Season, price and discounts
Sell-through pace, price with VAT and when a discount pays off.
The gist in 30 seconds
- A season is a race against time: by week 8 of 20, 2,600 of 5,000 units are sold (52%) against a target of 85%.
- The key number is the required pace: 137.5 units a week against an actual 325. While the required pace is below the actual one, no new markdown is needed.
- A markdown pays back only with enough sales lift: at a 60% margin a 20% markdown needs +50%, that is 487.5 units a week. Calculate that lift before launch, not after.
One example throughout: Our case
- A hypothetical store and one season batch: 5,000 units received, price excl. VAT RUB 6,000 (RUB 7,320 on the shelf incl. 22% VAT), cost RUB 2,400, initial margin 60%.
- Today is week 8 of 20: 2,600 units sold (52%), a pace of 325 a week, 2,400 units in stock. Suppose 1,820 of those sold at full price and 780 at 40% off: this is the basis of the margin in ideas 2 and 4.
- The 85% target (4,250 units) needs only 137.5 units a week: the target holds until the pace falls below 42% of the current one.
- The case question: is a 20% markdown needed? At a 60% margin it pays back only if sales grow by 50%, that is at 487.5 units a week.
About the topic
A season is the window in which an item sells at a good price. After it the item goes stale or is out of weather, and the price has to fall. So this topic is a race against time: how much has sold, how much must sell each week until the window closes, and how much margin you give away if you have to catch up with markdowns.
Decisions in a season are made three times, each with its own question. While full-price selling runs: are we on pace? When stock appears: is a markdown needed, how deep and for how many weeks? When the season is over: what did we actually earn and what should we buy next time?
The topic is read by the buyer, the pricing analyst, the commercial director and the owner. The buyer needs it to stop deliveries or reorder in time; the analyst, to prove that a markdown pays back; the owner, to see where the margin goes. The ideas below follow the order in which they are needed during the season. Most of them are worked on one hypothetical case (one store and one batch, the figures are in the “Our case” panel); three ideas about something else are marked “Another example”.
Two examples on the figures of the case. You received 5,000 units, by week 8 of 20 you sold 2,600, the season target is 85%. To reach it you still need to sell 0.85 × 5,000 − 2,600 = 1,650 units over 12 weeks, that is 137.5 units a week, while the actual pace is 325: the season is ahead of need, and no markdown is required yet. The second example is about price: at a 60% margin a 10% markdown pays back only if sales grow by 0.6 / (0.6 − 0.1) − 1 = 20%; growth of 10% turns the markdown into a loss.
Where to start. Fix the dates of the window and the sell-through target, then compare the actual pace with the needed pace every week. Decide on a markdown after checking the payback threshold, and break the season result down into full price, markdowns and lost margin. Common mistakes: counting the share sold not from everything received, taking a seasonal peak for a failure and giving an unnecessary markdown, judging a promotion by revenue without margin. In Russia add the price with VAT: all margin calculations are made on the price without the tax.
Terms used in this topic
- BS, IS, AS, SO
- Season stages. BS (Before Sale) is full price before the sale. IS (In Sale) is during the sale at reduced prices. AS (After Sale) follows it. SO (Sell Out) is final clearance of leftovers. Names in your company may differ.
- Sell-through
- Share sold: units sold out of units received for sale in the season (first order plus reorders). If you use another base, label it.
- Maintained margin
- Margin after markdowns rather than at list price: shows what was actually earned.
- Baseline
- The sales level without a promotion, from which the promotion effect is measured.
- pp
- Percentage point: the difference between two percentages. From 24% to 27% is 3 pp, not 3%.
- Carry-over
- Items of past seasons that keep selling in the new season without a markdown.
- Low seller
- An item whose sales are low relative to the rest of the range.
- Elasticity
- How many times sales change when the price changes: −2.5 means a 10% price cut lifts sales by 25%.
Key ideas
Sell-through and the required pace
Sell-through = units sold / units received for sale over the season (first order plus reorders; if a calculation uses another base, label it). Required pace = (target × received − sold) / weeks left. In our case 5,000 units were received, by week 8 of 20 sold 2,600 (52%), the target is 85% (4,250 units). The required pace is (0.85 × 5,000 − 2,600) / 12 = 137.5 units a week against an actual 2,600 / 8 = 325: the target holds until the pace falls below 42% of the current one. At a constant pace the whole batch sells out by about week 15, so the risk here is not leftover but an empty shelf. The pace is not constant over a season, so compare the required and the actual by week: the gap is the leftover risk.
Formula: Required pace = (target × received − sold) / weeks left
What to do: If the required pace is clearly above the actual one, decide on the leftover now: revisit the price, redistribute stock or boost promotion instead of waiting for the last week. In our case it is the other way round (137.5 against 325): no markdown is needed, watch the pace week by week.
Think first: By week 8 of 20, 2,600 of 5,000 units are sold, the target is 85%. Is the current pace enough?
Answer: Yes, with room to spare. You need (0.85 × 5,000 − 2,600) / 12 = 137.5 units a week, and 2,600 / 8 = 325 are sold. The target holds until the pace falls below 42% of the current one.
Initial and maintained margin
Initial margin is set by the shelf price, maintained margin includes markdowns. In our case the price excl. VAT is RUB 6,000 and the cost RUB 2,400, so the initial margin is (6,000 − 2,400) / 6,000 = 60%. Suppose that of the 2,600 units sold, 1,820 (70%) went at RUB 6,000 and 780 (30%) at 40% off, at RUB 3,600. The average price is RUB 5,280, the maintained margin (5,280 − 2,400) / 5,280 = 54.5%. The metric is more honest than “margin at list price” because it shows the cost of markdowns: 5.5 pp of margin.
