Syntha Lab RU

Payback of the digital sample (3D): savings on physical samples, weeks and the return period

From the number of styles, the rounds of the physical sample, the price of a sample and the share of rounds that 3D replaces counts the savings on physical samples per season, the costs of the digital sample and the license, the weeks saved on the critical path and the payback of the one-off investment. Shows the threshold: at what replacement share the digital sample is cheaper than the physical one.

Collection and range For whom: Heads of collection development, technologists, product managers and CFOs who decide whether to introduce a digital sample and in what volumes.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
How many physical sample rounds 3D will replace, what it costs and saves, how many weeks the critical path gains and after how many seasons the one-off investment pays back.
What data is needed?
The number of styles per season and the number of physical sample rounds per style.
How to read the result?
Example at the default values (60 styles, 3 rounds, sample RUB 7,500, replacement 40%): 72 samples replaced, savings RUB 540,000, net savings per season RUB 252,000, weeks per style 3, payback without time 1.8 seasons, with time 0.8; replacement threshold 12.4%. Example on the default values: Physical samples replaced per season: 72; Savings on physical samples per season: RUB 540,000; Costs of digital samples per season: RUB 168,000; License per season: RUB 120,000. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

A physical sample is expensive not only by the price of fabric and sewing but also by weeks: each round is shipping, a fitting and a pattern correction. A digital sample replaces part of the rounds, and its payback consists of two parts. Money: the replaced rounds are multiplied by the price of a sample, from which the work of a 3D specialist for each style and the license divided by seasons are subtracted. Time: only the saved weeks that lie on the critical path are counted, and they are valued by the margin of a style per week. In the example there are 60 styles, 3 rounds, a sample of RUB 7,500, replacement 40%: 72 samples are replaced, the savings are RUB 540,000, the digital costs RUB 168,000 and RUB 120,000 of license, the net savings are RUB 252,000 per season. The one-off RUB 450,000 pays back in 1.8 seasons without time and in 0.8 with it. The replacement threshold is 12.4%: below it the digital sample per style costs more than the replaced rounds.

When to use it

Apply before buying the software and the training, and also after a pilot on several styles, to replace the promised replacement share with the actual one. Especially useful where there are many styles and long rounds. Not suitable for a collection of a few styles: the license will not be recouped. Heavy fabrics and complex silhouettes are conveyed worse by 3D: take a lower replacement share for them.

How to read the result

Look at the net savings per season without time: if positive, the digital pays back with money, time is a bonus. If negative, the decision rests only on the value of weeks, which is harder to assess. The replacement threshold shows the reserve: in the example replacement is 40% at a threshold of 12.4%. The number of styles to cover the license (19.4) says from what size of collection the investment makes sense at all. A week on the critical path matters only when it moves the launch date: check it against the collection calendar. If a pilot showed a replacement share below the threshold, stop and recalculate the model on other fabrics.

Common mistakes

The replacement share is taken from the vendor’s presentation and not from a pilot. All saved weeks are counted as won: parallel work eats part of them. The license and the specialist work are not subtracted. The digital sample is considered a replacement for photo shooting and content: that is a different item. A week is valued by the margin of the whole collection and not of one style.

What data is needed?

  • The number of styles per season and the number of physical sample rounds per style.
  • The price of a physical sample, the price of a digital sample per style, the license and the one-off investment.
  • Weeks per round, the share of the critical path and the margin of a style per week: from the collection calendar.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Styles in development per seasonpcs60How many styles go through samples in one season, including those that later did not go into production. The example value is illustrative.
Physical sample rounds per style without 3Drounds3Prototype, fit, pre-production: how many times a style is physically sewn and corrected until it is approved. The example value is illustrative.
Price of one physical sample₽7,500Fabric, sewing, trims, shipping and the technologist time for one round, excl. VAT. The example value is illustrative.
Share of rounds that 3D replaces%40What part of the physical rounds goes to the digital: most often the fit and details on simple silhouettes; your own share from a pilot. The example value is illustrative.
Digital sample per style₽2,800The work of a 3D specialist on one style: digitizing patterns, fit, corrections, excl. VAT. The example value is illustrative.
One-off investment₽450,000Software, equipment, training and set-up of fabric libraries: paid once. The example value is illustrative.
License per year₽240,000The annual subscription to the software and support. The example value is illustrative.
Seasons per yearseasons2Into how many seasons the annual license is divided: two collections a year give two seasons. The example value is illustrative.
Weeks per physical sample roundweeks2.5Sewing, shipping, the fitting and corrections of one round; a digital round takes a few days. The example value is illustrative.
Share of saved weeks on the critical path%60How much of the saved time really moves the date of launch to the shelf: the rest is eaten by parallel work. The example value is illustrative.
Price of a week of delay of a style₽3,000The margin that a style earns less in a week of late launch; 0 if you do not value the time. The example value is illustrative.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Rounds replacedstyles × rounds × replacement share
Net savingsreplaced × sample price − styles × digital sample − license per season
Weeks on the critical pathrounds × share × weeks per round × critical path share
Paybackone-off investment ÷ (net savings + value of time)

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Physical samples replaced per season
72
Savings on physical samples per season
540,000 ₽
Costs of digital samples per season
168,000 ₽
Licence per season
120,000 ₽
Net savings per season
252,000 ₽
Weeks saved per style
3
Of them move the launch date
1.8Weeks on the critical path: see the collection calendar.
Value of the saved time per season
324,000 ₽
Payback without time, seasons
1.8
Payback with time, seasons
0.8
Replacement share threshold per style
12.4 %Below this share the digital sample per style costs more than the replaced physical rounds (without the license).
Styles to cover the license
19.4Fewer styles in the season: the license is not recouped by the savings.
Net savings per season at different replacement shares, thousand RUB
Line chart: Net savings: −153 → 792−200020040060080010 %20 %30 %40 %50 %60 %70 %80 %Net savings, 10 %: −153Net savings, 20 %: −18Net savings, 30 %: 117Net savings, 40 %: 252Net savings, 50 %: 387Net savings, 60 %: 522Net savings, 70 %: 657Net savings, 80 %: 792
Data as a table
MeasureNet savings
10 %−153
20 %−18
30 %117
40 %252
50 %387
60 %522
70 %657
80 %792

What the season is made of

ItemAmount, RUB
Savings on physical samples540,000
Digital samples−168,000
Licence per season−120,000
Net savings252,000
Value of the saved time324,000
Total per season576,000

The saving is real only if the digital round truly replaces a physical one: count the replacement share from a pilot on several styles, not from the software vendor’s promise.

Nuances and limits

  • Taking the replacement share from the vendor’s promises and not from a pilot on your own styles.
  • Counting the saved weeks in full: only part of them lies on the critical path.
  • Not counting the license and the 3D work: the saving on samples looks higher than it is.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →