  • A fine for description and content: a mismatch between the card and the goods or wrong characteristics; check photos and composition before posting
  • The sizes of sanctions and the terms are defined by the offer; there are no figures in this document on purpose, take them from the offer on the date of the calculation
  • Contesting: file a claim on time with evidence; without photos of packing and an acceptance act the chance of cancellation is low

Diagnosis by size, color, lot

  • Size: the return share grows from the center of the size run to the edges; a peak on extreme sizes means the grid does not match bodies; a hint to fix the table of measurements and grading
  • Color and lot: higher returns of one color or lot mean a problem of fabric, dyeing or sewing; check a sample and pass it to the factory
  • Causes: the return reason given by the buyer is grouped into size, quality, expectation and delivery; each has its own treatment
  • Money: losses = number of returns × (forward + reverse logistics + acceptance + write-off share × cost); estimate the effect of a fix in money to prioritize
  • Control: after fixing the grid or the card watch the return trend of the same item for at least two weeks

Differences for the brand and the retailer

  • Brand: Product fix: the brand changes patterns, grading, fit and the table of measurements from returns data; this gives an effect in the next lots.
  • Brand: Defects: defects go to the factory and defect fines are counted in the lot cost and in product acceptance.
  • Brand: Card: the brand adjusts the description, photos and model parameters so the buyer expectation matches the item.
  • Brand: Policy: the brand decides how to match the platform return rules with the rules of other channels.
  • Retailer: Incomplete run: the retailer lists only models with a sufficient run; a piece of a run gives failed try-ons and returns.
  • Retailer: Different brands: every brand has its own fit; keep a separate returns table by brand and use it in size advice.
  • Retailer: Repricing: a return at the end of the season will not go back on sale at the former price; count the cost of a return with the price reduction.
  • Retailer: Store stock: a platform return may go back to the warehouse or to a store; keep unified records so as not to lose a size.
  • Brand: Factory: the brand passes data on size returns to the factory for fixing patterns and grading.
  • Retailer: Size advice: the retailer uses a table of returns by brands for size advice in the card.

Where the data comes from

Data sourceFields
The platform report on orders, returns and causesitem, size, color, cause, status, deduction amount
Acceptance acts and photos of returnscondition, fitness for sale, defect
Brand records: cost, lots, size gridcost, lot, measurements, grading

How to build it step by step

  1. Step 1: Take data for a period of at least 4 weeks for every item: ordered, kept, returned, cause, size.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the buyout and return shares by item and by size; find sizes where the share is above the item average.
  3. Brand: Step 3: Compare the problem size with the measurement, pattern and grading; if returns grow toward the edges of the run, fix the grading and the table of measurements.
  4. Retailer: Step 3: Match returns with run completeness and brand; a piece of a run or a brand with an atypical fit is removed from the platform or given a size tip.
  5. Step 4: Break causes into size, quality, expectation and delivery; assign an action owner for each.
  6. Brand: Step 5: Pass defects to the factory with photos and the lot number; demand compensation under the contract and strengthen incoming control.
  7. Retailer: Step 5: Pass defects and damage to the supplier under the supply contract; record acts at return acceptance.
  8. Step 6: Estimate losses in money by the formula, choose three actions with the maximum effect and put them in the plan.
  9. Step 7: Check the fines: justification, basis, term; contest unjustified ones with evidence; close repeating causes by a process.

Formulas

MeasureFormulasNote
Losses from returnsLosses = N_returns × (Λ_fw + Λ_rt + acceptance + write-off_share × cost)For footwear and seasonal items keep the write-off share higher.
Return share by sizer_s = returns_s ÷ shipped_sTake the size as the unit of analysis: the average share hides the problem of extreme sizes.

Worked example

Illustrative returns by size: return share and losses (200 units ordered per size; logistics 90 + RUB 80, acceptance RUB 10, write-off 10% of the cost RUB 1,500; figures are illustrative)

SizeReturns, %Returns, pcsLosses, RUB
4223.04615,180
4419.03812,540
4615.0309,900
4819.03812,540
5023.04615,180
5227.05417,820

Returns grow from the center of the run (size 46) to the edges; losses on extreme sizes are noticeably higher. This is a signal to fix the grading and not to lower the price. Figures are illustrative.