Formula: Maintained margin = (average price after markdowns − cost) / average price
What to do: Look at margin after markdowns, not at list price, and compare it with the category plan: the gap is the cost of markdowns.
Think first: Initial margin is 60%. Suppose 70% of units sell at full price and 30% at 40% off. What is the maintained margin?
Answer: 54.5%: the average price is 0.7 × 6,000 + 0.3 × 3,600 = RUB 5,280, margin (5,280 − 2,400) / 5,280. Markdowns cost 5.5 pp of margin.
What lift pays for a markdown
Required lift = margin / (margin − discount) − 1, with margin and discount as shares of price. In our case the margin is 60% and the discount 20%: 0.6 / 0.4 − 1 = 50%. The price falls from 6,000 to RUB 4,800 and the profit per unit from 3,600 to RUB 2,400, so sales must grow from 325 to 487.5 units a week. A 10% discount needs +20% (0.6 / 0.5 − 1). For comparison: at a 30% margin the same 20% discount requires +200%, so for low-margin goods a markdown almost never pays back.
Formula: Required lift = margin / (margin − discount) − 1
What to do: Before a markdown compare the required lift with what past promotions delivered. If the required lift is out of reach, do not run the markdown or make it shallower.
Think first: Margin 60%, markdown 20%, 325 units a week sell now. How many units a week must sell for the markdown to pay back?
Answer: 487.5: 0.6 / 0.4 − 1 = 50%, that is 325 × 1.5. Profit per unit falls from 3,600 to RUB 2,400. If past promotions gave +20%, the markdown is not run.
Season stages
Stages: BS (before the sale), IS (in the sale), AS (after it) and SO (final clearance of leftovers): each stage has its own depth of discount and share of sales. A single total hides that full price was achieved only in the first stage. In our case, of the 2,600 units sold, 1,820 went before the sale at RUB 6,000 (margin 60%) and 780 in the sale at RUB 3,600 (margin 33.3%), while the overall margin of 54.5% looks calm. Stage names in your company may differ.
Formula: Stage margin = (stage price − cost) / stage price
What to do: Plan and control markdowns by stage; protect the full price in the first stage where it still works.
Think first: The overall batch margin is 54.5%. What is the margin on units sold in the sale at RUB 3,600 with a cost of RUB 2,400?
Answer: (3,600 − 2,400) / 3,600 = 33.3% against 60% before the sale. The average hides that a margin almost twice as low sits on 30% of the units.
Price with and without VAT
The shelf shows a price with VAT, margin is calculated without it. In our case the price excl. VAT is RUB 6,000, and at a 22% rate the shelf price is RUB 7,320 (6,000 × 1.22). If you take the shelf price by mistake, the margin comes out as (7,320 − 2,400) / 7,320 = 67.2% instead of 60%: an overstatement of 7.2 pp. A 20% discount off the shelf (RUB 5,856 incl. VAT) gives the same RUB 4,800 excl. VAT, so the share of the discount does not change, but comparison with cost must be done on one basis, without VAT. If you do not pay VAT, the shelf price equals revenue.
Formula: Revenue excl. VAT = shelf price / 1.22
What to do: Choose the “excl. VAT” basis once and calculate everything in it; convert to the shelf price only at the end.
Think first: Price excl. VAT is RUB 6,000, the rate is 22%. What margin comes out by mistake from the shelf price at a cost of RUB 2,400?
Answer: The shelf price is 6,000 × 1.22 = RUB 7,320, the margin on it (7,320 − 2,400) / 7,320 = 67.2% instead of the correct 60%: an overstatement of 7.2 pp.
Markdown ladder: steps against one discount
Another example: Stock of 640 units at RUB 5,000 incl. VAT, cost RUB 2,000 excl. VAT, sales of 55 a week, 8 weeks to season end. Elasticity is 2 (a 10% discount lifts sales by 20%), the leftover after the season sells at RUB 800 incl. VAT. Without markdowns 440 units sell and 200 remain. Steps of 0 / 20 / 30 / 40% for two weeks each sell 638 units and give a result of RUB 669k against 654k with no markdowns, while one deep markdown at the end gives only 633k. Scenarios are compared by result and by leftover, not by revenue.
Formula: Scenario result = Σ over steps (sold × (step price excl. VAT − cost)) + leftover × (leftover price excl. VAT − cost)
What to do: Compare scenarios by result and leftover, not by revenue; start with steps early rather than one deep markdown at the end.
Think first: Another example: with 640 units left, which pays more: steps of 0 / 20 / 30 / 40% or one deep markdown at the end?
Answer: In this example steps give RUB 669k against RUB 633k for one deep markdown (RUB 654k with no markdowns) and leave almost no leftover.
Elasticity from fact and the promotion result
The price fell from 6,000 to RUB 4,800 (−20%), sales rose from 325 to 500 units a week (+53.8%): elasticity −2.69. To pay back at a cost of RUB 2,400 you need +50% (487.5 units), so two weeks of the promotion are RUB 60,000 in the black (RUB 30,000 a week). But the post-promotion dip (290 units a week instead of 325, a shortfall of 70 units over two weeks at a RUB 3,600 margin, that is RUB 252,000) pushes the total to minus RUB 192,000. Sales lift is counted from the baseline, not from last week, and always with the post-promotion dip. The “Markdown ladder” takes elasticity as an absolute value, 2.69.
Formula: Elasticity = change in sales, % / change in price, %
What to do: Evaluate a promotion against the baseline and including the post-promotion dip; repeat only those that stay in the black.
Think first: A 2-week promotion gave +RUB 30,000 a week, then for 2 weeks 290 units sold instead of 325 at a RUB 3,600 margin. What is the result?
Answer: 2 × 30,000 − 70 × 3,600 = 60,000 − 252,000 = −RUB 192,000: the promotion’s gain is eaten by the dip after it.
Control week: full price counted separately
In week 8 of 20, from a received 5,000 units, 1,820 sold at full price (36.4%) and another 780 went on markdown (15.6%): 52% in all, 30% of it at a discount. The full-price plan for this week is 35% (hypothetical), a deviation of +1.4 pp. The required pace to the 85% target is 137.5 units a week against a current 325, and the 2,400 units left last 7.4 weeks of the 12 remaining: the shelf empties around week 15. The total sell-through hides how much sold without a discount, and the stock in weeks shows the risk of an empty shelf.
Formula: Deviation = full-price share (actual) − full-price share (plan for this week)
What to do: In the checkpoint week look at the full-price share separately: if the deviation from plan is negative, act before next week.
Think first: By week 8, 1,820 of 5,000 units are sold at full price, the plan is 35%. What is the deviation?
Answer: 1,820 / 5,000 = 36.4%, a deviation of +1.4 pp: at full price we are slightly ahead of plan, although 780 units (15.6% of the batch) went on markdown.
Deliveries, items, new and carry-over lines
Another example: of 10,000 units delivered 5,720 sold (57.2%), 45.2% at full price, but deliveries sell at different speeds: from 6 to 8.6% a week. By item there are 3 bestsellers, 3 low sellers and 1 with no sales, and 49% of stock sits in the weak ones. Sales per item: RUB 420,000 for new lines, RUB 640,000 for carry-over, RUB 840,000 for basics: carry the groups with higher yield.
Formula: Yield per item = sales of the group / number of items in the group
What to do: Carry over groups with high sales per item; clear weak ones earlier while there is still demand.
Think first: Another example: deliveries sell at 6 to 8.6% of the batch a week. In how many weeks does a delivery selling at 6% a week sell out?
Answer: 100 / 6 ≈ 16.7 weeks against 100 / 8.6 ≈ 11.6 weeks for the fastest: the slow delivery has to be dealt with earlier.
Price against the market and the season window
Another example: the price index against the market (our price to the median of competitor prices) is 97.6 by simple average and 94.3 weighted by sales: we are slightly below the market, one item is below the corridor, and on a third of items we are cheapest. The season matrix shows something else: leftovers from past seasons make 14% of sales and 29% in the peak month; stock beyond the window and cover costs RUB 4.64 m at cost, and that is money still recoverable by a markdown.
Formula: Price index to market = our price / median of competitor prices × 100
What to do: Check the price against the market corridor and the season window; turn stock beyond the window into cash with a markdown while it still works.
Think first: Another example: the price index to market is 97.6, the median competitor price is, say, RUB 5,000. What is our price?
Answer: 97.6 / 100 × 5,000 = RUB 4,880: we are 2.4% below the market median.
The business game “The brand season”: the same formulas, but the decisions are yours
The game leads one batch through five decisions: the purchase volume, the launch price, the decision in week 8, in week 14 and the fate of the leftover. The model recalculates sales by the same formulas as the topic: in week 8 with a batch of 5,000 and a price of 6,000 RUB 2,600 units are sold, as in the case. If you hold the price and order 5,000 units, at demand as planned 100% is sold (profit RUB 18,000,000), at demand 40% below the plan only 62.2% and a leftover of 1,892 units, at strong demand 1,216 units of demand are lost (RUB 3,064,320 of margin).
What to do: The market scenario is unknown in advance: the pace of the first weeks tells about it. Decide in week 8 by the required pace and not by hope, and compare the result with the grade of the game.
Think first: You ordered 5,000 units, hold the price to the end and demand is 40% below the plan. What share sold will you reach?
Answer: 62.2% instead of the 85% target: a leftover of 1,892 units would have to be sold to a liquidator at 35% of cost.
The season-end projection follows a curve, not a straight line
The first weeks of a season are slower: by week 5 the reference reaches 40% of the final. So a sell-through of 30% means a final of 75.0%, not 60%. A gap to the plan of 10.0 pp is 500 pcs of under-sale.
Formula: Projected final = sell-through now ÷ the reference share by the week
What to do: The price decision must be taken before the week after which little of the sales is left on the curve.
Think first: Why can the pace of the first weeks not be continued as a straight line?
Answer: A season follows a curve with a slow start, a straight line understates the final.
Carry-over and clearing are compared per unit
Clearing gives RUB 1,420 per unit, carrying over RUB 903.8 after storage of RUB 562.5 and an obsolescence risk of 25%. Carrying over equals clearing at a next-season price of RUB 3,952.
Formula: Carry over = (1 − risk) × season revenue + risk × lot − storage
What to do: With a close difference choose clearing: carry-over takes the place of the new collection.
With a broken run the tails are cut, not the style
With a coverage of 80% the tail size clears in 5.7 weeks and needs a price cut of 27.5% for it alone; the other sizes need no cut.
Formula: Depth d = 1 − u^(1 ÷ ε), u = stock ÷ (term × size rate)
What to do: Move the tail stock first, then cut the price in a targeted way.
