Initial and maintained margin
Shows how much margin you planned at the ticket price and how much remained after markdowns and discounts: initial and maintained margin, markdown share and gross margin by category.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- How much margin we planned and how much remained after markdowns and discounts.
- What data is needed?
- Units bought, ticket price and cost by category.
- How to read the result?
- The gap between initial and maintained margin is the price of your discounts in margin points. If the gap grows from season to season the problem is in the buy and size curve, not in the discounts themselves. A gap above 8 points is highlighted red as a rule-of-thumb: replace it with your own. Example on the default values: initial margin 68.3%, maintained margin 62.5%: price reductions and discounts take 5.85 pp. Discounts are 15.6% of ticket revenue and gross profit on sold goods is RUB 35.1m; the category with the largest loss is marked in the result.
Why and how to reason
Initial margin (IMU) is the one you counted on when setting the ticket price. Maintained margin (MMU) is what remained after markdowns. The difference shows the price of clearance, which matters more than the ticket price.
IMU = (ticket price - cost) / ticket price. Real price = ticket x (full-price share + markdown share x (1 - depth)) x (1 - other discounts). MMU is computed on it.
Example. Outerwear: ticket 14,900, cost 5,400: IMU 63.8%. Of what sold 55% went at full price, 45% on a 35% markdown, with 2% other discounts: real price 14,900 x (0.55 + 0.45 x 0.65) x 0.98 = RUB 12,302. MMU (12,302 - 5,400) / 12,302 = 56.1%. We lose 7.7 points. For all four categories IMU is 68.3%, MMU 62.5%, a loss of 5.8 points.
When to use it
It comes in handy after a season and when planning prices: to build into the initial margin an allowance for markdowns. Especially useful for categories where clearance is inevitable. Assumption: full-price shares and markdown depths come from season results. It does not account for returns and carrying cost. Data is entered ex VAT. Take data from the end of the season, not its middle.
How to read the result
Look at the margin loss: 5.8 points in the example. Categories with the largest loss show where the ticket price is too optimistic or buying is excessive. The markdown share of revenue at ticket prices (15.6%) is how much you gave to buyers. Target MMU must cover costs and leave profit. Decision: set the initial margin above target by the amount of expected loss, reduce buying in categories with a large markdown share. Compare MMU with the margin target: if lower, the problem is in buying, tickets or markdown depth. Decide which of the three causes is the main one and act on it rather than on the consequence.
Common mistakes
The usual mistakes: computing MMU at prices with VAT; confusing the sold share with the full-price share; not including other discounts (cards, promo codes); comparing categories with different clearance shares. Also: adjusting the ticket without changing buying. Also: comparing MMU of different seasons without adjusting for range structure.
What data is needed?
- Units bought, ticket price and cost by category.
- The share sold, the share at full price, discount depth on the rest.
- Optionally: other discounts and points.
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| IMU | (Ticket price − cost) ÷ ticket price |
| Realised price | Ticket × (full-price share + discounted share × (1 − depth)) × (1 − other discounts) |
| MMU | (Realised price − cost) ÷ realised price |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Initial margin (IMU)
- 68.3 %(Ticket price − cost) ÷ ticket price.
- Maintained margin (MMU)
- 62.5 %(Realised price − cost) ÷ realised price.
- Margin lost to reductions
- 5.8 ppThe difference between IMU and MMU in percentage points. There is no threshold: compare with your own past seasons.
- Markdown share of ticket revenue
- 15.6 %
- Gross profit on sold goods
- 35.1 m ₽
Margin by category
| Category | IMU | MMU | Markdown share | Gross profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Outerwear | 64 % | 56 % | 17 % | 9.94 m ₽ |
| Knitwear | 69 % | 65 % | 13 % | 11.3 m ₽ |
| Dresses | 70 % | 62 % | 19 % | 9.3 m ₽ |
| Accessories | 76 % | 74 % | 6 % | 4.54 m ₽ |
Reductions eat the margin most in “Dresses” (19 % of the ticket price). Check the buy and size curve for it and the depth of the price cut in the markdown calculation.
Nuances and limits
- Do not mix margin on price (IMU, MMU) and markup on cost.
- Use the price excl. VAT: a Russian shelf price includes VAT, so divide it by (1 + the VAT rate), otherwise the margin is overstated.
- Calculate by category: the total hides the problem category.