Syntha Lab RU

LFL and comparable sales (4-5-4 calendar)

LFL shows sales growth on a comparable base of stores and comparable periods, cleaned of openings, closings and relocations. It answers whether the business itself is growing or only the store count is, and decides whether to open new stores or fix existing ones.

Commerce and buying Retail Verified: 2026-11-13

Open interactively →

Why this document

Total revenue grows when stores open, even if every old store sells less. LFL removes that effect and shows the health of mature stores: traffic, conversion, average ticket. Investors and the board look at it because openings can be bought with money, while growth of existing stores cannot. The 4-5-4 calendar is needed to compare equal periods: without alignment a week with a holiday is compared with one without and shows a false rise or fall.

At a glance

What is this document and why is it needed?
LFL shows sales growth on a comparable base of stores and comparable periods, cleaned of openings, closings and relocations. It answers whether the business itself is growing or only the store count is, and decides whether to open new stores or fix existing ones.
Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
Retailer: finance and analytics, weekly and monthly; reported to investors and management. Brand: analyst, for own retail and for retail partners (sell-out); the calendar is aligned with partners.
What mistakes are the most common?
New stores are included in LFL → growth overstated → a base rule by trading time. Calendar months are compared instead of 4-5-4 weeks → weekdays do not match → compare by weeks with a 364-day shift. Relocation or space increase is not excluded → LFL reflects space → exclude or normalize by space.

For whom

Brand
A brand computes LFL for own stores and for partner sell-out; the base rules must be identical. For wholesale LFL shows whether the brand sells better on the partner shelf rather than shipments (sell-in), which depend on the partner count.
Retail
A retailer defines the comparable base by a rule (the store traded for the full comparison period and did not change space materially) and computes LFL for revenue, receipts, average basket and traffic. LFL and total growth are shown separately; their difference equals the contribution of new stores and closures.

What it consists of

The base rule

  • Retailer: A store is in the base if it traded for the whole comparison period and the preceding year; the threshold (often 12-13 months) is set by company policy.
  • Exclusions: closure, relocation and material change of space, refurbishment with a halt, force majeure; the rule is written down.
  • Retailer: The rule for a material space change: if store space changed by more than 15% (an editable threshold, in practice 10 to 20%), the store drops out of the comparable base for the change period; in the example store 6 with space up 40% drops out.
  • Retailer: Calendar: compare identical weeks shifted by 364 days (52 weeks) so that weekdays coincide; in a year with a 53rd week add it separately or shift the base, align holidays and sales by meaning, not by date. An omnichannel sale (ordered online, picked up in store) belongs to the pickup store for store LFL and to online for channel LFL: fix the rule once.

4-5-4 calendar

  • A 52-week year: 13-week quarters, months of 4-5-4 weeks (4-5-4-4-5-4-4-5-4-4-5-4); the comparison runs on the same weekdays, the period shifts by 364 days.
  • Retailer: Every 5-6 years a 53rd week is added; it is excluded from LFL or moved into the comparable base by a rule.
  • Brand: LFL on partner sell-out is computed on the same set of partners and weeks: in the example three partners give RUB 101.5 m against 96 a year earlier, LFL 5.7%; partner 2 falls (-7.7%), partner 3 grows (24.2%): total growth hides the divergence. A new partner is not in the comparable base.

Measures

  • Retailer: Revenue LFL = traffic LFL × conversion LFL × average basket LFL (a multiplicative decomposition).
  • Separately: price and volume (the “Revenue analysis: price, volume, mix” calculation).
  • Retailer: LFL in nominal and real terms: real LFL = (1 + nominal) ÷ (1 + price growth) − 1; at a nominal 5% and price growth of 3% (an assumption) the real growth is 2%. Show both so that growth on inflation is not taken for demand growth.
  • Retailer: Contribution to LFL by category and store: contribution = (Sales_current − Sales_base) ÷ Total base sales of the whole comparable group; contributions add up to the group LFL. It shows which category or store pulls the result up or down and where to direct purchasing and refurbishment.

Brand and retailer: what is computed differently

  • Retailer: retailer LFL is computed on comparable stores and weeks shifted by 364 days; opened, closed and rebuilt outlets drop out; the result is decomposed into traffic, conversion and check.

Brand: how the document differs and what to add

  • Brand: brand LFL is computed by wholesale partner and own channels: partner growth is sell-out, not shipment; without it LFL measures stock shifting.
  • Brand: comparable partners are those with a stable number of points and brand assortment; new shares and closed points go on a separate line.
  • Brand: brand site LFL is split into new and repeat customers: growth from advertising and growth in loyalty read differently.
  • Brand: marketplace LFL depends on positions and platform promotions: periods with the same promotion calendar are compared.
  • Brand: price in brand LFL changes by list and terms: real LFL is computed in units and at net price after discounts.
  • Brand: partner reports can be delayed: brand LFL is published after sell-out data arrives with a note on incompleteness.
  • Brand: a change in the partner’s assortment (brand models added or removed) is excluded from the comparable base: otherwise growth is tied to assortment, not demand.

Retailer: how the document differs and what to add

  • Retailer: retailer LFL includes stores that traded the full comparison period and did not change space by more than a set percentage.
  • Retailer: the 4-5-4 calendar aligns weeks and weekends: without it month comparisons give false deviations of 3 to 5%.

How to read the result and which decisions follow

  • LFL (5%) is below total revenue growth (15.7%): growth comes from expansion, not the existing network; decide whether to support openings until comparable stores grow.
  • Real LFL is negative while nominal is positive: price growth hides a fall in units; check traffic and conversion before purchasing decisions.
  • A store with negative LFL three periods in a row while neighborhood traffic grows: check assortment, merchandising and staff, then decide on refurbishment or closure.

Control checks

  • The base and current period contain the same stores (comparable sum 104.5 against RUB 99.5 million; LFL 5% = 104.5 ÷ 99.5 − 1, total growth with new and closed stores 15.7%).
  • The exclusions list (closure, relocation, refurbishment, new stores) is kept by date and reason; changing the rule recomputes history.
  • Typical traps: space changed but the store stayed in the base; calendar by weeks without alignment; price and units mixed.

Where the data comes from

Data sourceFields
POS and store registerSales by store and day, opening and closing dates, space, relocation history.
Company calendar4-5-4 weeks, a 364-day shift, holidays and promotion days.

How to build it step by step

  1. Step 1. Approve the base rule and the 4-5-4 calendar and publish them in the metrics policy.
  2. Retailer: Step 2. List stores by opening, closing and space-change dates.
  3. Retailer: Step 3. Select base stores for each period; exclude closed and relocated ones together with their prior year.
  4. Step 4. Compute the base sales now and in the comparable prior period (with the 364-day shift).
  5. Retailer: Step 5. Compute LFL and total growth; split the difference between new stores and closures.
  6. Retailer: Step 6. Decompose LFL into traffic, conversion and average basket.
  7. Step 7. Show price and volume separately to separate inflation from real growth.
  8. Retailer: Step 8. Publish the result with the base description and the number of stores in it.

Formulas

MeasureFormulasNote
LFLLFL, % = (Σ base sales now ÷ Σ sales of the same stores a year ago − 1) × 100The same stores and comparable days.
Total growthGrowth, % = (Σ all sales now ÷ Σ all sales a year ago − 1) × 100Includes new and closed stores.
Decomposition1 + LFL = (1 + traffic LFL) × (1 + conversion LFL) × (1 + basket LFL)Helps to see what drives growth.
Real LFLReal LFL ≈ (1 + LFL) ÷ (1 + price growth) − 1Shows volume growth net of inflation.
LFL decompositionLFL, % = (1 + Δtraffic) × (1 + Δconversion) × (1 + Δcheck) − 1Example: traffic −3%, conversion +4%, check +5% give (0.97 × 1.04 × 1.05 − 1) = +5.9%.

Formulas in notation

Like-for-like
LFL = Σ S_cur / Σ S_ly − 1
Sums only over comparable stores: open at least the policy period, without closures, relocations and space changes.
4-5-4 calendar
W_q = 4 + 5 + 4 = 13
Quarters of 13 weeks with the same number of weekend days make comparison consistent between years.

Worked example

A chain of six stores: LFL versus total growth, RUB m (an independent example, not tied to Models B and R)

StoreOpened (month)In LFL baseSales nowLast yearGrowth, %
Store 1 (long open)2022-03141.2388.4
Store 2 (long open)2023-09129.531.4−6.1
Store 3 (long open)2024-02133.830.112.3
Store 4 (opened 8 months ago)2026-03018.40
Store 5 (closed in September)2021-0506.215.9−61
Store 6 (relocated, space +40%)2020-1002719.538.5
Chain total156.1134.915.7
Comparable base104.599.55

The chain grew by 15.7% while LFL is 5%. The difference comes from new store 4 and relocated store 6, partly offset by the closure of store 5. Three stores are outside the base: opened less than a year ago, closed, and relocated with a space change. Management sees both figures with the base description.

Figures

Sales growth by store with a last-year base
Bar chart: Store 1 (long open) 8.4, Store 2 (long open) −6.1, Store 3 (long open) 12.3, Store 5 (closed in September) −61, Store 6 (relocated, space +40%) 38.5−80−60−40−2002040Store 1 (long open)Store 1 (long open)Growth vs last year: 8.48.4Store 2 (long open)Store 2 (long open)Growth vs last year: −6.1−6.1Store 3 (long open)Store 3 (long open)Growth vs last year: 12.312.3Store 5 (closed in September)Store 5 (closed inSeptember)Growth vs last year: −61−61Store 6 (relocated, space +40%)Store 6 (relocated,space +40%)Growth vs last year: 38.538.5%
Data as a table
MeasureGrowth vs last year
Store 1 (long open)8.4
Store 2 (long open)−6.1
Store 3 (long open)12.3
Store 5 (closed in September)−61
Store 6 (relocated, space +40%)38.5

Sales growth by store with a last-year base. Positive and negative growth in one network: comparable stores show the true dynamics, the rest are needed separately.

From last year’s revenue to the current: what LFL gives and what it does not
Waterfall: Last year 135, Comparable stores +5, New store +18.4, Closed store −9.7, Relocation, space +40% +7.5, Current year 156050100150200Last yearLast yearLast year: 135135Comparable storesComparable storesComparable stores: +5+5New storeNew storeNew store: +18.4+18.4Closed storeClosed storeClosed store: −9.7−9.7Relocation, space +40%Relocation, space+40%Relocation, space +40%: +7.5+7.5Current yearCurrent yearCurrent year: 156156RUB million
  • positive
  • negative
  • total
Data as a table
StepChangeLevel
Last year—135
Comparable stores+5140
New store+18.4158
Closed store−9.7149
Relocation, space +40%+7.5156
Current year—156

From last year’s revenue to the current: what LFL gives and what it does not. Network growth consists of comparable stores, a new one, a closed one and a relocated one: LFL shows only the first part.

Specifics by category

Apparel
LFL depends heavily on weather and the number of selling days on seasonal goods; compare by season groups, not only on the total.
Footwear
Weather and an early season start shift sales between months; quarterly LFL is more reliable than monthly. Basket growth is often driven by price rather than volume, so check LFL in pairs.
Accessories
Gift peaks (February, March, December) move with the holiday calendar; comparing under 4-5-4 and counting pre-holiday days is a must.
Kids
The school peak is tied to 1 September: compare August-September weeks by days to school; price growth and demography affect volume.
Men
Fewer seasonal jumps and a steadier LFL; sensitive to shifts in gift dates; a large share of repeat purchases amplifies the loyalty effect.
Women
Fashion swings more with weather and trend waves; growth often comes from lower prices; it helps to split LFL into full-price and sale.

Common mistakes

  • New stores are included in LFL → growth overstated → a base rule by trading time.
  • Calendar months are compared instead of 4-5-4 weeks → weekdays do not match → compare by weeks with a 364-day shift.
  • Relocation or space increase is not excluded → LFL reflects space → exclude or normalize by space.
  • LFL is confused with revenue growth → the contribution of new stores is hidden → show both figures.
  • Price is not separated from volume → inflation passes for demand growth → compute real LFL.
  • Real and nominal LFL are not separated → growth on price is taken for demand growth → show both and the contribution of traffic, conversion and check.
  • A store after space expansion stays in the comparable base → LFL is overstated → apply the space change threshold and take such a store out of the base for the period.

Russian specifics

  • Public Russian companies disclose LFL by their own method: figures of different companies cannot be compared without checking the base.
  • Revenue for LFL comes from POS and the books excluding VAT; the 22% VAT from 2026 must not distort the comparison with the year when the rate was 20%. Rule: Law 425-FZ of 28.11.2025: Federal Law of 28.11.2025 No. 425-FZ (amendments to parts one and two of the Tax Code; VAT 22%) (rule check not completed).

Open interactively →