How to work through it
- Define the season window: start and end dates and the sales stages.
- Calculate sell-through by week and the pace needed to reach the target.
- Compare the required pace with the actual and estimate the leftover risk in units and rubles.
- Before a promotion calculate the lift that would pay for it and compare it with a realistic expectation.
- Define the discount ladder and the duration of each step.
- Once a week reconcile deliveries and items: what sells at full price, what has stalled and where the price is above the market.
- At season end review initial and maintained margin by category and stage.
- Carry the conclusions into the buying budget and the plan for the next season.
Where to start
In the season watch the share sold and the pace needed; before a promotion check what sales lift pays for it; after the season review initial and maintained margin and category results. The discount ladder and promotion results are in the topics “Discounts, promotions and exit price” and “Promotions: planning and evaluation”. Calculations of the topic in order: “Season sell-through pace and leftover risk”, “Initial and maintained margin”, “Post-season review by category”, “Promo discount: the sales lift that makes it pay”, “Control week: full-price sell-through”, “Reference sell-through curve: season-end projection and gap”, “Price-cut trigger rules by item”. See also (their primary topic is another one): “Price, markup and margin”, “Price position among competitors”, “Weekly markdown ladder: discount steps and an ending-stock goal”, “Elasticity from a past promotion”, “Promotion result: incremental profit”, “Clearance scenarios compared by goal”, “Season stages: BS, IS, AS, SO”, “Season result: from gross sales to contribution”, “Sell-through by delivery: speed and time to sell out”, “SKU classification: ABC and sell-through, bestsellers, slow sellers, no-sale”, “New and carryover: share, return per SKU, sell-through and margin”, “Price monitoring by SKU: index to the market, position and price-scraping freshness”, “Season matrix: product season × sales month and stock against the window”.
Calculations in this topic
Season sell-through pace and leftover risk
From sales so far shows the sold share, stock in weeks, the forecast leftover at season end and the pace needed to reach the target.
Whether you will reach the sell-through goal, what will be left and what pace is needed.
Initial and maintained margin
Shows how much margin you planned at the ticket price and how much remained after markdowns and discounts: initial and maintained margin, markdown share and gross margin by category.
How much margin we planned and how much remained after markdowns and discounts.
Post-season review by category
After the season shows what sold at full price, how much went on markdown, the margin that was left and how much money sits in leftovers. A basis for the next buy.
What sold at full price, how much went on markdown, the margin and how much money sits in leftovers.
Promo discount: the sales lift that makes it pay
Shows how much more you must sell for a promo discount not to reduce profit, and compares promo discount depths. Cutting the price of leftovers at season end needs a different calculation: it looks at the stock, not at the sales lift.
By how many percent you must sell more for a discount not to reduce profit.
Control week: full-price sell-through
At the control week of the season, separates what sold at full price from what sold on discount, calculates sell-through from the on-hand stock at the start of the season, compares it with your goal and red line, shows the pace to the season goal and suggests: revisit the price-cut schedule, hold or consider a reorder.
Is the season heading for the full-price goal and what to do at the control week.
Reference sell-through curve: season-end projection and gap
Takes the curve of past seasons (what share of the final sell-through was reached by each week), divides the current sell-through by it and gets the season-end projection instead of a straight-line pace. Compares the projection with the plan: the gap in percentage points and in pieces of under-sale, a signal “ahead”, “on track” or “behind” and the last week when a decision can still work. It complements “Sell-through” (pace and stock projection) and “Control week”: here the shape of the season comes from your own history.
Where sell-through will end if the season shape repeats past ones, and until when the price can still be changed.
Price-cut trigger rules by item
Applies a rule to each item: if the stock coverage in weeks is above the threshold and the item has been on the shelf long enough, it goes into the price cut, and the depth depends on the coverage tier (for example, 12–16 weeks minus 20%, 16–24 minus 30%, above 24 minus 40%). Novelties, bestsellers and the core range go into exceptions. Shows the label and tier for each item, the number of items and the stock sum in the cut. It is a selection rule in practice; the dates and depth by scenario are counted by the “Discount ladder” and “Sale stages”.
Which items fall into the price cut by the rule and at which tier.
Price, markup and margin
Converts markup, margin and shelf price into each other including VAT and shows the profit left per unit.
Which markup corresponds to which margin and what shelf price results with VAT.
Price position among competitors
Compares your price with prices of similar items: median, range, rank and gap. Shows whether you are expensive or cheap for the market and which price falls inside the corridor.
Where your price stands relative to comparables and whether it falls into the market “corridor”.
Weekly markdown ladder: discount steps and an ending-stock goal
Compares three scenarios to the end of the season: keep the price, cut in steps, or one deep cut at the end. Shows the ending stock, the result including the clearance of leftovers, the exit price and warns when a discount does not pay back.
How to cut the price week by week so the leftover clears by the date without giving away margin.
Elasticity from a past promotion
Derives price elasticity from your sales before and during a promotion, shows a range from two observations, the sales growth needed to pay back, the result of the promotion in profit and the size of the dip after it.
How much demand changes with a discount, whether the last promotion paid back and how many sales were stolen from the future.
Promotion result: incremental profit
Compares the profit of a promotion with the profit you would have had without it and subtracts cannibalization, pull-forward demand and costs. Shows the required and actual sales growth, the baseline cushion and the sensitivity to its estimate.
Did we earn from the promotion beyond what we would have earned without it.
