Syntha Lab RU

Line balance: takt, sewers per operation, bottleneck and shift output

From the operation times (standard minutes per garment) calculates the takt for the target output and the sewers needed and, with a given number of sewers, allocates places to operations, finds the bottleneck, the shift output, the balance efficiency and the shortfall against the target; shows which stations idle and which hold back the flow.

Production and import For whom: Workshop heads and production planners who place sewers on the flow for an order deadline.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
How many sewers the target output needs, where the bottleneck is and how many garments the line gives with the people available.
What data is needed?
The standard time of each operation per garment.
How to read the result?
Example on the default values (12 operations, 14 sewers, a target of 220 per shift): the takt is 1.74 min, the target needs 17 sewers; with 14 sewers the output is 187 units, balance efficiency 67%, 3 sewers short. Example on the default values: Takt for the target output: 1.74 min; Sewers needed for the target: 17; Minimum sewers at perfect balance: 11; Shift output at the given sewers: 187 pcs. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

A sewing flow is like a conveyor with one rule: the speed of the whole line equals the speed of its slowest station. So the takt is counted first: how many minutes must pass between two finished garments to deliver the plan. The takt equals the net minutes of the shift multiplied by norm attainment and divided by the target output. An operation longer than the takt cannot be handled by one sewer and needs ⌈time ÷ takt⌉ people. The sum over operations gives the number of sewers for the target. If there are fewer people, the extra ones are placed at the longest stations and the longest of those left sets the output. Example: a takt of 1.74 min for a target of 220 needs 17 sewers; with 14 sewers the bottleneck is 2.05 min, the output 187 garments, balance efficiency 67%.

When to use it

It comes in handy when launching a new order to see whether the people will be enough for the deadline, when assessing the factory’s capacity, when moving sewers to another style and when looking for the bottleneck. It does not fit lines with a large buffer between stations and manual production where work goes by the whole garment. Take operation times from the time-standard calculation. For footwear the flow goes through upper, lasting and sole stages, for accessories flows are shorter, and for children’s the lots are smaller and changeovers frequent.

How to read the result

The main indicator: the output at the given sewers against the target. In the example the line delivers 85% of the target and is three sewers short. The second indicator: balance efficiency. Below 70% means people idle waiting for the bottleneck, and adding sewers to operations that are already “extra” is useless: put them at the narrow ones or split the narrow operation in two. Compare the station time bars with the takt: whatever is above the takt falls behind. If more sewers are needed than there are, three ways remain: add people, simplify the longest operations or move the deadline.

Common mistakes

The first error: placing people equally across operations. The second: estimating output by the average operation time and not by the longest station. The third: counting the target output at 100% of the standard and forgetting norm attainment. The fourth: taking the calculation for a schedule: the real output is lower because of hand-overs between stations and changeovers.

What data is needed?

  • The standard time of each operation per garment.
  • The number of sewers, the net minutes of a shift and norm attainment.
  • The target output per shift by the order deadline.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Net sewer minutes per shiftmin450The shift net of breaks and stoppages for one sewer. The example value is illustrative.
Norm attainment%85The share of standard minutes that the sewers really deliver per shift. The example value is illustrative.
Sewers on the linepeople14How many sewers are available to the line; not fewer than the number of operations in the table, otherwise merge operations. The example value is illustrative.
Target output per shiftunits220How many garments are needed per shift by the order plan and the deadline. Empty: only the output at the given sewers is calculated. The example value is illustrative.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Takttakt = net minutes × norm attainment ÷ target output
Sewers per operationneeded = ⌈operation time ÷ takt⌉; the sum over operations
Placing sewersone per operation, the rest one at a time to the station with the largest station time
Bottleneck and outputoutput = net minutes × attainment ÷ the largest station time
Balance efficiencysum of times ÷ (number of sewers × bottleneck station time)

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Takt for the target output
1.74 minThe time in which the line must deliver one garment.
Sewers needed for the target
17The sum of sewers per operation rounded up.
Minimum sewers at perfect balance
11The sum of times ÷ takt, rounded up: the lower bound, unreachable without splitting operations.
Shift output at the given sewers
187 pcs
Bottleneck
Setting in sleeves
Bottleneck station time
2.05 min
Line balance efficiency
66.5 %The sum of times ÷ (sewers × bottleneck station time): the average sewer load.
Balance loss
33.5 %
Sewers short of the target
3
Output against the target
84.8 %
Operations in the flow
12
Sum of operation times
19.09 min
Station time by operation, min
Bar chart: Preparing pieces and fusing 1.31, Shoulder seams 0.52, Setting in sleeves 2.05, Side and sleeve seams 1.77, Collar and stand 1.31, Attaching the collar 1.6800.511.522.5Preparing pieces and fusingPreparing pieces andfusingStation time: 1.311.31Takt: 1.741.74Shoulder seamsShoulder seamsStation time: 0.520.52Takt: 1.741.74Setting in sleevesSetting in sleevesStation time: 2.052.05Takt: 1.741.74Side and sleeve seamsSide and sleeveseamsStation time: 1.771.77Takt: 1.741.74Collar and standCollar and standStation time: 1.311.31Takt: 1.741.74Attaching the collarAttaching the collarStation time: 1.681.68Takt: 1.741.74CuffsCuffsStation time: 1.41.4Takt: 1.741.74Placket and buttonholesPlacket andbuttonholesStation time: 2.052.05Takt: 1.741.74HemmingHemmingStation time: 0.840.84Takt: 1.741.74ButtonsButtonsStation time: 0.750.75Takt: 1.741.74PressingPressingStation time: 1.591.59Takt: 1.741.74Inspection and packingInspection andpackingStation time: 1.121.12Takt: 1.741.74min
  • Station time
  • Takt
Data as a table
MeasureStation timeTakt
Preparing pieces and fusing1.311.74
Shoulder seams0.521.74
Setting in sleeves2.051.74
Side and sleeve seams1.771.74
Collar and stand1.311.74
Attaching the collar1.681.74
Cuffs1.41.74
Placket and buttonholes2.051.74
Hemming0.841.74
Buttons0.751.74
Pressing1.591.74
Inspection and packing1.121.74
Sewers by operation: allocated and needed
Bar chart: Preparing pieces and fusing 1, Shoulder seams 1, Setting in sleeves 1, Side and sleeve seams 1, Collar and stand 2, Attaching the collar 100.511.52Preparing pieces and fusingPreparing pieces andfusingAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 11Shoulder seamsShoulder seamsAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 11Setting in sleevesSetting in sleevesAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 22Side and sleeve seamsSide and sleeveseamsAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 22Collar and standCollar and standAllocated: 22Needed for the target: 22Attaching the collarAttaching the collarAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 11CuffsCuffsAllocated: 22Needed for the target: 22Placket and buttonholesPlacket andbuttonholesAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 22HemmingHemmingAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 11ButtonsButtonsAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 11PressingPressingAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 11Inspection and packingInspection andpackingAllocated: 11Needed for the target: 11people
  • Allocated
  • Needed for the target
Data as a table
MeasureAllocatedNeeded for the target
Preparing pieces and fusing11
Shoulder seams11
Setting in sleeves12
Side and sleeve seams12
Collar and stand22
Attaching the collar11
Cuffs22
Placket and buttonholes12
Hemming11
Buttons11
Pressing11
Inspection and packing11

Stations of the flow

OperationTime, minSewersStation timeLoad, %Sewers needed
Preparing pieces and fusing1.3111.31641
Shoulder seams0.5210.52251
Setting in sleeves2.0512.051002
Side and sleeve seams1.7711.77862
Collar and stand2.6121.31642
Attaching the collar1.6811.68821
Cuffs2.821.4682
Placket and buttonholes2.0512.051002
Hemming0.8410.84411
Buttons0.7510.75371
Pressing1.5911.59781
Inspection and packing1.1211.12551

The target needs 17 sewers and there are 14: add people, simplify the longest operations or move the deadline.

The model is simple: one operation per group of sewers, time divided equally, hand-over between stations without delay and without work-in-progress. Real lines smooth the spread with buffers and flexible sewers, so the output is usually below the calculated one. For footwear the flow goes through upper, lasting and sole stages with shared machines, for accessories flows are shorter, for children’s lots are smaller and changeovers more frequent.

Nuances and limits

  • Placing people equally on operations: the bottleneck stays narrow.
  • Counting output by the average time and not by the longest station.
  • Not counting norm attainment: the plan comes out overstated.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →