What a rise in conversion and order value gives: effect on profit and the price of the change
Compares scenarios: a rise in conversion, a rise in order value and the possible rise of returns with it. Shows the profit of each scenario against the base and by how many percent conversion or order value must rise to pay for the monthly price of the change.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What a rise in conversion or order value gives allowing for returns and whether it pays for the change.
- What data is needed?
- Visits, conversion, cost of a visit, order value, returns, margin, variable costs.
- How to read the result?
- Base: 200,000 visits, conversion 1.5% (3,000 orders), an order contribution of 1,802.50, profit after traffic 3,007,500. Conversion +10% gives +540,750, order value +5% gives +277,875, order value +5% with returns +2 pp only +110,265, both rises +846,413. One point of returns costs 80,100 a month. To pay for a change of 300,000 a month, conversion must rise by 5.5% or order value by 5.4%. Example on the default values: Profit after traffic in the base case: RUB 3.01 million · 3,000 orders; Best scenario: profit gain: RUB 846,413 · Conversion +10%, order value +5%; Worst scenario: profit change: RUB 110,265 · Order value +5%, returns +2 pp; One point of returns costs a month: RUB 80,100. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
Improving a site costs money: development, tests, subscriptions. So the question is not “will conversion grow” but “will the profit gain be enough to pay back the cost of the change”. The calculation turns each idea into profit. Profit equals visits × conversion × order contribution − visits × visit cost. In the base: 200,000 × 1.5% = 3,000 orders, contribution 1,802.5, profit after traffic 3.01 million. A 10% rise in conversion gives 300 orders and 540,750. The scenario “basket plus five percent, returns plus two points” shows the trap: the basket grew but returns ate part of the effect. Payback of a change costing 300,000 a month requires conversion to rise 5.5% or basket 5.4%.
When to use it
It comes in handy before launching an improvement, a price test, a loyalty program or a delivery change: to choose what to do first and to see how much can be invested. Do not use it when the base numbers are unstable or conversion has not yet settled after a launch. Assumptions: scenario effects are independent, traffic and visit cost do not change due to the improvement, the cost of the change is constant per month.
How to read the result
Look at three numbers. First: the best and worst scenarios by profit gain (846 thousand and 110 thousand): the spread shows where to look for money. Second: how much one point of returns costs a month (80 thousand): if a scenario raises returns, check it against this price. Third: the conversion and basket growth needed to pay back the change: if it is higher than you can realistically get, the change will not pay back. Choose the idea whose realistic effect is well above the payback threshold. If payback needs a rise higher than your best test gives, postpone the change and look for a cheaper idea: the cost of change matters as much as the effect.
Common mistakes
Typical trap: entering a growth target as a fact, forgetting that a higher basket often lowers conversion, ignoring returns, mixing a monthly cost of change with a one-off. Do not take as effect a rise explained by the season: compare with a control group. Do not add scenario effects mechanically: a higher basket and higher conversion often compete, so test a combined scenario separately.
What data is needed?
- Visits, conversion, cost of a visit, order value, returns, margin, variable costs.
- Scenarios: shifts of conversion, order value, returns and the cost of a visit, and the monthly price of the change.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Visits for the period | visits | 200,000 | Sessions for the period (month). The example is illustrative. |
| Conversion of a visit to payment | % | 1.5 | There is no single standard for conversion and payback in Russia: count from your own analytics; the example values are illustrative. The example uses 1.5%: the same 200,000 visits in the “Site funnel” calculation give 6 × 45% × 55% = 1.485%, i.e. 2,970 orders against 3,000; the gap is rounding of the conversion, the example basis is the same. |
| Cost of a visit | ₽ | 12 | Advertising and traffic costs ÷ visits. The example is illustrative. |
| The monthly price of the change | ₽ | 300,000 | Optional. Development, testing, subscriptions: what the change costs per period. The example is illustrative. |
| Average order value excl. VAT | ₽ | 6,500 | Amount excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026 (law of 28.11.2025 No. 425-FZ, a guide as of 13.11.2026, check against the act text). The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant. |
| Returns | % | 25 | The share of what was ordered that came back. For clothing it is clearly higher than in other goods, but there is no standard: take your own history. The example value is illustrative. For footwear and dresses online the return share is usually above the store average (trying several sizes); for children’s it depends on the child’s height, accessories have no sizes. We give no guide without your own data: take your own statistics by category and channel. |
| Margin after cost | % | 52 | The share of the price excl. VAT after cost, before the variable costs below. |
| Variable costs in revenue | % | 14 | Commissions, acquiring, delivery to the customer: a share of revenue. |
| Return handling, per order | ₽ | 200 | Receiving, checking, repacking, return delivery per returned order. |
| Show a tornado for the four levers | No | Profit when each lever is moved up and down with the rest at the base: which lever moves profit the most. | |
| Step: traffic, conversion and order value | % | 10 | The relative move of each lever in both directions. The example is illustrative. |
| Step: returns | pp | 2 | The move of the return share in percentage points in both directions. The example is illustrative. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Profit | visits × conversion × contribution of an order − visits × cost of a visit |
| Payback of the change by conversion | price of the change ÷ (orders × contribution of an order) |
| By order value | price of the change ÷ (orders × order value × (1 − returns) × (margin − variable)) |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Profit after traffic in the base case
- 3.01 m ₽ · 3,000 orders
- Best scenario: profit gain
- 846,413 ₽ · Conversion +10%, order value +5%
- Worst scenario: profit change
- 110,265 ₽ · Order value +5%, returns +2 pp
- One point of returns costs a month
- 80,100 ₽The lost margin plus handling when returns rise by 1 p.p. at the base orders.
- Conversion must rise to pay for the change
- 5.5 %The relative rise of conversion with all else at the base.
- Order value must rise to pay for the change
- 5.4 %Without a rise in returns.
Scenarios against the base
| Scenario | Orders | Contribution of an order | Profit | Profit vs base | Vs base net of the price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | 3,000 | 1,803 ₽ | 3.01 m ₽ | — | — |
| Conversion +10% | 3,300 | 1,803 ₽ | 3.55 m ₽ | 540,750 ₽ | 240,750 ₽ |
| Order value +5% | 3,000 | 1,895 ₽ | 3.29 m ₽ | 277,875 ₽ | −22,125 ₽ |
| Order value +5%, returns +2 pp | 3,000 | 1,839 ₽ | 3.12 m ₽ | 110,265 ₽ | −189,735 ₽ |
| Conversion +10%, order value +5% | 3,300 | 1,895 ₽ | 3.85 m ₽ | 846,413 ₽ | 546,413 ₽ |
Conversion and order value are linked: a discount and free delivery raise conversion but cut order value and margin. Confirm the effect with a test on part of the traffic, not with a calculation.
Nuances and limits
- A rise in order value often pulls returns up: check on large orders.
- A discount raises conversion but cuts order value and margin: set them together.
- Confirm the effect with a test with a control group, not with a calculation.