Clearance scenarios compared by goal
Compares several price-reduction scenarios (at most two steps in each) by three goals: the result including leftovers, sales volume and capital tied up in stock. The demand model is the same as in “Weekly markdown ladder”, so with the same data the results match. This is a Syntha Lab model, not a forecast.
Which of several price-reduction scenarios is best by result including leftovers, by volume and by capital frozen in stock.
Season stages: BS, IS, AS, SO
Splits a season into four stages (before the sale, in the sale, after it, the final clearance): sales, share of the stage, discount depth, gross margin, stock at the end of the stage and cover. Shows how much the season earned at full price, how much it gave away in discounts and where the leftover remained.
How much the season earned at full price, how much it gave away in discounts and at which stage the leftover remained.
Season result: from gross sales to contribution
Lays out the season result as a ladder: gross sales at list price, discounts, returns, net sales, cost of goods, gross margin, write-offs, selling costs. Shows how many margin points discounts ate. Fits a brand, a category and a retailer; check the names of the rungs against your own reporting.
Where the season’s gross sales went and how much margin discounts ate.
Sell-through by delivery: speed and time to sell out
Compares the deliveries (drops) of a season: what share of each delivery is sold and what share at full price, at what speed it sells and in how many weeks it will finish at the current pace. Shows which delivery has become heavy.
Which of the season’s deliveries sells slowly and when it will finish.
SKU classification: ABC and sell-through, bestsellers, slow sellers, no-sale
Ranks SKUs by net sales, assigns class A, B or C by the cumulative share and compares it with sell-through. A bestseller is class A with a high sell-through, a slow seller is one with a low sell-through, “no-sale” is a SKU with no sales. You set the thresholds; the calculation shows the quartiles of your data as a hint.
Which SKUs are bestsellers, which are slow sellers and which do not sell at all, and how much stock lies in them.
New and carryover: share, return per SKU, sell-through and margin
Compares groups of SKUs of a season, for example new items, carryover (carried over from past seasons) and basics: the share in the range and in sales, sales per SKU, sell-through and margin. Shows which group gives a return above its share in the range.
Which group of SKUs (new, carryover, basics) returns more than its share in the range.
Price monitoring by SKU: index to the market, position and price-scraping freshness
From a table of prices collected by scraping competitors calculates for each SKU the market median and minimum, your price index, your place among the competitors and the status against the corridor. Excludes stale data and SKUs with too few competitors from the total so that the index is not built on noise.
Where our price stands against the market for each SKU and whether the parsing data can be trusted.
Season matrix: product season × sales month and stock against the window
From 12 months of sales in four groups (SS, AW, leftovers of past seasons, core) calculates the share of seasonal goods and leftovers by month and calendar season, how much of its sales each season makes inside its own window and whether the window is enough to sell the stock.
What part of sales comes from seasonal goods, leftovers and core by month and whether stock fits in the season window.
Self-check questions
- Is sell-through calculated from everything received for sale over the season (first order plus reorders), not from the current balance?
- Are lots delivered at about the same time being compared?
- Is the required pace compared with the actual by week, not by season average?
- Is the required sales lift calculated before the markdown?
- Are price and cost compared on the same basis, without VAT?
- Is maintained margin known, not only list margin?
- Are results visible by season stage?
- Does the markdown decision account for it pulling future sales into the present?
Knowledge check
Multiple-choice questions. The correct answer and the explanation follow each question.
You received 5,000 units, by week 8 of 20 you sold 2,600, the season target is 85%. What weekly pace is needed until the season ends?
- A. 137.5 units
- B. 212.5 units
- C. 325 units
- D. 354 units
Correct answer: A. 137.5 units. (0.85 × 5,000 − 2,600) / 12 = 137.5 units a week. The actual pace is 2,600 / 8 = 325: the target is reachable with room to spare until the pace falls below 42% of the current one. 212.5 comes from dividing 4,250 by all 20 weeks, and 354 from not subtracting what is already sold. Covered in: Sell-through and the required pace.
Product margin is 60% of price, the discount is 10%. By how much must sales grow for the discount to pay back?
- A. by 10%
- B. by 17%
- C. by 60%
- D. by 20%
Correct answer: D. by 20%. Required lift = margin / (margin − discount) − 1 = 0.6 / 0.5 − 1 = 20%: from 325 to 390 units a week. 17% comes from dividing the discount by the margin, but after the discount the margin is already smaller. Covered in: What lift pays for a markdown.
Why does a markdown almost never pay back on low-margin goods?
- A. Customers of such goods hardly react to any discounts
- B. Low margin always means a bad, slow-moving product
- C. The gap “margin − discount” is small, the required lift soars
- D. The VAT in the price grows with the size of the discount
Correct answer: C. The gap “margin − discount” is small, the required lift soars. At 30% margin a 20% discount needs +200% lift: 0.3 / 0.1 − 1. In our case at a 60% margin the same discount needs +50%. The closer the discount to the margin, the faster the required lift goes to infinity. Covered in: What lift pays for a markdown.
The shelf price is RUB 7,320 incl. 22% VAT, the cost is RUB 2,400 excl. VAT. Which margin is correct?
- A. 32.8%
- B. 60.0%
- C. 58.0%
- D. 67.2%
Correct answer: B. 60.0%. 7,320 / 1.22 = RUB 6,000 of revenue excl. VAT, margin (6,000 − 2,400) / 6,000 = 60%. 67.2% comes from counting on the shelf price incl. VAT (an overstatement of 7.2 pp), 58% from subtracting 22% from the shelf price instead of dividing by 1.22. Covered in: Price with and without VAT.
