Regional price zones: profit from different prices
Compares the profit at different prices in two or three zones (regions, formats, channels) and at one common price. For each zone from its elasticity and cost it counts its own price and profit, finds the best single price on a grid and shows the zones’ gain in roubles and percent. Checks the spillover: if the price gap exceeds the cost of shipping or of the customer’s trip, the zones will not hold. It complements the price corridors by country and channel: here are different elasticities inside one country.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- Whether different prices in zones pay off and whether they hold against spillover.
- What data is needed?
- Elasticity and volume by zone, cost, the measurement price.
- How to read the result?
- Compare the zones’ gain with the spillover risk: a gain without holding the zones is worth nothing. Example on the default values: Zone 1 price: RUB 5,333; Zone 2 price: RUB 3,429; Single price (best): RUB 4,191; Profit at zone prices: RUB 2.09 million. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
If elasticity differs by region, different prices give more than one. In the example zones with ε −1.6 and −2.4: prices RUB 5,333 and RUB 3,429, profit 2.09 m RUB against 2.00 m RUB at the best single price RUB 4,191 (+4.3%). But the price gap of RUB 1,905 is above the spillover cost of RUB 1,000, the zones will not hold.
When to use it
Apply to offline and franchise with different markets; on marketplaces with transparent prices zones are hard to hold.
How to read the result
Read the zones’ gain together with the spillover warning: without holding it is not real.
Common mistakes
Different prices without assessing spillover and without regard for limits on prices.
What data is needed?
- Elasticity and volume by zone, cost, the measurement price.
- The cost of spillover between zones.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unit cost | ₽ | 2,000 | Excl. VAT, one for all zones; if logistics differ by zone, adjust it in the zone cost with a separate calculation. The example value is illustrative. |
| Price at which the volumes were measured | ₽ | 4,000 | The current single price excl. VAT: the zone volumes are counted from it. The example value is illustrative. |
| Cost of spillover between zones | ₽ | 1,000 | What it costs a customer to buy in the cheap zone and bring or order: delivery, a trip, time. If the price gap is larger, the zones do not hold. The example value is illustrative. |
| Elasticity (absolute value) | −1.6 | Enter the absolute value without a sign, above 1, otherwise there is no optimum: 1.6 means a 1% price rise cuts the volume by 1.6%. The elasticity of a one-off promotion is not the elasticity of a lasting price change. The example value is illustrative. | |
| Volume at the price p0 | pcs | 600 | Zero excludes the zone. The example value is illustrative. |
| Elasticity (absolute value) | −2.4 | Enter the absolute value without a sign, above 1, otherwise there is no optimum: 2.4 means a 1% price rise cuts the volume by 2.4%. The elasticity of a one-off promotion is not the elasticity of a lasting price change. The example value is illustrative. | |
| Volume at the price p0 | pcs | 400 | Zero excludes the zone. The example value is illustrative. |
| Elasticity (absolute value) | −2 | Enter the absolute value without a sign, above 1, otherwise there is no optimum: 2 means a 1% price rise cuts the volume by 2%. The elasticity of a one-off promotion is not the elasticity of a lasting price change. The example value is illustrative. | |
| Volume at the price p0 | pcs | 0 | Zero excludes the zone: by default two zones are counted. The example value is illustrative. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Zone price | c × ε ÷ (1 + ε) |
| Zone volume | q0 × (p ÷ p0)^ε |
| Single price | the maximum of the sum q0ᵢ × (p ÷ p0)^εᵢ × (p − c) over a price grid |
| Gain from zones | 2.09 m ₽ − 2 m ₽ = 85,803 ₽ |
| Spillover | the gap of the high and low price is compared with the spillover cost |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Zone 1 price
- 5,333 ₽
- Zone 2 price
- 3,429 ₽
- Single price (best)
- 4,191 ₽Grid search: the price with the highest total profit.
- Profit at zone prices
- 2.09 m ₽
- Profit at the single price
- 2 m ₽
- Gain from zones
- +85,803 ₽
- Gain from zones, %
- +4.3 %
- Zone price gap
- 1,905 ₽
Data as a table
| Measure | Profit |
|---|---|
| Zone prices | 2,089 |
| Single price | 2,004 |
Zones
| Zone | Elasticity | Zone price | Volume, pcs | Profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zone 1 | −1.6 | 5,333 ₽ | 379 | 1.26 m ₽ |
| Zone 2 | −2.4 | 3,429 ₽ | 579 | 827,245 ₽ |
The price gap between zones 1,905 ₽ is above the spillover cost 1,000 ₽: customers will start moving goods from the cheap zone, the zones’ gain will vanish. Narrow the price gap or check that moving is really more expensive.
What to do with the result: test the zones with a pilot in one or two zones and compare with a single price; estimate a zone’s elasticity from its own sales. Online and marketplaces make explicit zones hard, offline and franchise work better.
A typical mistake: adopting different prices without assessing spillover and without regard for the limits on a recommended price.
Nuances and limits
- Different prices without assessing spillover.
- Ignoring legal limits on prices.