JCPenney: an everyday-low-price experiment, 2012
A US department-store chain replaced frequent sales and coupons with everyday low prices; shoppers used to waiting for a promotion did not follow the new scheme.
Figures
- Net sales 2011 → 2012
- $17.26bn → $12.99bn, −24.8% (a 53-week year)
- Comparable sales 2012
- −25.2%
- Return to promotions
- from the start of 2013 most of the business moved back to a promotional model
Lesson
Customers learned from you to wait for promotions, and removing them abruptly without a test on part of the stores hits traffic harder than the saved margin helps. Change the mechanic in stages and compare with control stores.