Price and promotion: the optimal price, zones, the cross effect, a baseline, selection for a promotion
The document brings together price and promotion decisions: which price gives the highest profit at your elasticity, whether different prices in zones pay off, what happens to a neighboring item under a discount, how to assess a promotion without a control group, which items to put into a promotion under a margin budget, how to choose a price range for a new item and the launch price. Each decision reduces to a checkable calculation.
Why this document
Prices and discounts are usually decided by feel or by competitors. But every price has a profit that can be counted and every promotion has a “without the promotion” that can be estimated. The document shows where to take the assumptions and where the calculation stops working: outside the observed prices, without assessing spillover, with a small survey sample.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- The document brings together price and promotion decisions: which price gives the highest profit at your elasticity, whether different prices in zones pay off, what happens to a neighboring item under a discount, how to assess a promotion without a control group, which items to put into a promotion under a margin budget, how to choose a price range for a new item and the launch price. Each decision reduces to a checkable calculation.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The head of pricing or the category manager runs the calculations, the commercial director approves the price, marketing owns the promotion assessment; recalculate at each price change and after each promotion.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Taking the elasticity from one promotion → the optimum is random → use several periods and check the range. Not subtracting commission and acquiring → the price is understated → count the share as a percent of the price excl. VAT. Introducing different prices with no spillover assessment → the gain vanishes → compare the price gap with the spillover cost.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand sets the launch price and the recommended retail price and checks zones and steps with a pilot; on marketplaces price transparency makes zones and steps less reliable.
- Retail
- Retail compares its prices with competitors, counts the effect of a discount on neighboring items and chooses promotion items by stock, not by discount depth.
What it consists of
The optimal price and zones
- With a constant elasticity demand is q = q0 × (p ÷ p0)^ε, and the profit (price × (1 − fee share) − cost) × volume peaks at the price c ÷ (1 − fees) × ε ÷ (1 + ε). It exists for ε below −1: at an absolute elasticity up to one the profit grows with the price and only the corridor limits it. The shelf price equals the price excl. VAT multiplied by (1 + the VAT rate); the rate is entered as a guide as of the check date and compared with the current act.
- The optimum is sensitive to the elasticity near −1 and unreliable outside the range of observed prices: move in steps and compare with sales. Two “price and volume” pairs give a check elasticity and show whether you went beyond the data.
- Zones give different prices by regional elasticity: p = c × ε ÷ (1 + ε). The gain against the best single price is real only while the price gap is below the spillover cost: delivery, a trip, the customer’s time. For online this is usually not so, offline and franchise work better, with regard for limits on a recommended price.
The cross effect of a discount
- A discount on one item shifts demand for the neighbor: substitutes lose customers, complements gain. The full result is the change in profit of both items, not only of the one whose price you change. The limiting cross elasticity shows at which value the discount stops paying off overall.
- Cross elasticities should be estimated on price changes within a season; without checking on data the value is unreliable.
The promotion: the baseline and item selection
- Without a control group “without the promotion” is taken from last year: sales in the same weeks multiplied by the trend growth outside promotions. The uplift is the actual minus the baseline; the promotion profit is the actual at the margin with the discount minus the baseline at the margin without the discount. Sales after the promotion are compared the same way: a dip reduces the result.
- Selection for a promotion goes by the capital freed per rouble of lost margin: a high stock coverage, a higher elasticity, a price and cost such that extra pieces free cash. Bestsellers with a low coverage will sell without the promotion, their margin loss is useless.
A new item: the price range and the launch price
- The method of four price questions gives the acceptable price range between the lower bound PMC and the upper PME, the optimal point OPP and the indifference point IPP. At least 100 respondents from the target audience are needed; surveying employees does not do. The method shows perception, not demand: the price is checked by a price test.
- The launch price is chosen between a single price and steps down. Ideal steps are an upper bound provided customers do not wait for a cut; the share of waiting customers determines at which value a single price is more reliable. The frequency of promotions teaches people to wait.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Sales and prices | price and volume pairs, sales outside promotions for two years in the same weeks, sales after the promotion |
| Costs and stock | variable cost, the fee share, stock and rate by item |
| Surveys and segments | four prices per respondent, shares of customer groups and their maximum prices |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Estimate the elasticity from your data and check the range of observed prices.
- Step 2: Count the optimal price and what the corridor limit costs.
- Step 3: For regions check zones and spillover before deciding.
- Step 4: Before a discount on one item count the full result with its neighbor.
- Step 5: After a promotion estimate the baseline and the dip after it.
- Step 6: For a new promotion select items by coverage and the margin budget.
- Step 7: For a new item run a survey of 100 or more respondents and find the range.
- Step 8: Compare a single launch price and steps with your share of waiting customers.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Optimal price | p* = c ÷ (1 − fees) × ε ÷ (1 + ε), for ε < −1 | Price excl. VAT; on the shelf × (1 + VAT). |
| Baseline | Baseline = last year’s sales in the promotion period × (this year’s ÷ last year’s sales outside promotions) | The same calendar weeks. |
| Promotion priority | Priority = (extra pieces × cost) ÷ (sales without the promotion × price × discount) | Extra pieces not above the stock. |
| Cross volume | q_B = q_B0 × (p_A ÷ p_A0)^ε_AB | Plus substitutes, minus complements. |
Formulas in notation
- Optimal price
p^{*} = \frac{c}{1 - r} \cdot \frac{\varepsilon}{1 + \varepsilon}
c: cost, r: the fee share, ε: an elasticity below −1.
Worked example
An illustrative example: elasticity −2.5, cost RUB 1,800, fees 15%; a promotion with a 25% discount
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Optimal shelf price, RUB | 4,306 |
| Profit at the optimum, RUB | 991,878 |
| Profit at the current price, RUB | 979,918 |
| Promotion baseline, pcs | 500 |
| Promotion profit, RUB | −188,000 |
Zones: profit RUB 2,089,445 against RUB 2,003,642 at a single price of RUB 4,191, but the price gap of RUB 1,905 is above the spillover cost. Launch price: a single RUB 3,500 gives RUB 1,600,000, ideal steps RUB 2,600,000. All numbers are illustrative.
Figures
Data as a table
| Measure | Profit |
|---|---|
| Current price | 980 |
| Optimum | 992 |
Profit: the current price and the optimum. The optimum is slightly above the current price and gives a higher profit.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Profit on the actual | +912k | 912k |
| Margin of the baseline | −1.1m | −188k |
| Promotion profit | — | −188k |
What the promotion profit is made of. The discount gives away margin on the volume that would have sold anyway.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: many sizes, so broken runs and tails are the most common.
- Footwear
- Footwear: a stiffer size grid, extreme sizes sell worse, transfers are needed.
- Accessories
- Accessories: few sizes, stock coverage and storage time decide.
- Kids
- Kids: height-size and the school season, carrying over to next year often makes no sense by size.
- Men
- Men: a steady core range, carrying over is more often justified.
- Women
- Women: fashion items go out of date fast, the obsolescence probability is higher.
Common mistakes
- Taking the elasticity from one promotion → the optimum is random → use several periods and check the range.
- Not subtracting commission and acquiring → the price is understated → count the share as a percent of the price excl. VAT.
- Introducing different prices with no spillover assessment → the gain vanishes → compare the price gap with the spillover cost.
- Assessing a discount on the item alone → the loss on the neighbor is missed → count the full result.
- Comparing a promotion with the weeks before it → seasonality passes as an effect → take the same weeks of last year.
- Putting bestsellers into a promotion → margin is given away for nothing → select by stock coverage.
- Running a survey on a small sample and reading PME as the maximum price → the range is random → collect 100 and more answers.
Russian specifics
- The method is managerial and is not regulated; the VAT rate is entered as a guide as of the check date 17 Nov 2026 and compared with the current act and the product category. Different prices in regions and recommended prices have legal limits: consult a lawyer.