Promotion result: incremental profit
Compares the profit of a promotion with the profit you would have had without it and subtracts cannibalization, pull-forward demand and costs. Shows the required and actual sales growth, the baseline cushion and the sensitivity to its estimate.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- Did we earn from the promotion beyond what we would have earned without it.
- What data is needed?
- Price excl. VAT, cost, discount depth, promotion weeks.
- How to read the result?
- On the default data (price 5000, cost 2000, discount 20%, baseline 40 a week, 190 sold over two weeks) profit in the promotion is 327,560 and without it 218,880. After cannibalization (27,360), pull-forward (32,832) and costs (20,000) 28,488 is left. The growth of +137.5% is above the required +116.8% with all losses, but at baseline +10% the result falls to 6,600, and the promotion breaks even at a baseline of about 45 pieces a week. Example on the default values: Incremental profit of the promotion — RUB 28,488; Incremental profit per promotion week — RUB 14,244; Sales uplift over baseline — 137.5%; Required growth: the discount alone — 58.7%.
Why and how to reason
A promotion looks successful when sales rose, but profit is counted differently: compared with what would have happened without it. In the promotion 190 units were sold at a 20% discount (RUB 4,000), while without it 80 would have sold in 2 weeks (baseline 40 a week) at RUB 5,000. Profit per unit after returns: in promotion RUB 1,724, normal RUB 2,736. Promotion profit 190 × 1,724 = 327.6 thousand. Profit without promotion 80 × 2,736 = 218.9 thousand. From the difference we subtract what the promotion took from others: cannibalization 10 units (27.4 thousand), pull-forward 12 units (32.8 thousand) and costs 20 thousand. Incremental profit is RUB 28,488. Although sales rose by 137.5%, break-even with all losses needed a 117% rise, and with the discount alone 59%.
When to use it
Reach for it after each large promotion and before it to understand in advance what sales growth is needed. Assumption: the baseline is honestly estimated, best from pre-promotion weeks without seasonal spikes. It does not fit if there is no clear pre-promotion sales rate, nor a clearance of leftovers where the goal is not profit but freeing the warehouse. Estimate cannibalization and pull-forward from neighboring items and weeks after the promotion, not as zero.
How to read the result
The main thing is incremental profit and required growth against actual. If you needed +117% and got +137%, the margin is small (20 points) and the result rests on the baseline estimate: at baseline +10% the result falls to RUB 6,600, at −10% rises to RUB 50,376. The baseline at which the promotion is zero, 45.2 against 40, shows fragility. Decision: repeat the promotion if the margin is robust, change depth or length if small, and do not run it if required growth exceeds what is realistic. Log each promotion result: depth, length, uplift, cannibalization, profit. After a season you will have your own table that makes the next promotion easier to assess.
Common mistakes
The usual mistakes: calling revenue growth a success instead of profit; taking the baseline from a week with advertising; ignoring returns, which are higher in promotions; zero cannibalization; ignoring the post-promotion dip (see the dip calculation). A deep discount demands growth that is often impossible. Do not enter a baseline from weeks when another promotion was already running.
What data is needed?
- Price excl. VAT, cost, discount depth, promotion weeks.
- Baseline: weekly sales without the promotion; sold in the promotion.
- Optional: cannibalization and pull-forward in pieces, promotion costs, returns.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price before discount, excl. VAT | ₽ | 5,000 | Price excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026. The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant. |
| Unit cost excl. VAT | ₽ | 2,000 | Unit cost excl. VAT, delivered to the warehouse. |
| Discount depth | % | 20 | The discount as a percent of the price before the promotion. |
| Weeks of the promotion | weeks | 2 | How many weeks the promotion lasted. |
| Baseline: weekly sales without the promotion | pcs a week | 40 | What you would have sold without the promotion: history, seasonality, trend. Without a plausible baseline there is only revenue, not an effect. |
| Sold over the whole promotion | pcs | 190 | How many units were sold over the whole promotion, in pieces. |
| Cannibalization: lost on neighboring items | pcs | 10 | Pieces of neighboring items that would have sold at full price. Valued at the no-promotion margin. Empty: zero. |
| Pull-forward: taken from the following weeks | pcs | 12 | Purchases that would have happened later at full price. Estimate from the dip after past promotions. Empty: zero. |
| Promotion costs | ₽ | 20,000 | Advertising, coupons, gifts, labor. Empty: zero. |
| Returns in the promotion | % | 12 | Share of units sold. Empty: zero. |
| Returns normally | % | 8 | The share of returns in normal times, as a percent of sales. Needed to clean the uplift of the promotion from extra returns. |
| Cost of one return | ₽ | 300 | Logistics and handling. A returned item goes back on sale. Empty: zero. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Profit per piece | (1 − returns) × (price × (1 − discount) − cost) − returns × return cost |
| Profit without the promotion | baseline × weeks × profit per piece at full price |
| Result | sold × profit in the promotion − profit without the promotion − (cannibalisation + pull-forward) × full-price profit − costs |
| Required growth | profit without the promotion ÷ promotion profit per piece − 1; with all losses: (without + losses + costs) ÷ profit per piece ÷ baseline − 1 |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Incremental profit of the promotion
- 28,488 ₽Profit in the promotion − profit without it − cannibalisation − pull-forward − costs.
- Incremental profit per promotion week
- 14,244 ₽
- Sales uplift over baseline
- 137.5 %
- Required growth: the discount alone
- 58.7 %Growth at which profit, net of returns, does not fall; without cannibalisation and costs.
- Required growth: with all losses
- 116.8 %
- Result at baseline +10%
- 6,600 ₽
- Result at baseline −10%
- 50,376 ₽
- Baseline at which the promotion breaks even
- 45.2 pcs a weekIf the true baseline is higher, the promotion loses money.
Without and with the promotion
| Case | Pieces | Price excl. VAT | Profit per piece | Profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baseline (no promotion) | 80 | 5,000 ₽ | 2,736 ₽ | 218,880 ₽ |
| In the promotion | 190 | 4,000 ₽ | 1,724 ₽ | 327,560 ₽ |
Cannibalisation and pull-forward are subtracted from the uplift: the promotion “steals” them from neighbouring items and future weeks. The effect on the reference price is not counted directly: see “Frequent promotions: reference price”.
Nuances and limits
- A baseline from last year without adjusting for range and calendar overstates or understates the effect.
- Revenue is not the measure: margin after the discount, returns and costs can wipe out the uplift.
- Estimate cannibalization and pull-forward from past promotions, not as zero.
- Prices excl. VAT: 22% from 01.01.2026, set by the shipment date; confirm your regime with an accountant.