Deciding on leftovers: the season curve, carry-over or clearing, the timing and depth of a price cut
The document ties seven decisions on leftovers into one sequence: projecting the season end from the curve of past seasons, choosing between carry-over and clearing, searching the timing and depth of a price cut, choosing a liquidation channel, a targeted cut for a broken run, brand support and trigger rules. It helps decide what to do with goods that sell slower than planned and at which moment an action still makes sense.
Why this document
Stock usually grows not because of a poor buy but because of a late decision: the goods lag from the first weeks, but that is visible only if you know the season shape. The curve of past seasons answers where you should be by the week, and then each decision becomes a comparison of sums per unit or a search of combinations. There are no common norms: thresholds and elasticities come from your own seasons.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- The document ties seven decisions on leftovers into one sequence: projecting the season end from the curve of past seasons, choosing between carry-over and clearing, searching the timing and depth of a price cut, choosing a liquidation channel, a targeted cut for a broken run, brand support and trigger rules. It helps decide what to do with goods that sell slower than planned and at which moment an action still makes sense.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The category manager runs the calculation weekly, the buyer owns the assumptions, the finance director approves the loss budget; recalculate weekly in mid-season.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Building the curve by weeks from warehouse delivery → the curve shifts, the projection is wrong → count weeks from reaching the shelf. Leaving storage and capital out of the carry-over → it looks better → count the rate, cost and months. Taking the elasticity from the full price for deep discounts → the profit from the cut is overstated → confirm with a pilot.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand decides the fate of warehouse and wholesale leftovers: the liquidation channel and support for retail are its levers, carry-over depends on the style and material life.
- Retail
- Retail chooses the depth and timing of a price cut, transfers between stores and negotiations about support with the brand; it is limited by the marketplace promotion calendar and the space for the new collection.
What it consists of
Step 1. Where you are against the season: the reference curve
- The reference is the average over past seasons of the share of the final sell-through reached by each week since the goods reached the shelf. Each season is normalized to its own final, then the seasons are averaged. Build the curve separately by category and channel, cleaned of stock-outs and promotions.
- The projected final equals the current sell-through divided by the reference share for this week. The gap to the plan in percentage points multiplied by the receipts gives the under-sale in pieces. The signal “behind”, “on track” or “ahead” is set by a tolerance in points.
- The last week for a decision is the week after which less than a share you set of the final sales is left on the curve: the price changes little.
Step 2. Carry over or clear
- Clearing gives a share at the current price and the rest as a lot. Carry-over gives the revenue of the next season at its price and sales share, with a probability of obsolescence at which everything goes as a lot, minus the cost of storage and capital: the rate multiplied by cost and months. The decision is a comparison of two sums per unit.
- The break-even price of the next season and the break-even obsolescence probability show the margin of safety. If the difference is small, choose clearing: carry-over takes space and cash from the new collection.
Step 3. The timing and depth of the price cut
- The base sales rate decays week by week, after a cut it grows by the elasticity, and the sales of a week are not above the stock. A search over the week and depth finds the combination with the highest profit and shows how it beats the no-cut option.
- An elasticity estimated at the full price is overstated at deep discounts; confirm a depth of 50% and more with a pilot. If the marketplace bans a price below the purchase price, enable the constraint.
Step 4. Where to sell the leftovers and what to do with a broken run
- Liquidation channels are compared by present value: the channel price, the share really sold, costs, logistics and the term discounted at the capital rate. The stock is split by channel capacity, not all into the best one.
- With a broken run the style sells only through the sizes in stock. Tail sizes should first be moved to where they sell and then cut in price alone, to the depth at which the tail clears by the target term. Holes are better closed by replenishment.
Step 5. Brand support and trigger rules
- If the cut eats the retailer’s margin, the brand can compensate a share of the loss on units sold. The minimum share comes from the target margin and the brand ceiling from its margin per unit. Support is tied to units sold and a term; the form of the payment is determined by an accountant or lawyer.
