Own warehouse or 3PL: cost per order and break-even volume
Adds up fixed and variable costs of receiving, storage, picking, packing and returns for your own warehouse and for a logistics operator (3PL), shows the cost of an order and of a unit, the volume at which each option wins and how the difference changes when volume grows or falls.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What is cheaper at our volume: an own warehouse or a logistics operator.
- What data is needed?
- Orders, units per order, receiving, stock and returns for a month.
- How to read the result?
- With 6,000 orders a month the own warehouse costs 1.54 m (256 per order) and the 3PL 0.90 m (150 per order). The own warehouse starts to win from 23,787 orders a month, about 4× the current volume. Example on the default values: Own warehouse a month: RUB 1.54 million; 3PL a month: RUB 900,400; Own warehouse: cost per order: RUB 256; 3PL: cost per order: RUB 150.07. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
An own warehouse and a logistics operator (3PL) are built differently: an own warehouse has a large fixed part (rent, wages, equipment) and a small variable one; an operator has a small fixed part and a variable one for every unit and order. So the answer to “which is cheaper” depends on volume and must be compared at several. Own warehouse = fixed + orders × (picking + packing) + receiving × rate + returns × rate = 900,000 + 6,000 × 85 + 12,000 × 6 + 2,160 × 25 = 1.536 million a month. 3PL = fixed fee + receiving + storage + order picking with a surcharge per additional unit + packing + returns = 50,000 + 108,000 + 140,000 + 537,600 + 64,800 = 900,400. An order costs 256 against 150. Break-even: the volume at which the fixed part of the own warehouse spreads out: 23,787 orders a month, that is four times the current.
When to use it
It fits when choosing a logistics model, when volume grows or falls and when revising tariffs. It suits an online shop and a brand with an online channel. It does not replace requesting offers from operators and a test. Assumptions: the own warehouse’s fixed costs are unchanged across the whole range of volume (in fact growth needs a second shift, racks, space); investment in equipment and launch is not included, add it to fixed costs through depreciation.
How to read the result
Compare the cost of an order and a unit in the two options and find the break-even volume. If it is several times higher than current, the operator is cheaper and needs no investment. If close, take growth into account: what volume you will reach in a year. But do not look only at price. For a 3PL, lead times, picking accuracy, penalties for errors, the price of returns and access to stock matter. An own warehouse gains from control and seasonal flexibility. Then look at warehouse flows in the “Warehouse flows” calculation and at the last mile. The decision: stay on the current model, switch or request offers.
Common mistakes
Comparing rates without the surcharge for each additional unit in an order: with an operator it can be significant. Not including the manager’s pay and equipment rent in the own warehouse. Forgetting the operator’s minimum monthly fee. Counting returns the same in both options: with an operator they are usually dearer.
What data is needed?
- Orders, units per order, receiving, stock and returns for a month.
- Fixed and variable costs of the own warehouse.