The price fell from 6,000 to RUB 4,800, sales rose from 325 to 500 units a week. What is the elasticity?
- A. −0.4
- B. −1.5
- C. −2.7
- D. +2.7
Correct answer: C. −2.7. Elasticity = change in sales / change in price = +53.8% / −20% ≈ −2.7. The minus is normal: price and demand move in opposite directions. −1.5 is just the ratio 500 / 325, and −0.4 comes from dividing the other way round. Covered in: Elasticity from fact and the promotion result.
What do you measure promotion sales lift against to keep the estimate honest?
- A. Sales of the week before the promotion, at the old price
- B. The annual sales plan for this product category
- C. Sales of the closest competitor in the same period
- D. The baseline, including the post-promotion dip
Correct answer: D. The baseline, including the post-promotion dip. Last week may already be abnormal. The baseline shows what would sell without the promotion, and the dip afterwards takes back part of the gain: in our case it turns +RUB 60,000 into −RUB 192,000. Covered in: Elasticity from fact and the promotion result.
How does maintained margin differ from initial margin?
- A. It includes the markdowns actually given
- B. It is calculated without regard to the cost of the goods themselves
- C. It is always higher than the initial margin
- D. It is margin of the new collection only
Correct answer: A. It includes the markdowns actually given. Initial margin is set by the shelf price, maintained margin by the actual price after markdowns: in our case 60% became 54.5% when 30% of units went at 40% off. Covered in: Initial and maintained margin.
What do you compare when choosing between a markdown ladder and one deep markdown?
- A. Only the revenue of each scenario, with no leftover
- B. The result and leftover stock at season end per scenario
- C. Only the number of price cuts in a scenario
- D. Only the value of demand elasticity
Correct answer: B. The result and leftover stock at season end per scenario. Revenue can grow while the result falls. In the other example of the topic (640 units left) the steps gave RUB 669k with near-zero leftover, one deep markdown at the end only RUB 633k. Covered in: Markdown ladder: steps against one discount.
Children’s apparel is sold at a 10% VAT rate, but the item is not on the list (by OKPD 2 / HS codes). Which rate applies?
- A. Still 10%
- B. 0%
- C. Any rate the seller chooses
- D. The general 22% rate
Correct answer: D. The general 22% rate. The reduced rate applies only to goods on the list; without that the general 22% applies and the real margin on markdowns is lower than planned.
How does a markdown affect a labeled item (withdrawal from circulation)?
- A. A markdown does not change withdrawal: the code is written off at sale
- B. The item must be re-labeled before the price cut
- C. Markdowns on labeled goods are banned
- D. The code must be written off in advance, before the price cut
Correct answer: A. A markdown does not change withdrawal: the code is written off at sale. Price does not affect withdrawal: the code is written off at the moment of sale by receipt.
Why is footwear sell-through by size run below the total?
- A. Customers buy shoes less often than clothes
- B. Footwear does not sell on markdown at all
- C. Hit sizes run out, extreme and slow sizes remain
- D. The size run does not affect footwear sales
Correct answer: C. Hit sizes run out, extreme and slow sizes remain. The size run breaks before season end: average sell-through looks fine while extreme sizes keep leftover. That is why it is read by size.
Of 2,600 units sold, 780 went in the sale at RUB 3,600 with a cost of RUB 2,400. What is the margin on these units?
- A. 40.0%
- B. 33.3%
- C. 54.5%
- D. 60.0%
Correct answer: B. 33.3%. (3,600 − 2,400) / 3,600 = 33.3%. 54.5% is the overall batch margin, which hides the sale stage; 60% is the margin before the sale; 40% is the depth of the discount, not a margin. Covered in: Season stages.
The leftover is 2,400 units, 325 sell a week, 12 weeks remain in the season. What does the stock in weeks show?
- A. 17.5 weeks: too much leftover, a deep markdown is needed
- B. 12 weeks: stock matches the season end exactly
- C. 7.4 weeks: the leftover will not clear in time, a markdown is needed
- D. 7.4 weeks: the shelf empties before the end, time to think of a reorder
Correct answer: D. 7.4 weeks: the shelf empties before the end, time to think of a reorder. 2,400 / 325 ≈ 7.4 weeks with 12 left: the stock runs out around week 15 (5,000 / 325 ≈ 15.4), and the last weeks of the season the shelf is empty. This shows in the checkpoint week and is a reason to check a reorder, not a markdown. Covered in: Control week: full price counted separately.
Another example: of 10,000 units delivered, 5,720 sold, 1,200 of them on markdown. What share of the delivery sold at full price?
- A. 57.2%
- B. 79.0%
- C. 45.2%
- D. 12.0%
Correct answer: C. 45.2%. 4,520 units sold at full price (5,720 − 1,200): 4,520 / 10,000 = 45.2%. 57.2% is the total share sold; 79% is the full-price share of what sold (4,520 / 5,720), not of the delivery; 12% is the share of markdown units in the delivery. Covered in: Deliveries, items, new and carry-over lines.
In the game you ordered 5,000 units, hold the price to the end of the season and demand is 40% below the plan. What is roughly the share sold by week 20?
- A. 62%
- B. 100%
- C. 85%
- D. 78%
Correct answer: A. 62%. The weekly demand at the full price is 60% of the profile: over the season 3,108 units of 5,000 are sold, the leftover is 1,892. The 85% target is not reached, and this is solved by price or purchase volume and not by waiting. Covered in: The business game “The brand season”: the same formulas, but the decisions are yours.
In the game you ordered 6,500 units at RUB 2,300 and hold the price while demand is 40% below the plan. What is the leftover?
- A. 1,892 units
- B. 1,500 units
- C. 0 units
- D. 3,392 units
Correct answer: D. 3,392 units. The same is sold as with a batch of 5,000 (3,108) because demand does not depend on stock: the extra 1,500 units go entirely into the leftover of 3,392. A volume discount per unit does not compensate for the leftover. Covered in: The business game “The brand season”: the same formulas, but the decisions are yours.
How do you get the projected final sell-through from the reference curve?
- A. Multiply the current sell-through by the number of weeks left
- B. Take the plan as the projection
- C. Subtract the week from the plan
- D. Divide the current sell-through by the reference share by this week
Correct answer: D. Divide the current sell-through by the reference share by this week. The curve sets what share of the final is reached by the week; division turns the current number into the final. Covered in: The season-end projection follows a curve, not a straight line.
Clearing gives RUB 1,420, carrying over RUB 904 per unit. What to choose with a close difference?
- A. Carry over: storage costs nothing
- B. Clear: carry-over also takes space and cash from the new collection
- C. Not count
- D. Cut the price again without counting
Correct answer: B. Clear: carry-over also takes space and cash from the new collection. The sum per unit does not account for the space and cash for the new collection. Covered in: Carry-over and clearing are compared per unit.
Common mistakes
Mistake: Assuming a constant pace
What it costs: The seasonal peak is mistaken for a failure and extra discount is given A 20% markdown on 1,000 units at RUB 6,000 gives away 1,000 × 6,000 × 0.2 = RUB 1,200,000 of revenue that could have been kept.
How to avoid: Watch the weekly trajectory, accounting for weather and calendar. Compare the weekly trajectory with the same stretch of last season: if last year’s peak fell in November, wait for it and recalculate the forecast in the peak week. Decide on a markdown after the checkpoint week, not after the first four.
What it looks like (illustrative figures): Our case: 5,000 units received, a target of 85%. By week 4, 600 are sold, 150 a week. The linear forecast for week 20: 600 + 150 × 16 = 3,000, i.e. 60% against an 85% target. It looks like a failure, and a 20% markdown is set on 1,000 units. But then the November peak comes: from week 5 to week 8 sales run at 500 a week, by week 8 there are already 2,600, and without the markdown the target is reached with room to spare.
Mistake: Giving a markdown without the required lift
What it costs: Margin falls while units do not rise Weekly profit was 325 × 3,600 = RUB 1,170,000, now 390 × 2,400 = RUB 936,000: the promotion cost RUB 234,000 a week despite “growing” sales.
How to avoid: Calculate the required lift first. Before launch, calculate the required lift and compare it with the real lift of past promotions. If +50% is needed and +20% is typical, do not run the markdown or make it shallower.
What it looks like (illustrative figures): Our case: price RUB 6,000, cost RUB 2,400, 20% off: profit per unit falls from 3,600 to RUB 2,400. Required lift: 3,600 / 2,400 − 1 = 50%. Sales rose from 325 to 390 units a week (+20%).
Mistake: Measuring the season by total margin
What it costs: Deep discounts hide in the average The average hides that on 30% of units the margin is 33.3% instead of 60%; as the markdown share grows, the overall figure falls faster than it seems.
How to avoid: Review by stage. Calculate margin by season stage: before the sale, in the sale, after it and in final clearance. Then you can see at which stage earnings are lost.
What it looks like (illustrative figures): Our case: 70% of units sold at the full price of RUB 6,000, 30% at 40% off, RUB 3,600, cost RUB 2,400. Average price RUB 5,280, overall margin 54.5%: it looks calm. But on the discounted 30% of units the margin is 33.3%.
Mistake: Comparing sell-through of categories with different delivery dates
What it costs: Early lots look better B barely lags, yet the wrong conclusion cuts its price too early or trims the reorder.
How to avoid: Compare at the same week after delivery. Compare categories and batches at the same week after arrival, not on one calendar date.
What it looks like (illustrative figures): Another example: batch A arrived in week 1, batch B in week 7. In week 10, A has sold 60% (10 weeks on sale), B 20% (4 weeks), and B is called a failure. But at the same age the picture differs: after 4 weeks A had 24% (at an even pace), B already 20%.
Mistake: Mixing prices with and without VAT
What it costs: Margin overstated: at a shelf price of RUB 7,320 and a cost of RUB 2,400 it comes out at 67.2% instead of 60% Margin is overstated by 7.2 pp: a markdown that is in fact loss-making is considered acceptable.
How to avoid: Choose the basis once. Choose the basis once: run all margin and required-lift calculations on price excl. VAT and convert to the shelf price only at the end.
What it looks like (illustrative figures): Our case: shelf price RUB 7,320 (incl. 22% VAT), cost RUB 2,400 excl. VAT. Margin on shelf: (7,320 − 2,400) / 7,320 = 67.2%. Correct on revenue excl. VAT of RUB 6,000: (6,000 − 2,400) / 6,000 = 60%.
Taking weeks from warehouse delivery
What it looks like (illustrative figures): The curve shifts, the projected final is wrong.
Leaving storage and capital out of the carry-over
What it looks like (illustrative figures): Carry-over looks better than it is.