Figures

Return causes by size, % of the size returns
Heat map: 6×4; min 12.1, max 51.6Size did not fitSize didnot fitQuality and defectQualityand…Not as expectedNot asexpectedDeliveryDelivery424248.342 / Size did not fit: 48.317.242 / Quality and defect: 17.221.642 / Not as expected: 21.612.942 / Delivery: 12.9444444.444 / Size did not fit: 44.418.544 / Quality and defect: 18.523.144 / Not as expected: 23.113.944 / Delivery: 13.946464046 / Size did not fit: 402046 / Quality and defect: 202546 / Not as expected: 251546 / Delivery: 15484844.448 / Size did not fit: 44.418.548 / Quality and defect: 18.523.148 / Not as expected: 23.113.948 / Delivery: 13.9505048.350 / Size did not fit: 48.317.250 / Quality and defect: 17.221.650 / Not as expected: 21.612.950 / Delivery: 12.9525251.652 / Size did not fit: 51.616.152 / Quality and defect: 16.120.252 / Not as expected: 20.212.152 / Delivery: 12.1
  • 12.1 … 51.6 %
Data as a table
Size did not fitQuality and defectNot as expectedDelivery
4248.317.221.612.9
4444.418.523.113.9
4640202515
4844.418.523.113.9
5048.317.221.612.9
5251.616.120.212.1

Return causes by size, % of the size returns. The share of “size did not fit” grows toward the edges of the run; other causes depend little on size.

Losses from returns by size
Bar chart: 42 15.2k, 44 12.5k, 46 9,900, 48 12.5k, 50 15.2k, 52 17.8k05,00010k15k20k4242Losses: 15.2k15.2k4444Losses: 12.5k12.5k4646Losses: 9,9009,9004848Losses: 12.5k12.5k5050Losses: 15.2k15.2k5252Losses: 17.8k17.8kRUB of losses
Data as a table
MeasureLosses
4215.2k
4412.5k
469,900
4812.5k
5015.2k
5217.8k

Losses from returns by size. The edges of the size run lose the most; the center of the run is closer to the average.

Specifics by category

Apparel
Apparel: the main cause of returns is size and fit; treated by a table of measurements and model parameters; check shrinkage and composition.
Footwear
Footwear: last and width; a return with wear is not resold; losses are higher, so treat the cause and not the effect.
Accessories
Accessories: returns by expectation and color and not by size; accurate photos and scale reduce them.
Kids
Kids: returns by the child’s height and safety; a conformity check and careful acceptance are needed.
Men
Men: fewer returns, the cause is more often the fit of shirts and trousers; exact measurements decide.
Women
Women: the most returns; fit, fabric and several sizes in an order; model parameters and an accurate table cut them the most.

Common mistakes

  • Only the overall return share is watched → the problem size is not visible → analysis by size, color and lot.
  • Returns are treated with a discount → margin falls, the cause remains → fix the grid and the card.
  • A fine is accepted without a basis → unjustified deductions accumulate → request the document and contest on time.
  • Packing is not photographed → no evidence in a dispute → record packing and condition at shipment.
  • The entire return is counted as fit → resale is overstated → set the write-off share by category.

Russian specifics

  • A return of goods of proper quality in distance selling within 7 days after delivery, provided the presentation is kept (the consumer protection law, Art. 26.1); platform rules must not worsen the buyer rights. Rule: Law 2300-1 of 07.02.1992: Law of 07.02.1992 No. 2300-1 on consumer rights protection.
  • The rules of accepting returns, the order of fines for defects and logistics, their sizes and dispute terms are defined by the platform offer and rules; check on the date of the calculation.
  • Brand: For light-industry goods return and write-off affect marking: the code must be withdrawn from circulation by the rules; check the rules.
  • Retailer: A return and resale of marked goods require correct work with the code; clarify the procedure with the operator and the platform.

Open interactively →