- Rates from the operator’s offer: receiving, storage, picking, packing, returns.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Orders a month | orders | 6,000 | Shipped orders in an average month of the season. |
| Units per order | pcs | 1.8 | Average units in an order: affects picking. |
| Receiving a month | pcs | 12,000 | Units received from factories and suppliers in a month. |
| Average stock on hand | pcs | 40,000 | Units held on average in a month. Drives the storage fee at a 3PL. |
| Returns, share of units | % | 20 | Share of units coming back to the warehouse. It is higher for apparel than in other categories; use your own. For footwear and dresses online the return share is usually above the store average (trying several sizes); for children’s it depends on the child’s height, accessories have no sizes. We give no guide without your own data: take your own statistics by category and channel. |
| Fixed warehouse costs | ₽ | 900,000 | Rent, utilities, security, the stock system, staff at minimum load. Excl. VAT. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Picking and packing, per order | ₽ | 85 | Variable labor and materials per order. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Receiving, per unit | ₽ | 6 | Unloading, checking and putaway of one unit. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Returns handling, per unit | ₽ | 25 | Receiving, checking, cleaning and restocking one unit. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Fixed fee | ₽ | 50,000 | A subscription or the minimum monthly fee under the contract. Empty or 0: none. |
| Receiving, per unit | ₽ | 9 | From the operator’s offer. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Storage, per unit a month | ₽ | 3.5 | The operator may charge per pallet position or per unit: convert to a unit. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Picking an order | ₽ | 55 | The first unit of an order. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Picking each further unit | ₽ | 12 | Empty or 0: picking does not depend on the number of units. |
| Packing and materials, per order | ₽ | 25 | Box, bag, filler. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Returns handling, per unit | ₽ | 30 | From the operator’s offer. An example: enter your own data, there is no single standard in Russia. |
| Peak: how many times more orders | × | 1 | 1: no peak, as before. The multiplier of orders in the peak month of the season; the peak costs use the same rates. |
| Peak months in a year | months | 2 | Needed for the annual costs with the peak; at a multiplier of 1 it has no effect. |
| Capacity of the own warehouse, orders a month | orders | — | Optional. How many orders the own site ships a month: the calculation shows the peak load (see the “Warehouse capacity” calculation). Empty: not counted. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Own warehouse | fixed + orders × (picking + packing) + receiving × rate + returns × rate |
| 3PL | fixed + receiving × rate + stock × storage + orders × (picking + (units − 1) × surcharge + packing) + returns × rate |
| Break-even volume | multiplier k = (own fixed − 3PL fixed) ÷ (3PL variable − own variable); orders × k |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Own warehouse a month
- 1.54 m ₽
- 3PL a month
- 900,400 ₽
- Own warehouse: cost per order
- 256 ₽
- 3PL: cost per order
- 150.07 ₽
- Own warehouse: cost per shipped unit
- 142.22 ₽
- 3PL: cost per shipped unit
- 83.37 ₽
- Cheaper at the current volume
- 635,600 ₽ · 3PLThe difference in monthly costs.
- Volume from which the own warehouse wins
- 23,787 orders · 3.96×The crossing of the two cost lines: as volume grows, stock, receiving and returns are assumed to grow in proportion to orders.
Costs at another order volume
| Orders a month | Own warehouse | 3PL | Own, per order | 3PL, per order | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3,000 | 1.22 m ₽ | 475,200 ₽ | 406 ₽ | 158.4 ₽ | 3PL |
| 6,000 | 1.54 m ₽ | 900,400 ₽ | 256 ₽ | 150.07 ₽ | 3PL |
| 9,000 | 1.85 m ₽ | 1.33 m ₽ | 206 ₽ | 147.29 ₽ | 3PL |
| 12,000 | 2.17 m ₽ | 1.75 m ₽ | 181 ₽ | 145.9 ₽ | 3PL |
| 24,000 | 3.44 m ₽ | 3.45 m ₽ | 143.5 ₽ | 143.82 ₽ | own |
The own warehouse starts to win from 23,787 orders a month, 4× the current volume. Until then the 3PL is cheaper and, importantly, needs no investment or permanent space.
The own warehouse’s fixed costs are held constant over the whole range of volumes; growth by several times needs a second shift, racking or space. Investment in equipment and start-up is not included: add it to the fixed costs through depreciation.
Look beyond the price: at a 3PL, lead times, picking accuracy, penalties for errors, the price of returns and the handling of product labelling matter; fix them in a service-level agreement. A sale peak may be served at a higher price or more slowly.
Empty = 0 in the fields: Capacity of the own warehouse, orders a month. If that is not the case, fill them in: the result will change.
Norms (a guide as of 13.11.2026, check against the act text): Tax Code, part two. Check with an accountant and a lawyer.
Nuances and limits
- Do not compare picking alone: storage and returns are charged separately by an operator.
- The own warehouse’s fixed costs grow in steps as volume grows.
- Check service terms and penalties for errors against the contract.