- Trigger rules select items without manual sorting: stock coverage above a threshold and age above the novelty age, depth by coverage tier. Novelties, bestsellers and the core range are excluded.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Sales and deliveries | sold and received by week since reaching the shelf, stock by size, the sales rate without promotions and stock-outs |
| Prices and costs | price, lot price, cost, purchase price, the storage and capital rate |
| Your estimates | the elasticity at the needed depths, the sales share of the next season, the obsolescence probability, coverage thresholds |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Build the reference curve from past seasons separately by category and channel.
- Step 2: Weekly count the projected final and the gap to the plan.
- Step 3: For lagging items compare carry-over and clearing per unit.
- Step 4: Search the timing and depth of the price cut and compare with the marketplace promotion calendar.
- Step 5: Choose the channel by present value and split the stock by capacity.
- Step 6: For broken runs move the tails first, then cut the price in a targeted way.
- Step 7: Agree with the brand on support per unit sold and a term.
- Step 8: Fix the trigger rules and revise the thresholds each season.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Projected final | Final = sell-through now ÷ the reference share for the week; under-sale = (plan − final) × received | One sell-through base in the reference and in the current figure. |
| Carry-over and clearing | Clear = s1 × p1 + (1 − s1) × v1; carry over = (1 − o) × [s2 × p2 + (1 − s2) × v2] + o × v2 − h × c × m ÷ 12 | Per unit; prices excl. VAT. |
| Needed depth for a size | u = stock ÷ (term × size rate); d = 1 − u^(1 ÷ ε) | The elasticity is negative. |
| Support share | s = (target × price after the cut − margin without support) ÷ retailer loss | Not below zero. |
Worked example
An illustrative example: week 5, sell-through 30% against a plan of 85%; carry-over or clearing; the best price cut
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Projected final sell-through, % | 75.0 |
| Under-sale, pcs | 500 |
| Clear, RUB per unit | 1,420 |
| Carry over, RUB per unit | 904 |
| Best profit with a price cut, RUB | 1,782,680 |
The best cut: after 1 weeks by 25%, the closing stock 14 pcs against 448 pcs with no cut. Brand support in the example: 27.5% of the loss, RUB 110,000. All numbers are illustrative.
Figures
Data as a table
| Measure | Revenue per unit |
|---|---|
| Clear | 1,420 |
| Carry over | 904 |
The two sums of the decision per unit. Carry-over loses because of storage and risk.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Season revenue | +1,755 | 1,755 |
| Obsolescence risk | −289 | 1,466 |
| Storage and capital | −563 | 903 |
| Carry over | — | 904 |
What carry-over is made of. The carry-over season gives revenue, storage and risk reduce it.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: many sizes, so broken runs and tails are the most common.
- Footwear
- Footwear: a stiffer size grid, extreme sizes sell worse, transfers are needed.
- Accessories
- Accessories: few sizes, stock coverage and storage time decide.
- Kids
- Kids: height-size and the school season, carrying over to next year often makes no sense by size.
- Men
- Men: a steady core range, carrying over is more often justified.
- Women
- Women: fashion items go out of date fast, the obsolescence probability is higher.
Common mistakes
- Building the curve by weeks from warehouse delivery → the curve shifts, the projection is wrong → count weeks from reaching the shelf.
- Leaving storage and capital out of the carry-over → it looks better → count the rate, cost and months.
- Taking the elasticity from the full price for deep discounts → the profit from the cut is overstated → confirm with a pilot.
- Cutting the price of the whole style with a broken run → margin is lost on sizes that sell anyway → cut the tails.
- Paying support with no link to units sold → the brand pays for the unsold → tie it to units and a term.
- The same thresholds for all categories → the rules select too much → set thresholds by category.
Russian specifics
- The method is managerial and is not regulated; prices in the calculations are excl. VAT. The tax treatment of brand support payments and the accounting impairment of stock are determined by an accountant or lawyer: the calculation does not assess them. A lot of leftovers without labeling cannot be sold in some categories: check the requirements for your category.