Syntha Lab RU

First-order discount: CAC and LTV

Calculates the margin of a discounted first order, repeat purchases over 90 and 180 days, the acquisition cost and the customer payback period; compares with spending the same money without a discount if you have a control group.

Promotions: planning and evaluation For whom: Marketers and online store heads paying for acquisition with a discount.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
Does a customer who came on a first-order discount pay back and is that better than acquisition without a discount.
What data is needed?
The discount, number of new customers, first basket excl. VAT, margin at full price.
How to read the result?
At a 20% discount the margin of the first order is 1,750 (loss on the discount 1,000) and CAC is 2,000: the customer pays back within 90 days (2,245), over 180 days 2,575 and the cohort earns 575,000. 75% did not come back. A control group without a discount for the same spend earns 695,000, which is 120,000 more. Example on the default values: Margin of the first order — RUB 1,750; Loss on the discount per customer — RUB 1,000; Customer margin over 90 days — RUB 2,245; Customer margin over 180 days — RUB 2,575.

Why and how to reason

A first-order discount buys a new customer, but the brand pays out of margin. So we compute two numbers: what the customer brought and what he cost. First order: ticket RUB 5,000, margin 55%, discount 20%, so order margin 5,000 × (0.55 − 0.20) = RUB 1,750, loss on the discount RUB 1,000. Repeat orders: in 90 days 0.18 orders × 5,500 × 50% = RUB 495, in 180 days 0.3 × 2,750 = RUB 825. Customer margin over 90 days RUB 2,245, over 180 days RUB 2,575. Acquisition cost (CAC) 2 million ÷ 1,000 = RUB 2,000: the customer pays back in 90 days. Cohort profit over 180 days 1,000 × (2,575 − 2,000) = 575 thousand ₽. But a control group without discount (700 customers, 0.4 orders in 180 days) would have brought 700 × 3,850 − 2 million = 695 thousand: the discount does not win here.

When to use it

Reach for it when launching a new-customer discount and evaluating its effect by cohort. You need real repeat orders at 90 and 180 days, and a control group without discount makes the conclusion reliable. It does not fit one-off purchase goods or products where the second purchase comes after a year. If there is no control group, compare at least with a past cohort and remember that without control the conclusion is weak.

How to read the result

Look at customer payback time and cohort profit. If a customer pays back longer than the horizon you are willing to fund, the discount is too deep. Comparison with control answers the main question: did the discount bring more customers than it lost in margin. If control gives more profit, as here, cut the discount or replace it with a gift. The non-returning share (75%) suggests repeat-purchase work matters more than discount depth. If the control shows the discount does not win, test a replacement: a gift with the first order, free delivery, or a smaller discount with a higher basket threshold.

Common mistakes

Typical trap: counting customer margin before the discount; using yearly repeat orders instead of 180 days; ignoring that discount hunters come and do not return; leaving out acquisition costs. Acquisition costs must be the same as in the control. Do not wait for a yearly customer payback if you pay for acquisition every month.

What data is needed?

  • The discount, number of new customers, first basket excl. VAT, margin at full price.
  • Repeat orders per customer over 90 and 180 days and the share who came back.
  • Optional: acquisition spend and a control group without a discount.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
First-order discount%20The first-order discount in percent.
New customerspeople1,000How many new customers came through the offer.
Average first basket before discount, excl. VAT₽5,000Price excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026. The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant.
Margin at full price%55Gross margin of a first order at full price, as a percent of revenue excl. VAT.
Acquisition spend (optional)₽2,000,000Advertising and everything that brought these customers. Empty: zero.
Repeat orders per customer in 90 daysorders0.18Cumulative: how many repeat orders came per new customer.
Repeat orders per customer in 180 daysorders0.3The average number of repeat orders per customer within 180 days after the first.
Came back within 180 days%25Share of customers with at least one repeat order. The rest did not come back (“bargain hunters” and one-off buyers). Empty: not shown.
Repeat basket excl. VAT (optional)₽5,500The average repeat-order ticket excl. VAT among customers who bought again; empty means the repeat ticket equals the first.
Repeat-order margin (optional)%50Empty: same as the full-price margin.
New customers without a discountpeople700How many customers the same spend would bring without a discount (from a control group or a test).
Repeat orders per customer in 180 days (control)orders0.4The same for a control group without the discount. Without a control it cannot be said that the discount led to repeat orders.
Threshold: share not back within 180 days%—If more did not come back, the measure turns amber. Empty: no threshold, the color does not change. There is no single standard in Russia: enter your own.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
First orderbasket × (full-price margin − discount)
Customer over a periodfirst order + repeat orders × basket × repeat margin
CACacquisition spend ÷ number of new customers
Cohort profitcustomers × (margin over 180 days − CAC)

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Margin of the first order
1,750 ₽Basket × (margin − discount). The loss on the discount: basket × discount.
Loss on the discount per customer
1,000 ₽
Customer margin over 90 days
2,245 ₽
Customer margin over 180 days
2,575 ₽
Customer acquisition cost (CAC)
2,000 ₽
Customer payback period
90 days · within 90 days
Cohort profit over 180 days
575,000 ₽
Did not come back within 180 days
75 %
Without a discount (control): profit over 180 days
695,000 ₽ · no discount better by 120,000 ₽
Cohort profit over 180 days: with and without the discount
Bar chart: With the discount 575k, No discount (control) 695k0200k400k600k800kWith the discountWith the discountCohort profit: 575k575kNo discount (control)No discount(control)Cohort profit: 695k695k₽
Data as a table
MeasureCohort profit
With the discount575k
No discount (control)695k

Customer: with and without a discount

CaseFirst orderOver 180 daysCACCohort profit
With a discount1,750 ₽2,575 ₽2,000 ₽575,000 ₽
Without (control)2,750 ₽3,850 ₽2,857 ₽695,000 ₽

Without a discount the same spend gives more profit: the discount brings more customers but less valuable ones. For established customers a deep discount does not raise future purchases (Anderson and Simester, 2004).

Abuse through several accounts and “bargain hunters” pull repeat orders down: count the cohort on real data, not expectation.

Nuances and limits

  • Without a control you cannot say whether the customer would have come without the discount.
  • Several accounts and “bargain hunters” pull repeat orders down.
  • A deep discount may pay for new customers but not for established ones (Anderson and Simester, 2004).

Terms used

Calculate on your data →