Price and volume indices: Laspeyres, Paasche, Fisher and the chain index
From the prices and quantities of a group of goods in two (or three) periods calculates the Laspeyres, Paasche and Fisher price indices, the volume indices, splits the revenue growth in roubles into price growth and volume growth (real growth) and compares the chain index over three periods with the direct one.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- Which part of the revenue growth in roubles is prices and which is real growth in units and how it changes with the chosen basket.
- What data is needed?
- Average prices and quantities sold by group in two or three periods.
- How to read the result?
- Example on the default values (six groups, three periods): prices by Laspeyres 12.2%, by Paasche 11.4%, by Fisher 11.8%; revenue grew by 13.2%, real volume growth 1.6%. Over two periods the chain Fisher is 21.7%, the direct 21.6%. Example on the default values: Laspeyres price index: 12.2%; Paasche price index: 11.4%; Fisher price index: 11.8%; Revenue growth in roubles: 13.2%. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
Revenue grew by 13%: through prices or through volume? To separate them, indices are needed. A price index asks how much the same basket would cost today. Laspeyres takes the basket of the base period: Σ p1 × q0 ÷ Σ p0 × q0. Paasche takes the basket of the current period: Σ p1 × q1 ÷ Σ p0 × q1. They diverge because buyers change the structure: they walk away from what has become dearer. Fisher is the geometric mean of the two and usually the best compromise. Here Laspeyres is +12.2%, Paasche +11.4%, Fisher +11.8%. Revenue grew by 13.2%: this is Paasche price × Laspeyres volume = 1.1144 × 1.0156 = 1.1318. So real volume growth is small (1.2% by Fisher, from 0.9 to 1.6% by the different indices), and almost all of the revenue growth is prices. The chain index over three periods is compared with the direct one, and the difference shows the effect of the change of structure.
When to use it
It comes in handy when analyzing revenue growth, in price negotiations with suppliers and when assessing real growth of a group or channel. Do not use it if the assortment changes so much that there are hardly any comparable items: the index would be computed on a small share. Assumptions: items are comparable between periods, prices without VAT and without one-off discounts, quantities in the same units.
How to read the result
The main point: compare revenue growth with the price index. Growth of 13.2% with price growth of 11.8% means real growth is only about 1.2% by Fisher: the business has hardly grown, it has just become dearer. The gap between Paasche and Laspeyres (minus 0.7 points) shows how much buyers change the basket: a small gap means the structure is stable. If the volume index is negative, revenue is held by price, and that is a risk. The chain index against the direct one (a difference of 0.1 points) is needed to check whether a change of structure within the period distorts the result. Compute indices by groups to see where prices rose the most.
Common mistakes
The usual mistakes: comparing prices with and without VAT, including novelties without a base price, computing the price index from the group’s average price instead of separate items, mixing the volume index with revenue growth. For real growth take the volume index itself, not the difference “revenue minus prices” by eye.
What data is needed?
- Average prices and quantities sold by group in two or three periods.
- The same groups and units in all periods.
- New and discontinued groups with zero quantity.
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Laspeyres | Σ p1 × q0 ÷ Σ p0 × q0 |
| Paasche | Σ p1 × q1 ÷ Σ p0 × q1 |
| Fisher | √(Laspeyres × Paasche) |
| Volume | Laspeyres: Σ q1 × p0 ÷ Σ q0 × p0; Paasche: Σ q1 × p1 ÷ Σ q0 × p1 |
| Link | revenue 1 ÷ revenue 0 = Paasche price × Laspeyres volume |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Laspeyres price index
- 12.2 %Period 1 prices to period 0 at base-period quantities: the price growth of “the same basket”.
- Paasche price index
- 11.4 %The same at the compared period’s quantities.
- Fisher price index
- 11.8 %The geometric mean of Laspeyres and Paasche: closest to the “true” price growth.
- Revenue growth in roubles
- 13.2 %
- Volume growth by Laspeyres (real growth)
- 1.6 %Revenue growth at base-period prices: without the effect of prices.
- Volume growth by Paasche
- 0.9 %
- Volume growth by Fisher
- 1.2 %
- Paasche minus Laspeyres, p.p.
- −0.71Shows how buyers shift to groups that rise in price less.
- Chain Fisher index, period 0 → 2
- 21.7 %
- Direct Fisher index, period 0 → 2
- 21.6 %
- Chain minus direct, p.p.
- 0.1The drift of the chain index: it builds up when the basket structure changes a lot.
Data as a table
| Measure | Growth, % |
|---|---|
| Laspeyres | 12.2 |
| Paasche | 11.4 |
| Fisher | 11.8 |
| Revenue | 13.2 |
Data as a table
| Measure | Price growth |
|---|---|
| Outerwear | 19.2 |
| Jeans | 5.9 |
| Dresses | 6.5 |
| Knitwear | 16.7 |
| Footwear | 20.8 |
| Accessories | 5.9 |
Indices of period 0 → 1
| Measure | Prices | Volume |
|---|---|---|
| Laspeyres | 1.1215 | 1.0156 |
| Paasche | 1.1144 | 1.0092 |
| Fisher | 1.118 | 1.0124 |
| Revenue 1 ÷ revenue 0 | 1.1318 |
Revenue grew by 13.2 %: of it prices by Paasche 11.4 % and volume by Laspeyres 1.6 % (the product of the indices equals the revenue growth). Real volume growth at base-period prices is 1.6 %.
Groups must be comparable: a change of range inside a group looks like a price rise. The index does not separate a price rise from an improvement in the goods. For footwear, accessories and children’s count by your own groups and sizes and not by a mix.
Nuances and limits
- Comparing the average prices of the whole range: a change of structure looks like a price rise.
- Calling revenue growth in roubles business growth: part of it is prices.
- Leaving out new and discontinued groups: the index counts the wrong basket.