Russia and the EAEU
In Russia the shelf price includes VAT, so all margin calculations first bring the price to a net-of-tax form: from 01.01.2026 the general VAT rate is 22%, and the shelf price is divided by 1.22 (7,320 / 1.22 = RUB 6,000 in our case). If you do not pay VAT (for example, on the simplified regime below the exemption threshold), revenue equals the shelf price and input VAT is part of cost. Above the threshold the general or a reduced special-regime rate applies: confirm it with an accountant. For children’s goods on the list the rate is 10%: if an item is not on the list, the general rate applies, which changes real margin on markdowns.
The sales calendar in Russia is shaped by holidays and everyday occasions: 23 February, 8 March, 1 September, New Year, and marketplace seasonal sales. The start of the outerwear season depends heavily on the region: in the North and Siberia winter usually comes earlier, in the South later, and one plan with the same dates for every store exists only on paper. Check your own data for demand spikes on pay days.
Discounts on marked goods do not change withdrawal from circulation: the code is written off at the sale on the receipt. If goods are sold on a platform, the terms of participation in promotions and the commission are set by the platform’s contract and offer and they change; the platform economy law 289-FZ applies from 01.10.2026. Take current terms, not figures by habit.
The mechanics of a season are the same; the calendar and taxes differ. VAT rates by country are on the page “EAEU and CIS countries”; check them with an accountant: the same discount gives a different margin net of tax. The festive calendar is different: Nauryz in Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan (around 21–23 March), Kurban Bayram and Eid al-Fitr in countries with a significant Muslim audience, and the school season on the dates of each country. For Kazakhstan, mandatory marking of light-industry goods is being introduced in stages from 01.12.2026: check the stages and dates for your goods against the texts of the acts and account for them when planning stock for the sale.
Categories and audiences
- Apparel
- Apparel is most tied to weather and calendar: outerwear usually sells in a narrower window than light items (take the window length from your own past seasons). The shelf is cleared by a markdown in the last weeks of the window, not after, while goods are still relevant. The cost of catch-up markdowns shows in maintained margin.
- Footwear
- Footwear is strongly seasonal (boots, sneakers, sandals), and the size run breaks before the season ends: hits lose sizes, the extremes remain. Sell-through of the run is lower than the total, and markdowns sell mostly the slow sizes. Look at sell-through by size.
- Accessories
- Accessories are less tied to weather, so the window is longer and markdowns are needed less often. But gifting peaks (December, 8 March) are short: unsold festive goods remain after them. Classics can be carried over to the next season without discount.
- Kids
- In children’s wear the season is stricter: the school and winter windows, and carry-over to next year is often impossible because the child grows. The markdown has to come earlier and deeper; check on your own data how sensitive demand is to promotions. Season windows (school, winter) are shorter, so control weeks are set more often.
- Men
- In a men’s season the fork runs between what can be carried over and what cannot: a basic T-shirt or socks wait for the next season without losing price, while unsold outerwear loses it. At season end split the stock into these two parts and plan the markdown only for the second; then maintained margin is counted on outerwear and not diluted by basics.
- Women
- The women’s season is cut by occasions: 8 March, graduations, holidays. A dress unsold by the end of an occasion loses its window, so markdowns on such items are timed from the occasion date, not from the end of the season; basic knitwear can be held longer. Look at maintained margin separately for “occasion” and “basics” groups, otherwise one figure mixes two different markdown schedules.
Questions this topic answers
- Will we reach the sell-through goal?
- When does a promo discount or a markdown pay off?
- How do we look on price among competitors?
- How are sales, margin and stock split across the season stages: before the sale, in the sale, after it and the final sell-out?
Key measures and terms
- Sell-through (share sold)
- Weeks of supply
- Markup
- Required sales lift for a promo discount
- Full-price share
- Median and price corridor
- Markdown and its depth
- Maintained margin (MMU)
- Sale stages: BS, IS, AS, SO
- BS (Before Sale)
- IS (In Sale)
- AS (After Sale)
- SO (Sell-Out)
- Calendar season and product season
- Initial stock of the season (IS)
- Aftersale
- Product matching
- Price index against the market
- Price discrimination (price differentiation)
- Charm price endings (nines)
- The school season and children’s seasonality
- Archive and re-edition: bringing archive models back
Study first
What next
Next step: “Markdown and exit price”, “Season results: brand, category, SKU”. Related: “Assortment and sizes”, “Taxes and VAT”, “Platforms and marketplaces”.
Documents on this topic
- Sales plan
- Market pyramid: segments, markups and business model
- Niches: sport and outdoor, underwear, outerwear, knitwear, bridal, school uniform, workwear
- Retail math by segment: IMU, MMU, markdowns, sell-through, GMROI, turnover
- Trends, DNA and trade shows: collection balance and participation payback
- Demand forecasting: smoothing, seasonal indices, analogs and error control
- Markdown mathematics: steps, leftovers, timing and liquidation
- Holt-Winters, seasonal decomposition and Croston: forecasting with trend, season and intermittent demand
- Price and volume indices: Laspeyres, Paasche, Fisher, chain indices, deflator and the 4-5-4 calendar
- The six-month merchandise plan and model stock: sales, coverage, safety stock, purchases by month
- Trends and the range forecast: from a signal to the trend share in the matrix, the life window, the test batch and the chase order
- The 365-day strategy and the hypothesis register: prioritization, a plan by area and defense before the owner and the bank
- Forecast accuracy and the value of an AI forecast: WAPE, bias and FVA on a season assortment
- A buying plan from revenue backwards: revenue, cost, delivery, order and the recalculation rules
- Deciding on leftovers: the season curve, carry-over or clearing, the timing and depth of a price cut
- Price and promotion: the optimal price, zones, the cross effect, a baseline, selection for a promotion