Syntha Lab RU

LCL vs full container: break-even volume

Compares the cost of delivering a shipment as less-than-container load (a rate per cubic meter plus consolidation) and as a full container (the rate plus extra costs), finds the volume at which the container becomes cheaper and counts the cost per piece. Extra waiting days for a consolidated load can be included. Rates are entered in one currency.

Production and import For whom: Logisticians and buyers choosing the shipment format.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
Whether LCL or a container is cheaper and at which volume the choice flips.
What data is needed?
Container and LCL rates and consolidation.
How to read the result?
Compare cost, break-even volume and container fill; near the threshold the term decides. Example on the default values: LCL: RUB 3,760; Full container: RUB 6,100; Cheaper: LCL; Difference: RUB 2,340. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

LCL pays off while the shipment is small: in the example at 38 m³ it costs 3,760 against 6,100 for a container; the container wins from 62.6 m³.

When to use it

Apply when planning a shipment and comparing carriers’ offers. It supplements “Air or sea” and “Container detention”.

How to read the result

Look at the break-even volume and the container fill; near the threshold the term decides, so enter the waiting days.

Common mistakes

They compare rates without volumetric weight, ignore downtime and take the volume from the rated figure rather than the layout.

What data is needed?

  • Container and LCL rates and consolidation.
  • Shipment volume and usable container volume.
  • Waiting days and the cost of a day.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Container rate₽5,800The freight of one container on your route; LCL and container rates in the same currency. The example value is illustrative.
Container extra costs₽300Terminal, loading, clearance per container. The example value is illustrative. Optional. Empty: the field is ignored (counted as zero in sums).
LCL rate per m³per m³95Per cubic meter or tonne, whichever is larger: enter per m³ here. The example value is illustrative.
LCL consolidation₽150A fixed charge for consolidating and deconsolidating the shipment. The example value is illustrative. Optional. Empty: the field is ignored (counted as zero in sums).
Shipment volumem³38The volume of the packed cartons, not the weight. The example value is illustrative.
Usable container volumem³68With real loading: less than the rated volume. The example value is illustrative.
Pieces per m³pcs500From the “Packing density” calculation: carton and pieces in it. The example value is illustrative.
Extra waiting days of an LCL loaddays0Optional: how many days longer an LCL load takes to consolidate and deconsolidate. The example value is illustrative.
Cost of a day of delay₽0Optional: lost sales, cost of money and downtime for one day. The example value is illustrative.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Containernumber of containers × (rate + extra costs); number = volume ÷ usable volume, rounded up
LCLrate per m³ × volume + consolidation + delay days × cost of a day
Break-even volume(container rate + extra − consolidation − delay) ÷ rate per m³
Per piececost ÷ (volume × pieces per m³)

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

LCL
3,760 ₽Rate × volume + consolidation + delay.
Full container
6,100 ₽Number of containers × (rate + extra costs).
Cheaper
LCL
Difference
2,340 ₽
Break-even volume for one container, m³
62.6(Container − consolidation − delay) ÷ rate per m³.
Container fill
55.9 %
Per piece: LCL
0.198 ₽
Per piece: container
0.321 ₽
Cost by shipment volume
Bar chart: 17 1,765, 34 3,380, 38 3,760, 51 4,995, 68 6,61002,0004,0006,0008,0001717LCL: 1,765Container: 6,1003434LCL: 3,380Container: 6,1003838LCL: 3,760Container: 6,1005151LCL: 4,995Container: 6,1006868LCL: 6,610Container: 6,100RUB
  • LCL
  • Container
Data as a table
MeasureLCLContainer
171,7656,100
343,3806,100
383,7606,100
514,9956,100
686,6106,100

Comparison by volume, m³

Volume, m³LCLContainerCheaper
171,765 ₽6,100 ₽LCL
343,380 ₽6,100 ₽LCL
383,760 ₽6,100 ₽LCL
514,995 ₽6,100 ₽LCL
686,610 ₽6,100 ₽container

Now LCL is cheaper, the difference is 2,340 ₽. Check the volumetric weight and the carrier’s rates against the invoice: this is only rate arithmetic.

What to do with the result: if the volume is close to the threshold, add the waiting days and the cost of delay and then decide; near the threshold the term decides, not the rate. A typical mistake: comparing rates without volumetric weight and without downtime.

Nuances and limits

  • Comparing rates without volumetric weight.
  • Ignoring downtime.
  • Counting volume by the rated figure.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →