Syntha Lab RU

Multi-buy: effective discount and basket

Converts “2 for 1”, “second at a discount”, “3 for 2” and a set into an effective discount per piece. Shows the basket margin before and after, how many pieces per basket are needed for the same margin and the average basket after.

Discount mechanics and the promotion calendar For whom: Category managers and marketers choosing a “two items together” mechanic.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What effective discount a format really gives and how many pieces per basket are needed for the margin not to fall.
What data is needed?
Price per piece excl. VAT and cost.
How to read the result?
At price 4000 and cost 1700 “2 for 1” gives an effective discount of 50% and cuts the basket margin from 2,300 to 600 (−1,700): to keep the margin you need 7.7 pieces per basket. “Second at 50% off” is a 25% discount, a margin gain of +300 and 1.8 pieces are enough. A set of 3 at 15% off gives +2,800: a mild discount and more pieces, so compare formats with the same k. Example on the default values: Best format by basket margin gain — RUB 2,800 · Set of 3 at 15% off; Effective discount of the best — 15%; Pieces per basket for the same margin — 1.4 · buyers take 3; Participant basket after (best format) — RUB 12,700.

Why and how to reason

A “2 for the price of 1” offer looks like a 50% discount, and “3 for 2” like 33%. But the interesting question is what happens to basket margin. Effective discount per piece = 1 − (paid ÷ taken): for a set of 3 pieces paid at 2.55 prices that is 1 − 2.55 ÷ 3 = 15%. Then compare basket margin before and after. Piece price RUB 4,000, cost 1,700, margin per piece 2,300, and before the offer the buyer takes 1 piece. “2 for 1”: revenue 4,000, cost of two 3,400, margin RUB 600, which is 1,700 less. “3 for 2”: 8,000 − 5,100 = 2,900, plus 600. A set of 3 at 15% off: 10,200 − 5,100 = 5,100, plus RUB 2,800 to basket margin. The buyer takes more pieces and this offsets the loss on price if the discount is not too deep.

When to use it

This is the calculation for the case when choosing an offer format or justifying why “2 for 1” is dangerous. Assumption: buyers who take the offer would have bought one piece (otherwise you give a discount to those who would have bought two anyway). It does not fit short-life goods (food), items not needed in pairs where returns rise, or leftovers where clearance matters. Check that the offer does not crowd out a basket that was already larger.

How to read the result

Look at basket margin gain for each format and at the number of pieces at which margin stays the same (1.35 with three in the set): if buyers take more, the format pays. A negative gain means the format cuts profit, like “2 for 1”. The average basket for all (RUB 8,050) accounts for the share of baskets with the offer (25%): growth of average basket and growth of margin are not the same. Compare both columns: revenue can rise while margin falls. Test the best format on a small share of baskets and compare the margin gain with the calculated one: buyers behave differently than in a table and the share taking the offer is often smaller than expected.

Common mistakes

Comparing formats by discount depth instead of basket margin; taking the share of baskets with the offer from a hypothesis; forgetting some buyers will return the second piece; ignoring different margins of pieces in a set. Better to test the offer on a small share. Do not enter the price of a set per piece: buyers pay for the whole set.

What data is needed?

  • Price per piece excl. VAT and cost.
  • How many pieces such a buyer took without the offer; average basket before; share of baskets with the offer.
  • Formats: pieces taken (k) and pieces paid for (p).

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Price per piece excl. VAT₽4,000Price excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026. The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant.
Unit cost excl. VAT₽1,700Unit cost excl. VAT.
Pieces in the basket without the offer for these buyerspcs1How many such a buyer would take without the offer.
Average basket before, excl. VAT₽6,500Average ticket excl. VAT before the offer, for a normal purchase.
Share of baskets taking the offer%25What share of tickets will, in your estimate, take the offer. There is no single standard: use past promotions.
Threshold: effective discount at which to warn%—The deepest effective discount at or above the threshold: a warning. Empty: no threshold, the color does not change. There is no single standard in Russia: enter your own.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Effective discount1 − p ÷ k
Basket margin afterp × price − k × cost
Basket margin beforepieces without the offer × (price − cost)
Pieces neededmargin before ÷ (price × p ÷ k − cost)
Basket afterbasket before + p × price − pieces without the offer × price

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Best format by basket margin gain
2,800 ₽ · Set of 3 at 15% off
Effective discount of the best
15 %
Pieces per basket for the same margin
1.4 · buyers take 3
Participant basket after (best format)
12,700 ₽
Average basket across all after
8,050 ₽ · was 6,500 ₽
Margin gain per 100 baskets
70,000 ₽
Deepest effective discount
50 % · 2 for 1

Formats on one set of economics

FormatEff. discountBasket revenueBasket marginMargin changePieces needed
2 for 150 %4,000 ₽600 ₽−1,700 ₽7.7
Second at 50% off25 %6,000 ₽2,600 ₽300 ₽1.8
3 for 233.3 %8,000 ₽2,900 ₽600 ₽2.4
Set of 3 at 15% off15 %10,200 ₽5,100 ₽2,800 ₽1.4

“2 for 1” cuts the basket margin by 1,700 ₽ provided the buyer takes 2 pcs.

The calculation assumes that every participant really takes k pieces. “2 for 1” is −50% on the pair, not “one free”: judge by the effective discount. Compare formats with the same k, otherwise the one with more pieces wins.

Nuances and limits

  • “2 for 1” is −50% on the pair, not “one free”.
  • A rise in pieces per basket without a rise in demand: the buyer takes extra and returns it.
  • Multi-buy breaks size stock: check that there is something to put in.
  • State the conditions in full in advertising (Art. 5 of Law 38-FZ), have a lawyer check the text.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →