Syntha Lab RU

Last mile by delivery type: courier, pickup point, post

Compares delivery types to the customer by the full cost to you: the carrier’s rate minus the customer’s fee, the return leg and the margin lost on refused parcels. Shows the weighted cost of an order, its share of the basket and margin, the lead time and the gain from shifting a share of orders to a cheaper type.

Warehouse, fulfillment and the last mile For whom: Delivery managers and commercial directors.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
Which delivery type is cheaper for us allowing for refusals.
What data is needed?
Average order, margin and number of orders.
How to read the result?
The full delivery cost averages 273 per order: net delivery 120.5 and the cost of refusals 152.5 (6.1% of the basket, 13.5% of order margin). Courier 339.5, post 181.25. Shifting 10 pp of orders from courier to post gives 94,950 a month. Example on the default values: Net delivery per order: RUB 120.5; Cost of refusals per order: RUB 152.51; Full delivery cost per order: RUB 273.01; Share of the average order: 6.1%. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

The last mile seems an item to compare by tariff: courier 350, pickup point 180, post 220. But the tariff is not the full price. Net delivery = tariff − customer fee. Non-collection adds a hidden part: cost of non-collection = refusal share × (return carriage + order value × margin), because the refusing customer brought no margin and the goods still have to be brought back. In the example courier: 350 − 150 = 200 of net delivery plus 6% × (300 + 4,500 × 45%) = 139.5 of non-collection, total 339.5. Pickup point: 80 + 174 = 254. Post: 70 + 111.25 = 181.25. By tariff the pickup point is cheapest (180), but by full price, with the customer fee and non-collection, post is cheaper (181 against 254): the tariff misleads. Weighted full price 273 per order, 6.1% of the order and 13.5% of margin; delivery for the month 1.64 million. Shifting 10 pp of orders from the most expensive type to the cheapest gives 94,950 a month.

When to use it

Reach for it when choosing delivery services, revising tariffs and deciding which delivery type to promote. It suits an online shop and a brand with an online channel. It does not suit a case without an estimate of non-collection by type: take your own statistics, not the market average. Assumptions: count the customer fee excluding VAT if you pay it; with free delivery over an order value enter fee 0; tariffs in contracts change, check against the annex.

How to read the result

Compare full price by type, not tariff: the cheapest by tariff is not always cheapest by full price because its non-collection may be higher. Then the share of delivery in order margin: if above your attention threshold delivery eats profit. The benefit of a shift shows whether to encourage the customer to change type (a discount for pickup points, free delivery above a threshold). Watch lead time: the cheapest may be the slowest and conversion will fall. The decision: which type to promote, what fee to set, with which carrier to revise the tariff.

Common mistakes

Taking non-collection share as an average rather than by delivery type. Not accounting that you pay twice for return carriage (tariff there and back). Counting the customer fee with VAT. Shifting orders to the cheap type without checking lead time: conversion may fall more than the gain.

What data is needed?

  • Average order, margin and number of orders.
  • By type: order share, rate, customer fee, refusals, return leg, lead time.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Average order excl. VAT₽4,500For orders delivered to customers.
Gross margin%45Share of margin in the price excl. VAT: needed to estimate the loss on refused parcels.
Orders a monthorders6,000To convert into money for the month.
Share of orders to shift, pp%10How many percentage points of orders to shift from the costliest type to the cheapest.
Attention threshold: delivery share of order margin (optional)%—Optional. There is no single standard in Russia: set your own. If empty, the metric has no color.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Net deliveryrate − customer fee
Cost of refusalsrefusal share × (return leg + basket × margin)
Shiftshifted share × (full cost of the costly − full cost of the cheap) × orders

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Net delivery per order
120.5 ₽Rate minus the customer’s fee, averaged over the types.
Cost of refusals per order
152.51 ₽Refusal share × (return leg + lost margin).
Full delivery cost per order
273.01 ₽
Share of the average order
6.1 %
Share of order margin
13.5 %Set your own attention threshold in the field above: there is no single standard in Russia.
Delivery for the month
1.64 m ₽
Average lead time
3.1 days
Costliest type
339.5 ₽ · Courier
Cheapest type
181.25 ₽ · Post
Gain from shifting the share of orders, per month
94,950 ₽ · 10 p.p.Does not allow for the customer refusing another type and for the lead time changing.

Delivery types: cost to you

TypeShareNet deliveryCost of refusalsFull costLead time, days
Courier35 %200 ₽139.5 ₽339.5 ₽2
Pickup point or locker50 %80 ₽174 ₽254 ₽3
Post15 %70 ₽111.25 ₽181.25 ₽6

The cheapest type by rate is not always cheapest by full cost: it may have a higher refusal rate, and the return and lost margin may cost more than the delivery itself. Check the refusal rate of each type in your own statistics.

Count the customer’s delivery fee excl. VAT if you pay it; with free delivery above an order amount put a fee of 0. Carrier rates change: check against the current appendix to the contract.

Empty = 0 in the fields: Attention threshold: delivery share of order margin (optional). If that is not the case, fill them in: the result will change.

Nuances and limits

  • The cheapest by rate is not always cheapest by full cost.
  • Take rates from your contract: none are built in.
  • The customer may not agree to another type.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →